[Dr Winston O Boogie jr]

Originally Posted by John_W

From NBC Sports dated May 8, 2015:

Got incriminating info on your phone? Refuse to provide it. Know things that would tend to point toward guilt? Refuse to talk, or at least refuse to answer certain questions.

Some fans think that’s OK, spouting off principles that apply only in the context of criminal prosecutions. But the right to remain silent, the presumption of innocence, the requirement of proof beyond a reasonable doubt, and all other Constitutional protections only matter when the outcome is prison or death.

For workplace investigations, the employer makes the rules. And when the employer expects cooperation, anything other than significant sanctions for failure to cooperate will invite others to refuse to cooperate.

During the various significant NFL investigations in recent years, cooperation has been consistent, and automatic. The Saints cooperated when the NFL was investigating the bounty case. The Ravens cooperated when the NFL was investigating the Ray Rice elevator video. The Dolphins cooperated when the NFL was investigating the bullying scandal — with the exception of trainer Kevin O’Neill, who expressed hostility to the investigation and later was fired.

Per multiple sources, Ravens employees automatically and without hesitation surrendered their cell phones for forensic examination that entailed a specific search for certain recipients and phrases. The procedure balanced the needs of the investigation with individual privacy rights.

Here, multiple individuals chose to extend their privacy rights so broadly that it interfered with their obligation to cooperate with their employer. Separate from whatever the Patriots did or didn’t do to the footballs, the failure to cooperate requires punishment, or others will do the same thing in the future.

The one glaring problem with this theory is that the NFL is not the employer. The Patriots are Tom Brady's employer. And as far as I know it was only one individual (Brady) that refuse to surrender his cell phone.

Why should he participate and cooperate with this kangaroo court? Maybe they investigated the officials he might cooperate. In all of those other case cited there were serious laws broken and/or rules infractions causing bodily harm and even death to people. This involves a ball being under inflated. And don't forget. ten balls were between 12.4 and 12.49, one ball was around 11.5 and the twelfth ball was t 12.5 exactly. We're talking about a ball being under inflated by a pound as opposed to coaches offering financial reward to players who injure opposing players or people being killed.

The problem here is the officials not doing their job properly and teams having to go against the rules to protect themselves from the referees.