[Justus]

Originally Posted by Polar Bear

"Model simulations are not scientific experiments" (not your words). You said that statement is "wrong" (your words). Your reply was wrong because all model simulations are not scientific experiments. Your later posts are still defending that statement.

you said to me "And you are the judge of what constitutes a valid scientific experiment because of what?" I made no such claim. I simply stated what should be obvious to anybody trained in modeling and/or the scientific method. All models are not scientific experiments.

Finally, I am much a subject matter expert in this discussion as you are. I'm a professional engineer trained in modeling and the scientific method. I think you feel the weakness of your rebuttal and have resorted to personal attack.

How long ago did you declare your participation in this thread over?

Sorry to be blunt, but...well you get the gist.

Well said!