[Challenger]

P

Originally Posted by Carl in Tampa

I am of two minds in this controversy.

1. In view of the accuracy in Voice To Text programs in modern cell phones, I find it difficult to believe that a Voice to Text projector in the classroom would not be a reasonable accommodation in the spirit of the ADA law. Not perfect perhaps, but reasonable. Most people who can hear do not catch every word that a speaker says; Voice to Text need not be better than that.

2. I would not be so negative about the Schwartz lawsuit if it simply asked for enforcement of the ADA law, but I understand that the plaintiffs are asking for payment to them of money for "damages" because they could not reach an agreement with the school operators.

3. For years I looked at the wheelchair ramp cuts in curbings as a curiosity. Then the day came that I was confined to a wheelchair. Now I realize how many obstacles there were in public areas to people in wheelchairs just a few years ago. I would probably be mostly homebound if it were not for the ADA laws. This is ironic because I was once the ADA compliance officer at my old Sheriff's Office, and worked to accommodate our disabled employees.

Here's a thought. Obtain a set of shooter's earmuffs and wear them all day, including going out to eat, going to a town square during the entertainment, and doing a little shopping. See how it is to order a meal when you can't hear the server. See how it is to not be able to hear the music while people are line dancing. See how you interact with salespeople whom you can't hear. How much TV will you watch when many of the programs are not Closed Captioned? How will you use a telephone? (Yes, I know about TTY phones. It can be done, but requires special equipment.)

Then you might better understand the situation of the hearing impaired.

CAUTION: I recommend against driving with the muffs on. It might even be illegal in Florida, and it certainly will increase your chances of being in a traffic crash. Also, when on foot have a friend with you who can hear who can help keep you from being run over when you cross streets.

Empathy and compassion are good emotions.

Points well made