There is one place I've seen a gator almost everytime I've gone there and the record was 5 at one time, but you have to be playing golf. At Cane Garden, Allamanda nine there is 2 connected ponds of water around holes 5, 6, 7 and 8 and there is a bridge at one point that you will cross over. I've seen as many as 5 in that area but that was a couple of years ago. Usually always see one, but last week when I played that nine I didn't see any. Those who live in the area of Liberty Park Neighborhood Pool and Allamanda Rec Center would probably know best. Here they are on the map.
Google Maps