First place suggested was The Rose Plantation, and there's where we ended up going...
It fit the description of what I was looking for perfectly. We hadn't been there before and it's definitely a bit different. The food was very good. It's a bit pricey, but there were several entrees for around $20, so it would be possible to eat there without going overboard. But it was our anniversary and we did go overboard...and enjoyed every penny of it!
The country atmosphere and setting may not be for everybody, but we enjoyed it very much.