[redwitch]

Sadly, lawn only has a thirty day warranty from date of closing, which means we are usually SOL. You can try talking to home warranty and explain all you did do since day one, including following contractor’s directions and recommendations. They might be willing to talk to the builder again. (Odds are that if you had hired Dean’s and gotten same results, contractor would have if you had hired Superior....)

The biggest issue going against you is the webworms. If Superior treated the lawn for insects, they should be responsible. You might actually have a case against them. (Webworms are pretty easy to spot — you’ll see small, white or light brown butterflies coming out of the grass every time you step on it. They can eat a lawn pretty quickly.) If you didn’t contract for lawn insecticides, you really have no recourse but to pay to resod yourself.