Quote:
Originally Posted by drr47
Before we take Mrs Palin out in the town square and stone her, we should check the facts .
The Smear
Mayor Sarah Palin Banned Books and Fired the Librarian
A librarian accused former Mayor Palin of banning a list of books in 1996 in a blog post at Librarian.net [2].
Others, including the New York Times [8], claimed that Mayor Palin fired librarian, Mary Ellen Baker (aka Mary Ellen Emmons), president of the Alaska Library Association at the time.
Time Magazine furthered the smear in their article, "Mayor Palin: A Rough Record" [6]. Also, Obama's own website is furthering this fraudulent list [7].
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Truth
Sarah Palin Never Fired The Librarian and The Banned Books List is Bogus [1]
The website where the original smear started, Librarian.Net [3], says the banned books list is bogus [2] and came from an old University list of banned books [5].
there appears to be no truth to the claim made by the commenter, and no further documentation or support for this has turned up.
The "banned books list" includes books that were published after 1996 (like Harry Potter).
The librarian, Mary Ellen Baker, was not fired but instead resigned [4] in 1999.
We ask Mr. Obama to denounce these smears and to remove them from his website immediately.
Sources:
[1] Main investigative work by Michelle Malkin
[2] Librarian.Net
[3] Librarian.Net Poster Jessamyn West
[4] Pacific Northwest Library Association Resignation announcement August 31, 1999
[5] Florida International
[6] Mayor Palin: A Rough Record Time Magazine article.
[7] Obama's website furthering the smear
[8] New York Times, Palin's Start in Alaska: Not Politics as Usual says "Ms. Plain fired Ms. Emmons shortly after taking office"
[9] Alaska Daily News article
|
(1) The link originally given here did not say Palin had a list of books nor did it say the librarian was fired. It did have direct quotes of people who heard Palin asking about the possibility of banning the books.
(2) I looked at the official Obama website and could find no mention of the book banning (doesn't mean it's not there, just means I couldn't find it). Could you please provide a direct link to where Obama is smearing Palin?
Where did you get your sources from? It really does help to provide links when claiming that things were said by other sources rather than just "Time Magazine," etc. Most of what you said sounds more like it was copied from a blog than something you actually wrote. I don't mind that you copied, but it is always nice to see the source.