[Trayderjoe]

Take out the history, as people, places, and conditions change over time, it is called evolution. Just because we did something one way in the past does not immediately validate the process as being the only/right way to do it now. We CHANGE. Remove the statistics from the discussion since any statistic appears to be challenged, even if the numbers are provided by "the boots on the ground". Set aside race as an argument as the the introduction of rascism immediately shuts down the conversation. Ignore the reports from the news media since there is a definite bias (interestingly there is another thread that talks about media bias).

So starting from the bare bones, what benefits does uncontrolled immigration offer that controlled immigration does not? I can't think of any myself. Can anyone else identify such benefits?

Should there not be a demonstrable list of such benefits, I would therefore propose that controlled immigration already provides the benefits that uncontrolled immigration supporters espouse.