Chels, there is no comparison to the issues you suggest. It is quite simple. The Bush "bill" you refer to calls for the use of armed forces, ie. our military, under exigent circumstances in a domestic law enforcement role.

Obama, in his own words if you listen to the clip I posted in the original post, quite expressly calls for a full time civilian national police. I am not an advocate of either ,but, Obama's concept of a national police is far more sinister for largely the reasons pointed out by 12ridehd.