It looks fine to me. A modest home with the addition blended in in the same style. Obviously had a big enough corner lot to do this. One shouldn't have to buy a McMansion aka premier home to get the garage space they need. People don't need to be so judgmental. I've seen some ugly homes in ugly colors, but I don't go posting about it. That would just be rude. More power to this guy who dared to do something a little different yet followed the rules. Too bad his neighbors aren't very nice. They just need to get over themselves and chill out.
Yes, the Villages is very cookie cutter. Even with different floor plans, many homes look the exact same on the front façade.