For the 10 years I lived in The Villages I had a roll-up from Michelle's Screens. I love it functionally and especially aesthetically. The folks that bought our home still use it so that makes 14 years and it still works perfectly and looks great.
Now we have a new home and ordered another one about 3 months ago (takes about 2 or 3 weeks with measurements and ordering the color you want) but we depend on it and love the remote control - The garage gets so hot without it.
The cons, you need to put it up when it rains and if there's a power outage you need to wait until the power is back on. Only one power outage in 15 years and that was for like an hour so that's really not an issue.
Call Michelles Hideaway Screens -
Garage Screens | Retractable Screens | Michele's Hide-Away Screens (tell 'em Carl sent ya 😜) super nice and super professional.
Good luck and either way, it's a must in Florida! Enjoy whatever you decide upon. God Bless.