Talk of The Villages Florida - View Single Post - Would YOU fly on the Boeing 737MAX- JUST re-certified by FAA?
View Single Post
 
Old 11-30-2020, 11:39 AM
Dilligas Dilligas is offline
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2013
Posts: 414
Thanks: 0
Thanked 342 Times in 166 Posts
Default Boeing max design flaws

What most are missing is the forest for the trees. Yes the MCAS pushed the planes into nose dive and crash.....however, the MCAS was installed to correct a major design flaw. Boeing was making and selling a lot of 737s, then as engines became bigger and stronger, instead of redesigning a different plane, they simply addeed the oversize engine to the basically current 737. Because of the weight of the engine, they had to shift the engine forward of the wings. That move allowed the plane to become unbalanced in flight, in which the nose began to rise to a point of possible stall. To conteract that rise, they installed MCAS and software to bring the nose back down. Boeing is a major important company to USA economy....however, by not notifying pilots of the MCAS and training them for it's malfunctioning, Boeing is responsible, and those who covered the problem should be prosecuted. The fact that the engineers determined the life of 737 Max could have 13 fatal crashes is meaningless without the additional information of 1) how many Maxs in service, 2) how many flight hours, 3) how often service is required, $) how does the 13/total Maxs compare to other models/crashes....etc. There are so many Maxs in service and production, the 13 becomes an insignificant fact. It is a published fact that commercial flying is safer than walking, driving, trains, or boats.
If Boeing rectified the Max problem with simply software....there is still a problem. If Boeing has revised the design of the engine mount and can retrofit existing planes, and FAA approves, then it would be safe.