Not sure if anyone posted this, I read all the post on page 1 and some others following but a simple option to look at is upgrading the garage door opener to use wireless communication with a program on yours and your spouse’s smartphone. Everyone carries a cell phone these days wherever they go. No remotes to steal and simple, get home, pull your cell phone out and press a few buttons on your phone and garage door opens. Problem solved. See more info here:
Retrofit Your Garage Door Openers to Work With Wi-Fi | Family Handyman