You might find more Progressive ASI customers having increases, I switched in 2018 from American Integrity because they had almost doubled my CYV in 8 years. I asked about ASI with my Villages Insurance agent and she said, they won't include sink holes in their policy. That might mean those onboard with that clause will see them trying to dump you or at least raise your premiums.
American Integrity had a complaints here on this forum about not paying claims, or dragging their feet, that combined with my rates jumping five times in eight years made me change. My Villages agent suggested Coastal Insurance and it was $420 cheaper than AI and the second year it did go up but only about $50.
Cabrillo Coastal General Insurance Agency – Residential property insurance for hurricane-exposed areas.