The other day, I posted to a year old thread. A member of TOTV wrote "for some unknown reason, Starflyte has chosen to revive a year old thread rather than open a new one." Or something like that. She added that was just her 2 cents worth, what ever that's worth.
Not exact quotes, but close. It is like politics- everyone will not agree with everyone else.
I personally prefer for threads to be revived because it keeps all the posts in one group, but if a new thread is opened, I can search myself for the older ones.