Quote:
Originally Posted by positiveinlife
1. Review of sceptical papers
In supplementary table 1 we present the full list of all 31 sceptical papers we found in our dataset. An in-depth evaluation of their merits is outside the scope of this paper, and could be an interesting area for further work.
So this paper put no effort into looking into the counter data that exist just summarily dismissing it. Hmmmm.
|
So, you dismiss their paper without reviewing it, while pointing out that they provided references to contrary positions and simply stated reviewing those are outside the scope of our paper.
Seems like you are doing the same you blame them for.