Bush's idea was and still is good. He was talking about putting just a small percentage of the 15% that we contribute with the employer to SS. The market goes up and down but it has steadily risen alot in the last 15 years or so. If the SS collapses under the weight of 78 million baby boomers, the money that was put in your private account will still be there.
But in your case, Cologal.....I bet if Obama suggested it or anyone with a "D" after his name suggested it....you would think it was a great idea...right?