In my field, the peer review process is pretty substantial. You can take a pretty good guess who will be reviewing your paper. They will typically be people working in the same area.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mntlblok
Rarely do I achieve such a win after such a screw-up! A banner day. :-)
Fascinating to learn that retractions are rare in your field. They are most definitely not in the areas of biology that I've had reason to follow. It's been most disheartening. But, it *has* caused me to learn a good bit more about proteins than I ever thought I'd have bothered with. :-)
I had some minor direct involvement in this situation. Just a moment... Learned more than I wanted to about how the world works. :-(
Do you happen to have easy access to that post of yours on the feedback loops? It was better than anything I've read or seen since on the subject. TIA |