Talk of The Villages Florida - View Single Post - Thoughts or Ideas on Second Home... Financial or Tax Thoughts
View Single Post
 
Old 02-18-2025, 03:44 PM
DrMack's Avatar
DrMack DrMack is offline
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2023
Location: Dabney
Posts: 179
Thanks: 312
Thanked 139 Times in 66 Posts
Default First Hand Experience

Quote:
Originally Posted by MNViking View Post
Good morning, I am seeking information from those who are more seasoned and experienced than myself in this area. Allow me to paint the scenario, and if interested I would value input, and thoughts or considerations I may have not looked into or even thought of.

Situation: Age 55, with a wife of 42. Looking to purchase in the Villages and do not want to spend more than $300k for a home down there. This would be a second home, and used as such, not sure of renting it out yet as the distance of caring for and who to watch over it may/may not be an issue. That being said, it will eventually be our retirement home, and visits until that time, or we are allowed to work from our current jobs and office down there. That is neither here nor there for the conversation. (Unless something is valuable I should know.)

I owe less than $105k on current home.
I have roughly $150K sitting fairly liquid to use on a purchase of the home down there to minimize the mortgage loan.

Questions and thoughts I am seeking are:

Should I pay off the current home, and not have the mortgage, and take out the full mortgage on the future retirement home and put at least 20% down to avoid PMI on that home?

Do I not pay off the current home, and then put $100k+ on the down payment on the future retirement home? Keeping roughly $40k+ in a money market for any boo-boos that may occur for a rainy day fund?

I am trying to ascertain the info to help make a better education decision for the finances, and since I am not in that industry, I don't know what I don't know. Therefore the questions may not be right?

Feel free to ask questions and I will check back and respond. What decisions did you all make, or what are the thoughts on what is best?

I appreciate the information?
I believe you have thoughts that you will earn money on a rental here in the Villages. I would hope so, but doubt it.

From our own personal experience we purchased a home a couple years ago in Dabney. I can tell you for certain we have lost money on the build. If we sold today, we might almost get 550 k or about what we paid for the home in early. 2023. The thing is we have since paid property taxes annually as well as all the other bills mentioned and have done some improvements. If we sold today we would lose all that and a real estate commission. Buying for profit is a fool’s errand.
__________________
I can’t golf, but I can sail


Fairfax VA
Stamford CT
Rye NH
Provincetown MA