Talk of The Villages Florida - View Single Post - What makes The Villages homes worth 150K more?
View Single Post
 
Old 06-03-2025, 01:28 PM
jimmyinvillages jimmyinvillages is offline
Junior Member
Join Date: May 2025
Posts: 16
Thanks: 1
Thanked 17 Times in 9 Posts
Default Middleton vs. The Villages

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ruger2506 View Post
Edited: Like the title says. I wonder what makes the relatively same house across an imaginary line worth 50-150K more (depends on inner lot vs woods/lake lot). If you do a side by side comparison of homes in The Villages to comparable homes just across the street in Middleton, there seems to be a substantial price difference. Is it the amenities? The perceived status?

Whatever it is, I'm crossing my fingers "it" drags up the Middleton home prices with it.
I had the most up front, honest sales rep at the Villages and through our conversations tailored it to this:
-Middleton is a lot cheaper yes, for the same build quality product
-The Villages proper gives you access to all the clubs/amenities - not importantly, this doesn't just mean Golf. Let's ignore all the golf options for a second. Maybe you want to join the Corvette Club. Or the Softball Club. Especially for single retirees wanting to meet people these clubs / rec centers are clutch.
-Middleton prices won't come up to Villages prices (sorry Ruger) because of the above point
-Middleton will have a great downtown (though it may take 1-2 years to feel it) and Eastport is super close. Those living in Middleton can thus go to downtown Middleton and/or Eastport for restaurants/things to do/nice walks, etc. + if they want go to the other Town Squares further up north.

Middleton has a great community of people/neighbors from what I'm hearing and you can have a great life there. Just depends on your individual situation. If you care more about the town squares and have a spouse/good friends in the area already it's fine. If you're a single retiree and don't know anyone paying more to be in the Villages ecosystem could make sense.