Talk of The Villages Florida - View Single Post - Indian Air plane crash
View Single Post
 
Old 06-13-2025, 05:14 PM
BrianL99 BrianL99 is offline
Sage
Join Date: Dec 2021
Posts: 3,632
Thanks: 298
Thanked 3,513 Times in 1,400 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bodrum View Post
The 787 as well as all modern airplanes have a warning system that goes off when the throttles are advanced, and the takeoff configurations are incorrect
Quote:
Originally Posted by idlewild View Post
From what I have observed and read, this cause of the crash was most likely due to pilot error. Specifically, the first officer should have retracked the landing gear at about 50 feet following what appeared to be a normal routine takeoff. Instead, he/she most likely mistakenly retracted the flaps which lead to the loss of lift at the time when the landing gear should have normally been retracted. The pilot probably did not know this had happened and was unable to recover in time.

Nothing suggests power failure either due to a bird strike or engine failure nor do I think the flaps were set improperly (5%) for takeoff. Instead, I sadly believe it was due to the flaps being mistakenly retracted prematurely instead of the landing gear which lead to the loss of lift shortly after takeoff.
Quote:
Originally Posted by kcrazorbackfan View Post
Flaps are used 100% of the time when an airliner takes off; the flaps on that flight were not down, which WOULD have provided additional lift, and the landing gear were still down, which ADDED a lot of additional drag. Something went bad wrong with that flight.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Velvet View Post
You are not the first one to make this observation. People I know agree with this. We shall see if this was the cause and whether the cause was pilot or mechanical.
Quote:
Originally Posted by talonip View Post
I was an airline pilot for 33 years and military for over 20. If the flaps or trims and other things were not set for takeoff correctly there are
very loud warnings in the cockpit when throttles are advanced for takeoff. Annoying WARNINGS.
Let the NTSB or Indian equivalent get the FDR and voice recorders and we will eventually get to the truth

Thank you, finally someone with a clue.

"It was the pilot's fault because I saw a video and his flaps weren't down" ? Why do people who don't have a clue how to fly an airplane, post such things? It boggles my mind.

You surely have way more logged time than me, but anyone who flies has heard plenty of "stupid pilot tricks". Fortunately, today's planes of that sort, make it unlikely a pilot is going to make a stupid mistake.

Anything is possible, but I doubt the investigation is going to show the Pilot screwed up, all by himself.
__________________
"God made me and gave me the right to remain silent, but not the ability." Sen John Kennedy (R-La)
" ... and that Norm, is why some folks always feel smarter, when they sign onto TOTV after a few beers" adapted from Cliff Claven, 1/18/90