[manaboutown]

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby

Not sure what numbers you're looking at, but here's mine (rounded):

Between my payroll deduction and employer contribution, I've paid in just under $60,000 in social security taxes.

I'm getting $40 more per month in social security payments than I did when I started getting them, just 1.5 years ago. I anticipate around $20 more per month for 2026. Regardless:

At the current total of my social security checks, I will have received 100% of what I put in, and what my employer put in, by the 7th year of collecting social security checks. I won't even be 70 years old yet, at that point, because I started getting them when I was 62.

This means that all the checks I receive after I turn 70, will be "in addition" to what I/my employer paid in. If I live to be 90, that'll mean 100% of what I get post 70-years-old will be "profit." I dunno - seems like a pretty good deal to me. Get a 100% return on your initial investment in 7 years after the start of the payout, and then keep getting steady monthly checks for the next 20 (or more) years.

This narrative totally ignores the time value of money and the interest, dividends and capital gains one can obtain over the years. It is similar to pitches I used to hear from whole life insurance salesmen 50 years ago.