Mama mia...you guys are VERY opinionated, but I guess that's ok in a forum format.
I personally, would be very excited to have a Carvel Ice Cream Store in the Villages or near the Villages. COME ON DOWWWWWWWWWWN! I remember the Cookie Puss and the Fudgie the Whale. Those fresh crunchies in the middle are to DIE for. Yes, I would definitely support Carvel because I absolutely love the quality and creaminess of the ice cream. Good customer Service is mandatory and if you have good and friendly customer service that would bend over backwards for you, THAT is THE key. The ice cream cakes are simply FUN and have excellent quality. I have always been impressed with them. If customer service is good, the owners will make and customize those cakes to one's specifications and the grandchildren will squeal with delight. As to answer your question, Yes, I would prefer ordering from a private person vs. a supermarket. I would prefer it customized. Oh yes...COME ON DOWN you guys!! You would have my vote! Would I buy from someone else? Of course from time to time...but, A CARVEL is a must because of the quality.
And yes, I have gone to DQ for may years. But, I am more impressed with Carvel. Very creamy and not as runny as DQ. I think Carvel ice cream would hold up 20 seconds longer in the heat than DQ. DQ is a bit runny. If I choose to have an ice cream..I don't want to think DIET. I simply just WANT IT. Thanks for posing the question.