I'll try to explain this to you one more time Cologal. Saratogaman said in response to me; basically ("You don't think Scalia, Thomas, Roberts or Alito are judicial activists; give me a break!!").

So; I said "Name one of their rulings that makes new law instead of interpretation"; in so many words.

No one has come up with a ruling crafted by any of them to dispute me and the case you noted, although I think it still is not making new law, is not a ruling by the 4 named justices.

I hope this clears this up for you. Not funny anymore, huh?