We just got back from High Five and it was WON-DER-FUL! The place was packed, all the way out the door. Probably smarter to go by golf cart and sit in it to eat outside.
I can't say it takes the place of Brewster's for me, but all flavors are non-fat yogurt, which DO NOT taste non-fat. And there are a ton of toppings and syrups to choose from. We'll definitely be going back there again and again.
Yummmmmmmmmm!