[zcaveman]

I have both. The two extra bedrooms are a library/craft room and the other bedroom is my man-cave/computer room.

I have an air mattress for guests that they can put down in the library.

ilovetv is right. Sometimes you need the extra bedroom just as a place to chill out so if I had to make a choice I would go with the extra bedroom.

However, keep in mind that many people have moved to a new house because they ended up wanting/needing a two car garage.

Z