I had rotator cuff surgery on left shoulder May '09. Had a .5 inch tear requiring 6 stitches and 6 months of re-hab. Anyway, had it diagnosed in The Villages by Dr. Isaac Mitchell at Tri-County Ortho. He was spot on with his diagnosis of my physical presentation and MRI I had done in The Villages.
My Indiana Doc did the surgery and it was just as Dr. Mitchell had said it would be... including the re-hab time.
Dr. Mitchell has an impressive background from John Hopkins that you can check out if interested.
http://www.tricountyortho.com/isaac-l-mitchell.html