So, as I understand what BTK is saying, it makes NO DIFFERENCE as to the correctness of the issue but only a WHAT IF it might be true.

Well, that is about the same as stating your belief that growing pineapples in the winter in Minnesota is ideal. Everyone knows that Minnesota is not the ideal place to grow pineapples in the winter but WHAT IF it were true?

Exact same logic that BTK used and just wanted to "hypothesize".