We chose Sanibel, because we decided to build. There didn't seem to be a lot of difference between new and preowned, so we decided to build what we wanted. We are very glad we did. The area is great, the people are super friendly. However, we have not been anywhere in the Villages where they have not been super friendly, so is you want new, build, if you want prowned look in any Village as they are all fantastic. The bottom line is enjoy your life no matter which Village you are in.