We've had directtv for well over 10 years and primarily have it because of the NFL package which is only available on directtv. Since I am a St. Louis Rams fan thats really the only way I can watch my Rams. I have been happy with directtv. We have 3 directtv dvr's, 2 being high def. Yes, sometimes in very rainy weather or with lightning you may lose the signal but we have so much saved on the dvrs that we just go to a saved program. I have comcast for my internet and have had it ever since we moved here 7 years ago. I have no problems with comcast but I believe others have. My computers are in another room other than the tv rooms. My dish in the backyard faces southwest.
As to cost I think I'm paying a lot for all these services. Oh well, I don't really want to leave anything for my sons when I go. Might as well enjoy life to the fullest now.
John