I only looked at new. IMHO: The Club has a better oil system. It uses an oil pump and filter. The Yamaha uses a "slinger" for the oil. (Your car has an oil pump, your lawn mower has a "slinger"). I think both carts are quiet compared to the "older" gas cart. I did not smell fumes with either cart. I ended up buying a new Yamaha from a dealer in Kentucky and saved about $2k. The club has a better oil system but did not like the headlights. Seems there are more Yamahas here, maybe better resale. Club seems to have more "after market" add ons available. If you can, wait until you have your garage cleared out and take measurements. A 4 seater can add 12"- 24" to the length. Take your time, test drive and shop around .
