View Full Version : Dr Nguyen - knee replacement - just had it done
784caroline
12-22-2014, 09:55 AM
I cannot speak highly enough about the skills of Dr Nguyen and his unique process of doing full knee replacement surgery. I had it done thursday (12/18) 1pm in Florida Hospital Altamonte Springs. Great staff, private room and very happy with the hospital itself. By 10pm, the night of surgery, I had my first PT and was walking (with walker) 600 ft. Friday I walked 1200 ft and was released from the hospital. Prior to release you do some group PT and its practical stuff...how to get in and out of a car, how to walk stairs, plus other exercises you should be doing. Normally after release, he would have sent me directly to outpatient PT but because of the holiday schedules I am doing home care first. It has been great. Knee flex the night of surgery was 101 degrees, friday 103, by sunday it was already 110 with a goal of between 130-135 degrees. Pain level has been minimal and moreso when I try to bend the knee to get flex. This is critical in your rebhab. Today 4 days after sugery I am pretty much off the walker and walking (slowly) on my own....no pain...but still on some pain meds. Biggest adjustment is trying to get greater knee flex and moreso training your mind to accept the fact that you have an artifical knee and you must learn to "trust" it.
Just compare what I have just stated above from first hand experience, to other local surgeons who perform this operation the normal or routine way over the knee cap. For the most part their patients are in (heavy) pain and discomfort for 2-3 weeks before they can start walking.
Dr Nguyen's procedures and protocols will definitely be the future of full knee replacements . I could not be more pleased. If you are considering Dr Nguyen, be preapred to wait for teh initial appointment and then the waiting list once approved by him for surgery is approx 6 months out.
Any questions, just ask!!
pbkmaine
12-22-2014, 10:22 AM
What is different about the way he does it?
massapequa girl
12-22-2014, 10:27 AM
I need a replacement as well, Dr. Kerina wants to do a partial, everyone says Dr. Nguyen is the best, but I'm not sure anymore. appreciate you input if you can call me 753 4028..I am scared to death to have it done!
784caroline
12-22-2014, 11:03 AM
What is different about the way he does it?
The primary difference is that almost all doctors make the incision over the knee cap cutting all ligaments and muscle along the way and then stitching it up after the knee is replaced. THis is very painful and the time to recover and start walking is delayed. DR Nguyen uses the same prostesis knee as other Drs (Stryker), but he cuts the the side of the knee allowing him to simply move aside the ligaments and muscles. This procedure dramatically reduces the amount of pain the patient is in and allows much better and quicker recovery time to walk. He is the ONLY Dr in the States and worldwise to use this procedure and he is currently tryng to patten the procedure for use by other Surgeons.
CFrance
12-22-2014, 11:05 AM
I am bookmarking this thread. Thanks for the information, and merry Christmas and a speedy recovery to you, 784caroline!
Villages Kahuna
12-22-2014, 11:29 AM
How about a quick name, address and phone number?
The Mountaineer
12-22-2014, 11:47 AM
Welcome to the 300,000 a year who get knee replacements.
Since I got my store-bought knee nearly a decade ago, it was the cut and replace procedure you mentioned. Oh, yes, there was a LOT of pain for weeks, including 2 in a rehab place. But the results have been magnificent, other than it being tricky to get in and out of cars and requiring an aisle seat at concerts so that I can stick my right leg out into the aisle. I walk up to 3 miles a day when we travel to 52 countries and 43 states, and I'm 82 years old. I go to the Cuyahoga Falls Natatorium with the free Medicare Silver Sneakers program 3 times a week to maintain the knee. It gets stiff if I don't flex it every 15 to 30 minutes.
If I have to do the left knee someday, I'll check into the later procedure. Medicine is always coming up with better ways to do things.
Polar Bear
12-22-2014, 01:24 PM
Nothing against Dr. Nguyen at all, but I've been very pleased with my TKR done by Dr. Duke early this year. I had minimal pain, was out of the hospital on the second day, and up and around almost immediately. I'm convinced that success of the replacement (assuming the doctor does a good job of course) is almost totally dependent on the patient's commitment to the therapy.
784caroline
12-22-2014, 04:02 PM
How about a quick name, address and phone number?
Dr Steve Nguyen
Optimotion Orthopedics
1640 N Maitland Ave
Maitland, Fl 32751
407-355-3120
He also has office hours near The Villages on Fridays just off Rolling Acres Rd across from Home Depot. However, all appointments need to go through his maitland Office.
villages07
12-22-2014, 04:13 PM
784... Congrats on getting that pesky knee fixed. Perhaps tennis is back in your future?
I have had both knees replaced by Dr Kerina...6 and 3 years ago. I did attend dr Nguyens seminar before my second TKR and it was intriguing. Given my success with Kerina I stayed with him but would have used Nguyen otherwise. I have heard similar success stories as yours from other Nguyen patients. The best thing is that you did it and can get back to the activities you enjoy. Good luck with the rehab.
texasfal
12-22-2014, 06:52 PM
My husband had a knee replacement by Dr. Nguyen on 5/22. He did so well he was back playing division 1 softball in August. Absolutely no pain, in fact he took only 1pain pill and that was only because the PT requested that he do so. I can't praise Dr. Nguyen enough.
kcrazorbackfan
12-22-2014, 08:22 PM
The primary difference is that almost all doctors make the incision over the knee cap cutting all ligaments and muscle along the way and then stitching it up after the knee is replaced. THis is very painful and the time to recover and start walking is delayed. DR Nguyen uses the same prostesis knee as other Drs (Stryker), but he cuts the the side of the knee allowing him to simply move aside the ligaments and muscles. This procedure dramatically reduces the amount of pain the patient is in and allows much better and quicker recovery time to walk. He is the ONLY Dr in the States and worldwise to use this procedure and he is currently tryng to patten the procedure for use by other Surgeons.
Actually, there are 8 Orthopedic Surgeons in the US now using this method; my wife's surgeon in KC (Dr. David Paul) is now using it. It is the way to go if a person needs knee replacement.
slipcovers
12-23-2014, 05:11 PM
This procedure is done by several ortho surgeons in the US. It involves robotic navigation and 3D images, computer assisted. Dr Nguyen was trained by Stryker to use this minimal invasion TKR. The hospitals invest millions for the robotic navigation system, not Dr Nguyen. There are other companies that have developed robotic navigation, Maco and Praxim are two. This procedure is not for everyone, your doctor will tell you if you are a candidate.
Buckeyephan
12-23-2014, 07:12 PM
I called for an appt. in August and couldn't get one until January. At that time, they were scheduling surgeries for March but my time would not happen until after I saw him. Ridiculous! That would mean almost a year from first call to surgery. Dr. Duke did my right knee on Dec. 8. So far, things are great.
kcrazorbackfan
12-23-2014, 09:26 PM
I called for an appt. in August and couldn't get one until January. At that time, they were scheduling surgeries for March but my time would not happen until after I saw him. Ridiculous! That would mean almost a year from first call to surgery. Dr. Duke did my right knee on Dec. 8. So far, things are great.
That length of time is typical for the great Ortho. Doc's that are in high demand; it was the same way with my shoulder Doc in KC; he's the best in the Midwest at what he does.
PaPaLarry
12-25-2014, 11:34 AM
Nothing against Dr. Nguyen at all, but I've been very pleased with my TKR done by Dr. Duke early this year. I had minimal pain, was out of the hospital on the second day, and up and around almost immediately. I'm convinced that success of the replacement (assuming the doctor does a good job of course) is almost totally dependent on the patient's commitment to the therapy.
I'll second that!!!!
VT2TV
12-25-2014, 11:23 PM
I saw Dr Nguyen's PA on Dec. 8th, and am on the schedule for May 28th. One thing that has somewhat helped me is an injection of Syn-Visc done by a different doctor. It does not take the pain away, but i think it is actually helping some.
ziggie
12-26-2014, 12:34 PM
Was this procedure covered by ins.? how much did it end up costing you?
VT2TV
12-28-2014, 12:55 AM
Was this procedure covered by ins.? how much did it end up costing you?
Are you talking about the knee replacement or the injection?
paulascorpio
12-28-2014, 10:09 PM
I had my knee replacement by Dr Duke in July 2014. The lower part of my knee is still numb from cutting the muscles and nerves. Some days it still hurts to stand long times. I have a friend that went to Dr Nguyen with far greater success. I was in a local rehab with a lot of Nguyen patients. They were far more progressed than I was since my muscles/nerves were cut.
I am seeing Nguyen in March for my other knee. Dr Duke is a great surgeon but technology changes and it seems that Nguyen's patients are much quicker to recover.
Polar Bear
12-28-2014, 11:29 PM
I had my knee replacement by Dr Duke in July 2014. The lower part of my knee is still numb from cutting the muscles and nerves. Some days it still hurts to stand long times. I have a friend that went to Dr Nguyen with far greater success. I was in a local rehab with a lot of Nguyen patients. They were far more progressed than I was since my muscles/nerves were cut.
I am seeing Nguyen in March for my other knee. Dr Duke is a great surgeon but technology changes and it seems that Nguyen's patients are much quicker to recover.
Sorry to hear that. With all due respect, I appear to have had much better results with Dr. Duke. I have no numbness and recovery was surpassingly quick.
ziggie
12-29-2014, 08:20 AM
Are you talking about the knee replacement or the injection?
knee replacement
hoopsterdad
12-29-2014, 08:52 AM
several factors are involved in the replacement. one is a skilled surgeon, mine was dr. duke, who does not cut muscle, tendons, or ligaments, i am not overweight, age, i was 60 when i had the surgery, i trained hard for the surgery, strength, worked hard after in rehab at home, walker for one day, cane for two weeks, golfing from forward tees at 6 weeks, full swings at 12 weeks, now, one year later, ran and walked a mini marathon, do a workout on the elliptical than is second to none. very happy. you are only going to get out of the replacement what you want. i want all that i can get out of that.
MoeVonB61
12-29-2014, 09:07 AM
Have a neighbor that says the same about Dr. Nguyen....and BTW, I would feel far more confident about the outcome with any surgery at Florida Hospital Altamonte (or Orlando) or even Florida Hospital Waterman.
slipcovers
12-29-2014, 11:05 AM
several factors are involved in the replacement. one is a skilled surgeon, mine was dr. duke, who does not cut muscle, tendons, or ligaments, i am not overweight, age, i was 60 when i had the surgery, i trained hard for the surgery, strength, worked hard after in rehab at home, walker for one day, cane for two weeks, golfing from forward tees at 6 weeks, full swings at 12 weeks, now, one year later, ran and walked a mini marathon, do a workout on the elliptical than is second to none. very happy. you are only going to get out of the replacement what you want. i want all that i can get out of that.
I totally agree, the skilled surgeon is key, with either conventional or robotic TKR. Both surgeries muscle, tendons and ligaments are cut. Excess weight in the area requires a larger incision, as with all surgery. Physical condition before surgery will make it much easier with PT after. Dedication to PT is what makes the difference if you just want to be pain free or be active, sports, dancing, golfing or long walks. Stationary bike, to me, was a necessity to loosen up the leg before PT. It is no walk in the park and not entirely up to the surgeon, you have to give 100%.
The flex the OP is referring to is the passive motion machine, only moves the leg up and down, no big deal. The worse part is yet to come, flexing backward. Bring the heal of the foot back and up to the butt. That is the real flex.
lvlwallach
12-29-2014, 05:32 PM
There is no comparison with the results you will get with Dr. Nguyen. I had a full knee replacement nine years ago. My husband had the surgery on Sept. 19th with Dr. Nguyen and we both can tell you there is a world of difference. He was walking 1000 steps the same evening as surgery (which was late in the day) and put down the walker in two days. The outpatient therapy was 3 weeks and he has 125 degrees mobility. I have never had that result with my knee. Yes it is a long way or the surgery but he has offices here for the followup visits. Be prepared to see Physican Assistants for most of the followup. I guess he is just too busy to see everyone afterward.
Polar Bear
12-29-2014, 05:49 PM
There is no comparison with the results you will get with Dr. Nguyen. I had a full knee replacement nine years ago. My husband had the surgery on Sept. 19th with Dr. Nguyen and we both can tell you there is a world of difference. He was walking 1000 steps the same evening as surgery (which was late in the day) and put down the walker in two days. The outpatient therapy was 3 weeks and he has 125 degrees mobility..
Actually results can be very comparable. The recovery stats you mention are almost identical to mine. I think the most important number you mention is "nine years ago".
Sorry, but it's apples-and-oranges to compare surgeries from then and now, regardless of the surgeon.
shrink
01-10-2015, 12:30 AM
Had my right knee done a year ago by a highly recognized Tampa surgeon. Pain was a 9/10 for 2-3 weeks, and I was in PT for 12 weeks...on pain meds for all that time. Had my left knee done this past November by Dr. Nguyen. Pain was 2/10, went to PT 3 times before being released by P.A. with 125 degree flex. Was line dancing at Spanish Springs at 3 weeks post surgery. Off pain meds after 2 weeks, and only used them to sleep. You don't need to wait many months to see doctor and schedule surgery if you are willing to have your initial appointment scheduled with the PA instead of the doctor. At least that way, you can get on the surgery schedule. Only concern I have is that there is a fair amount of disorganization within this practice, probably because Dr. Nguyen takes on too many patients for the staff he employs. It is important to check and double check appointment times, etc. Things seem to change quickly, and not always with advanced notice. None the less, the ends justify the means, in my opinion.
VT2TV
01-12-2015, 11:07 PM
knee replacement
I am still waiting to have the replacement done.
auntmeme
01-28-2015, 09:56 PM
who did you go with
VT2TV
01-31-2015, 02:25 AM
Dr Nguyen--down to 4 months....and counting
CFrance
01-31-2015, 08:10 AM
Be sure to let us know a couple days before so we can perform some TOTV good wishes for a successful operation.:MOJE_whot::pray::pray::wave:
Cedwards38
01-31-2015, 08:52 AM
How will this impact sports activity? Could a person easily play golf, tennis, softball, or other sports with the new knee?
784caroline
01-31-2015, 09:32 AM
Just had my 6 week follow up with Dr Nguyen and got cleared for golf, water volleyball and whatever I would routinely do. IN finishing up PT at Physio Med near Home Depot, they told me I met all goals and they asked me was there anything else they could help me with. I wanted to get back to water volleyball and golf which involve twisting and jumping. So the PT at my last session included jumping on a trampoline both holding on and well as hands free, and twisting exercises(within limits) . This was more of a confidence builder (mental) that I could do what I wanted with no pain. Enjoyed PT at this location....very personal staff.
BTW: For new patients of Dr Nguyen, they are scheduling surgery for September....that is 7-8 months out.
Finallyfree
01-31-2015, 11:03 PM
I had my knee replacement on 12/4, done by Dr. Duke at Marion community Hospital in Ocala. I was off pain meds in less than a week, no muscle or tendons cut. I used the walker for about ten days and then a cane for a week. I was golfing at six weeks from front tees. Have been released at eight weeks for full golfing, water volleyball and working back into pickleball. I couldn't be happier with Dr. Duke who has done over 7,500 knee replacements.
dotti105
03-18-2015, 12:42 PM
I have been going to Dr Duke's practice for a year now for steroid injections every 3 months, for both knees. They are deteriorating very quickly. The steroids no longer give me relief for more than 6 weeks.
I called last week to make an apt to see Dr. Duke. Now, mind you, I have been a patient there for a year and never seen by him, just his PA, which was fine with me because steroids were what I needed. But things have changed.
I was told that he would only see me after I did my pre op clearance by my PCP, Chest x ray and pre op labs. We would not see me, period, until those things were done.
That really turned me off. He has been signing off on my care for a year now and yet will not see me?? I am a RN and I get the need for PAs and NPs. But my MD should see me if I want to be seen. i don't know if I am ready for TKR, or if there are other options. That is why I wanted to be seen by him.
I called Dr Nguyen on the same day. I have an appt with HIM for next week in Maitland as he no longer comes up here on Fridays. But I don't mind driving an hr if I will be seen by the surgeon and we can discuss my options, waiting, not waiting, bilateral TKR, etc.
I set my appts for the pre op stuff that Duke wants and he will see me in late April. Dr Nguyen is seeing me a month earlier and I have never been to his practice.
I have the feeling that I will already be on the surgical schedule with Dr Nguyen by the time Duke is willing to see me.
This has been a big turn off for me.
bagboy
03-18-2015, 02:37 PM
I had a TKR in November of 2013 performed by Dr. Nguyen at the Florida Hospital Altamonte. I am 100% satisfied and I cannot recommend Dr Nguyen highly enough!!! Just make sure you do the rehab as instructed.
Polar Bear
03-18-2015, 03:14 PM
...i don't know if I am ready for TKR, or if there are other options. That is why I wanted to be seen by him...
With all due respect, I was told that that very uncertainty is why the first step toward a TKR is to see the PA for just such a discussion. Seemed very reasonable to me and it worked out well.
SALYBOW
04-21-2015, 02:54 PM
Where is Dr Nguyen and where does he operate? What is his first name?
784caroline
04-21-2015, 03:06 PM
Where is Dr Nguyen and where does he operate? What is his first name?
HIs business card shows Dr Steve V. Nguyen. He operates from The Florida Hospital in Alamonte Springs on Monday, tuesday and thursdays...very nice hospital about 1:20 - 1:30 mintues from TV. His PAs have office hours in TV off of Rolling Acres Rd on Fridays while Dr Nguyen and his other PA has office hours in Maitland Florida on Wednesday and Friday.
SALYBOW
04-21-2015, 03:12 PM
TY Caroline
mixsonci
04-22-2015, 09:33 AM
Does anyone know if your insurance will pay for the surgery the way Dr. Nguyen performs it? I mean, when I had my cataract surgery, insurance would not pay for the laser portion of the surgery, only the "old-fashioned" hand cutting surgery. The old-fashioned way is still a good way to go and very safe and reliable, but the laser is the way of the future progression, but no insurance will cover it.
Grannygail
04-22-2015, 11:08 AM
Yes, insurance covers Dr. Nguyens surgery. I had surgery March 17th and was playing golf 20 days later. Very fast recovery along with you dedication to rehab therapy.
raynan
04-22-2015, 11:57 AM
I have 3 surgeries scheduled with Dr. Nguyen (and no, I do not have 3 legs). 1st is Monday to incise and drain a Morel Levelleur Lesion which other orthos here in The Villages diagnosed as a hematoma that would gradually lessen. 18 months later it is still huge. 1st knee replacement in July, 2nd in Oct. He has done 22 in our neighborhood and all with fantastic results. My BC/BS is covering it. Surgery for non Medicare patients is done by him at the Surgical Ctr in Orlando as day surgeries. Medicare requires overnight stays and are done at Florida Hospital Altamont Springs. I'll update after each surgery.
784caroline
04-22-2015, 02:58 PM
I have 3 surgeries scheduled with Dr. Nguyen (and no, I do not have 3 legs). 1st is Monday to incise and drain a Morel Levelleur Lesion which other orthos here in The Villages diagnosed as a hematoma that would gradually lessen. 18 months later it is still huge. 1st knee replacement in July, 2nd in Oct. He has done 22 in our neighborhood and all with fantastic results. My BC/BS is covering it. Surgery for non Medicare patients is done by him at the Surgical Ctr in Orlando as day surgeries. Medicare requires overnight stays and are done at Florida Hospital Altamont Springs. I'll update after each surgery.
WOW are you saying he is doing outpaitent total knee replacement surgeries if you have other than Medicare insurance. I know he is good but alot of things can happen (primarily blood clots). I have medicare but also BC/BS and his office secures a 5 day hospital stay approval from BC/BS in advance even though we only use one. There are added out of pocket costs with a hospital stay when you only have insurance such as BCBS, but a TKR is a major surgery and we in TV live 1:30 minutes if we would ever have to get back to see him quickly!! Not sure I would be willing to take that risk!
raynan
04-22-2015, 07:42 PM
Yes.
maureenod
04-22-2015, 09:26 PM
Hi Nancy, I have had a total knee replacement and when I need the other done I will do therapy months before surgery.....stretching especially...same as after surgery. Stationary bicycle is great. Therapy before surgery will make therapy after much easier,so I have been told.
Polar Bear
04-22-2015, 09:30 PM
Hi Nancy, I have had a total knee replacement and when I need the other done I will do therapy months before surgery.....stretching especially...same as after surgery. Stationary bicycle is great. Therapy before surgery will make therapy after much easier,so I have been told.
Yeah. My knee was done by Dr. Duke. He recommended a therapy regimen before surgery and I believe it was a big help. My results are excellent.
optv13sp
04-23-2015, 08:44 AM
Does Dr. Nguyen do a TOTAL knee replacement or is it a partial replacement?
bagboy
04-23-2015, 09:09 AM
WOW are you saying he is doing outpaitent total knee replacement surgeries if you have other than Medicare insurance. I know he is good but alot of things can happen (primarily blood clots). I have medicare but also BC/BS and his office secures a 5 day hospital stay approval from BC/BS in advance even though we only use one. There are added out of pocket costs with a hospital stay when you only have insurance such as BCBS, but a TKR is a major surgery and we in TV live 1:30 minutes if we would ever have to get back to see him quickly!! Not sure I would be willing to take that risk!
STOP for just a second! You are always at risk when undergoing minor or major surgery. Dr. Nguyen does not perform TKRs then roll you out the door as you seem to be thinking. In Nov of 2013 I was a NON medicare patient of Dr. Nguyen, and received a total TKR on a Monday morning at the Florida Hospital Altamonte. After a tremendous amount of professional care from Dr. Nguyen, physical therapists, a hospital staff, I was released later in the afternoon on tuesday. I had excellent follow up care that included Dr. Nguyens monitoring my physical rehabilitation, which was very successful.
I am relating my personal experience with a very qualified health care professional. I don't care who uses what doctor for any procedure. I know that Dr. Nguyen is not going to risk his patients well being for any reason.
raynan
04-24-2015, 12:45 PM
Dr. Nguyen requires PT before and after surgery. Before to strengthen surrounding muscles which helps a lot in the recovery.
Dr. Nguyen does total knee replacements (TKR).
784caroline
04-24-2015, 02:42 PM
STOP for just a second! You are always at risk when undergoing minor or major surgery. Dr. Nguyen does not perform TKRs then roll you out the door as you seem to be thinking. In Nov of 2013 I was a NON medicare patient of Dr. Nguyen, and received a total TKR on a Monday morning at the Florida Hospital Altamonte. After a tremendous amount of professional care from Dr. Nguyen, physical therapists, a hospital staff, I was released later in the afternoon on tuesday. I had excellent follow up care that included Dr. Nguyens monitoring my physical rehabilitation, which was very successful.
I am relating my personal experience with a very qualified health care professional. I don't care who uses what doctor for any procedure. I know that Dr. Nguyen is not going to risk his patients well being for any reason.
Bagboy I also had a TKR by Dr Nguyen just as you describe. BUt a prior post is stating Dr Nguyen is also doing Outpatient TKR surgery at an Orlando Surgical Center with no hospital stay...that is what I find amazing. According to the prior post Medicare patients cannot have it done this way for Medicare requires at least one night in the hospital
dotti105
04-25-2015, 01:10 AM
I was seen by Dr Nguyen today and his first question was "how long have you had trouble with those kneecaps?" He saw something on XRay that no one else has noticed.
He told me that what I probably would need is a Partial Knee Replacement, something I have never been told. He sent me for an MRI today and I have a follow up with him in May.
Now I need to do some research on Partial Knee Replacements. I don't especially want to go through the surgery for the partial now and in 3 yrs have to have total knees. I'm more a fan of the "one and done" approach.
We did talk about PRP which ins does not cover He says it is really not successful. That is what Dr Duke ( when he finally saw me) suggested, if I felt I was not ready for TKR.
I am anxious to see what my MRI shows and what Dr Nguyen says after seeing it. He seemed to think the main problem was my kneecaps not the arthritis. News flash for me.
This is going to be an interesting ride......
784caroline
04-25-2015, 08:39 AM
Dotti
What is a PRP ???
From my understanding, a partial Knee replacement is fine for the right person. If you are active,especially in sports, the partial probably will not be long lasting. For golf, dancing or just getting around I understand "partials" have been very successsful.
JBarracks
04-25-2015, 08:57 AM
The Metal Test....I had total knee replacement three years ago in St. Louis. I was in extreme pain below the knee for three weeks. The surgeon had done thousands of these knee replacements (Stryker) and hadn't seen this before. I was put back in the hospital for four days until the pain subsided. I was on heavy meds but the pain just went away. I hadn't been given a metal test.
Now I am due for another knee replacement on my other knee and as I've already had a Stryker knee replacement the nurse felt no need for a metal test just a patch to test for a metal reaction. I passed the patch test but thought about the problem that I had a few years ago and asked for the metal test (a blood draw). The test results show that I am very reactive to Nickel, Chromium and Zirconium. Just what the Stryker knee is made from.
My new knee will now be made of ceramic material.
FYI I would ask for the metal test. I may have been one in a million to have a reaction to the Stryker knee but the metal test will clear up any doubts.
bagboy
04-25-2015, 09:46 AM
The Metal Test....I had total knee replacement three years ago in St. Louis. I was in extreme pain below the knee for three weeks. The surgeon had done thousands of these knee replacements (Stryker) and hadn't seen this before. I was put back in the hospital for four days until the pain subsided. I was on heavy meds but the pain just went away. I hadn't been given a metal test.
Now I am due for another knee replacement on my other knee and as I've already had a Stryker knee replacement the nurse felt no need for a metal test just a patch to test for a metal reaction. I passed the patch test but thought about the problem that I had a few years ago and asked for the metal test (a blood draw). The test results show that I am very reactive to Nickel, Chromium and Zirconium. Just what the Stryker knee is made from.
My new knee will now be made of ceramic material.
FYI I would ask for the metal test. I may have been one in a million to have a reaction to the Stryker knee but the metal test will clear up any doubts.
I have seen numbers ranging from 1 in 4 to 1 in 7 of people who have an allergy to the metals that you described. Unless we have a joint replacement or eat nails for breakfast, one would most likely never know they have the allergy. Before surgery with Dr. Nguyen, the metal allergy potential was discussed. Along with the "patch" test, Dr. Nguyen and his PA strongly suggested, but did not require the blood allergy test.
I opted FOR the test which was done by an independent lab in Chicago. My insurance would not cover the $265 cost. I paid for the test out of pocket and it came back negative, no allergies to metal. A small price to pay for peace of mind or more importantly to avoid any dangerous and painful side effects, should I have been one that has the metal allergy.
bagboy
04-25-2015, 09:58 AM
I was seen by Dr Nguyen today and his first question was "how long have you had trouble with those kneecaps?" He saw something on XRay that no one else has noticed.
He told me that what I probably would need is a Partial Knee Replacement, something I have never been told. He sent me for an MRI today and I have a follow up with him in May.
Now I need to do some research on Partial Knee Replacements. I don't especially want to go through the surgery for the partial now and in 3 yrs have to have total knees. I'm more a fan of the "one and done" approach.
We did talk about PRP which ins does not cover He says it is really not successful. That is what Dr Duke ( when he finally saw me) suggested, if I felt I was not ready for TKR.
I am anxious to see what my MRI shows and what Dr Nguyen says after seeing it. He seemed to think the main problem was my kneecaps not the arthritis. News flash for me.
This is going to be an interesting ride......
I personally feel that you are in good hands, and wish you the best.
raynan
04-25-2015, 12:01 PM
I also showed no reaction to the patch test but told them I do react to cheap jewelry so I opted for the metal test. Came back strong allergic reaction to nickel. I will have ceramic also.
bagboy
04-25-2015, 03:04 PM
I also showed no reaction to the patch test but told them I do react to cheap jewelry so I opted for the metal test. Came back strong allergic reaction to nickel. I will have ceramic also.
That's very wise of you to have the test. Best wishes on you surgery!
billds567
04-26-2015, 04:44 PM
Had mine done Jan 2014 and Dr. Nguyen told me that a partial would only last 7-8 yrs. I am very active and very pleased with the full knee.
raynan
04-26-2015, 07:39 PM
Thanks, bagboy, for your kind wishes.
raynan
04-28-2015, 11:56 AM
I had Dr. Nguyen remove a Morel Lavallee Lesion from my leg that occurred after a fall that fractured my fibula. The fibula healed in 3 weeks but orthos and my primary here in the villages said the surrounding trauma was a hematoma and would shrink on its own. 18 months later I was still nursing it. If I was active and without keeping it elevated it would enlarge during the day and hurt. When I got my appointment with Dr, Nguyen about a knee replacement he took one look at my leg and said it was not a hematoma, needed surgery and drained. Yesterday it was done on outpatient basis in Orlando. He said he could have put his entire forearm into the sac that was removed. No drain needed to be installed. My leg is wrapped up for 5 days and so far, no pain. I'll update. Both knees to be replaced, one in July other in Oct.
CFrance
04-28-2015, 01:49 PM
I had Dr. Nguyen remove a Morel Lavallee Lesion from my leg that occurred after a fall that fractured my fibula. The fibula healed in 3 weeks but orthos and my primary here in the villages said the surrounding trauma was a hematoma and would shrink on its own. 18 months later I was still nursing it. If I was active and without keeping it elevated it would enlarge during the day and hurt. When I got my appointment with Dr, Nguyen about a knee replacement he took one look at my leg and said it was not a hematoma, needed surgery and drained. Yesterday it was done on outpatient basis in Orlando. He said he could have put his entire forearm into the sac that was removed. No drain needed to be installed. My leg is wrapped up for 5 days and so far, no pain. I'll update. Both knees to be replaced, one in July other in Oct.
How fortunate for you that he recognized it for what it was. He sounds like a keeper.
paulascorpio
05-29-2015, 10:22 PM
Please make sure you get a metal allergy test.
vBulletin® v3.8.11, Copyright ©2000-2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.