Hot water temperature

[queasy27]

Everything is working fine but I'm curious why my hot water changes temperature. Sometimes it's too hot to use full on and other times it's about medium hot full on.


Standard 40 (?) gallon electric model
Located in the garage
It's about 15 years old
Nobody here but me and I never change the thermostat on it (if there is one; I've never looked).
No service/maintenance people who would have changed it.
The sprinklers aren't on and nobody else uses water while I'm using it.
It's unrelated to whether or not the washer is running.
The temperature is too hot about 30% of the time and can vary during the same day.
It's not any specific time of day that I can pinpoint.


Is this perhaps an indication that it's getting old and can't hold a steady temperature, or is it normal to vary?

[Toymeister]

It sounds like the thermostat located on the heating element for an electric water heater.

No it is not normal for the temperature to vary.

Realistically, though, it is 15 years old. You really should consider replacing it.

[retiredguy123]

The temperature should be consistent. Most electric water heaters have two heating elements. You can remove the two metal plates on the water heater and adjust the temperature with a screw driver. Both elements should be set on the same temperature. I think the builder sets the temperature at 120 degrees, but I increased mine to 125. Be careful when you remove the metal plates because the edges are sharp. It could be that one of the elements is not working, which may provide an inconsistent temperature.

[villagetinker]

Also, we notice some difference in temperature with the cold weather, the incoming water is colder...

[Toymeister]

If you are really into this you can test the resistance of the elements to see if they need to be replaced. And yes, before someone accuses you of losing all common sense the first line of instruction says shut off the power. How to Check Heating Elements in Hot Water Heaters | Home Guides | SF Gate (https://homeguides.sfgate.com/check-heating-elements-hot-water-heaters-35746.html)

[retiredguy123]

If you are really into this you can test the resistance of the elements to see if they need to be replaced. And yes, before someone accuses you of losing all common sense the first line of instruction says shut off the power. How to Check Heating Elements in Hot Water Heaters | Home Guides | SF Gate (https://homeguides.sfgate.com/check-heating-elements-hot-water-heaters-35746.html)
I agree, but if you have a bad heating element, buy a new water heater. 15 years is past it's life expectancy.

[queasy27]

Thanks for the advice, everyone.

[Topspinmo]

I agree, but if you have a bad heating element, buy a new water heater. 15 years is past it's life expectancy.

Who gets 15 years out of water heater:1rotfl: and if you do if full of calcium deposits with little water. IMO thats why the little water supply can’t hold temperature, you probably get 10 gallons heated?

[Toymeister]

Who gets 15 years out of water heater:1rotfl: and if you do if full of calcium deposits with little water. IMO thats why the little water supply can’t hold temperature, you probably get 10 gallons heated?

You certainly can get twenty years if you flushed it annually.

As to your second point a new 40 gallon heater provides 28 gallons. Not because 28 gallons is forty, rather 28 gallons of cold water displacing 28 gallons of hot makes it so cold that it's not effectively functional as the heating elements cannot over come the temperature loss quickly enough. At 28 gallons the tank is full of 85 degree water which feels cool.

[retiredguy123]

You certainly can get twenty years if you flushed it annually.

As to your second point a new 40 gallon heater provides 28 gallons. Not because 28 gallons is forty, rather 28 gallons of cold water displacing 28 gallons of hot makes it so cold that it's not effectively functional as the heating elements cannot over come the temperature loss quickly enough. At 28 gallons the tank is full of 85 degree water which feels cool.
Ok, I give up. I thought I was frugal, but you win. I'm surprised you even have a water heater.

[CWGUY]

You certainly can get twenty years if you flushed it annually.

As to your second point a new 40 gallon heater provides 28 gallons. Not because 28 gallons is forty, rather 28 gallons of cold water displacing 28 gallons of hot makes it so cold that it's not effectively functional as the heating elements cannot over come the temperature loss quickly enough. At 28 gallons the tank is full of 85 degree water which feels cool.

:coolsmiley: I don't see anything frugal in this post..... I see it as factual. Something that is sometimes lost on this site.

Although it was "gas" I replaced my last HWH at approx. 16 years (still worked fine) because I wanted something more efficient and TECO gave me a $400.00 rebate to do it. The 40 gal. gas HWH that I purchased cost only a little more than that and had electric flue dampener and electric ignition. I would like to add - I have always flushed my HWH twice a year. I write dates down on the side of the heater with a pencil. :thumbup:

[Topspinmo]

Ever open you’re 10 to 15 year tank and see the build up?

[CWGUY]

:ohdear: No.....I have a life! :1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl: I put it to the curb and make the call to have it picked up. :rolleyes:

[Topspinmo]

:ohdear: No.....I have a life! :1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl: I put it to the curb and make the call to have it picked up. :rolleyes:


Well GOOOOOOOOOOD for YOOOOOOOOOOU:MOJE_whot:

[CWGUY]

Well GOOOOOOOOOOD for YOOOOOOOOOOU:MOJE_whot:

:pray: Well God for you too! :icon_wink:

[Down Sized]

I would bet that most people in the villages don’t even know to flush their hot water tank twice a year. Even if they were aware, they wouldn’t do it.

[B-flat]

And while the discussion is on who would you recommend to install a water heater, someone reliable and not a rip off? At least up north I have paid in the $600 range for a 40 gallon tank to be installed.

[CWGUY]

And while the discussion is on who would you recommend to install a water heater, someone reliable and not a rip off? At least up north I have paid in the $600 range for a 40 gallon tank to be installed.

:shrug: Gas or Electric?

[photo1902]

And while the discussion is on who would you recommend to install a water heater, someone reliable and not a rip off? At least up north I have paid in the $600 range for a 40 gallon tank to be installed.

Mike Scott Plumbing.(352) 748-9111

[B-flat]

:shrug: Gas or Electric?

Gas

[B-flat]

Ok thanks for Mike Scott, I’ve seen his vans on the road both here and in Ocala.

[CWGUY]

Gas

Appliance Sales and Services - Peoples Gas (https://www.peoplesgas.com/residential/services/appliancesandsales/)

And don't forget the rebate or here is another option - Water Heater Payment Plans - Peoples Gas (https://www.peoplesgas.com/residential/services/waterheaterpaymentplans/)

[B-flat]

Appliance Sales and Services - Peoples Gas (https://www.peoplesgas.com/residential/services/appliancesandsales/)

And don't forget the rebate or here is another option - Water Heater Payment Plans - Peoples Gas (https://www.peoplesgas.com/residential/services/waterheaterpaymentplans/)

good suggestion, thanks.

[CWGUY]

:ho: