Hip replacement advice

[Bay Kid]

My hip is hurting when I sleep and can't walk many miles without some pain. Now I wonder if it is time to have the hip replaced? I heard there are new ways that would be easy, quick recovery and not much pain. Is this wishful thinking?

[jebartle]

Dr. Messieh 352-243-6899 fixed my hip and I recovered after 2 weeks and ready to play golf but dr. Wanted me to wait 6 weeks....He is in his office on Wednesdays only. Highly highly recommend.

[villagetinker]

I would definitely see a doctor first to see if there are other options. I have had 2 friends go through this, both were out of commission for about 6 weeks, but if I recall correctly, one was able to delay the operation for 1 or 2 years with other treatments.

[Mudder]

It could be a bursa if it's the outside of your hip that hurts. I would go to pain management doc for evaluation. Injections may be all you need. I could not walk from one end of Publix to the other the pain was so bad. Bursa was cause, injections solved the problem.

[JGVillages]

Dr Joseph Locker / Ocala.

[Aces4]

My hip is hurting when I sleep and can't walk many miles without some pain. Now I wonder if it is time to have the hip replaced? I heard there are new ways that would be easy, quick recovery and not much pain. Is this wishful thinking?

Kid, do you already have the diagnostics and tests determining hip replacement is necessary? I had the same symptoms and could barely walk when I visited my Dr. He advised me he believed it was a pain he saw in many elderly patients that had lost flexibility. He gave me a series of stretching exercises and in three weeks I saw vast improvement and I now do them daily. No pain, no surgery. Obviously, this won’t help where the DX is replacement. Btw, my fairly young Dr. has had the same symptoms until utilizing the exercises.

[JoMar]

I had two knees and a hip replaced, the hip was the easiest. The previous method was to enter from the rear, the current method is to enter from the front. Less invasive and faster recovery time. I used Dr. Ethier and more than satisfied.

[bmit16]

I would go to a highly recommended orthopedic hip doctor. I had my knee replaced and I knew when I needed to go. Asking people on this op about your hip is irrelevant. Ask a qualified doctor.

[MarkGoldberg]

My hip is hurting when I sleep and can't walk many miles without some pain. Now I wonder if it is time to have the hip replaced? I heard there are new ways that would be easy, quick recovery and not much pain. Is this wishful thinking?

Absolutely. There are 2 basic ways hip replacement is done. Anterior and Posterior. Anterior is a very simple recovery with almost NO pain at ALL! Posterior cuts more muscle and it is the muscle recovery that takes longer, has more limitations and pain. Please have this taken care of as it is truly very easy and you will immediately feel better. There are many surgeons doing this surgery. I used Dr Locker, in Ocala, and would recommend him without hesitation. If you have ANY questions please feel free to ask.

[bd20166]

Try Stretch Zone before you submit to surgery.

[tsmall22204]

Hip replacement is not like an oil change, go to your doctor. Self diagnosis is for fools.

[Miss.BettyBoop]

Go to a podiatrist! I could barely walk due to hip pain. Went to a foot doctor, got the right shoe inserts, walked out of the office pain free and have been for over a year. Conservative is the best first option!

[Bay Kid]

Thank you all. Heading to the doctor.

[Chloe Girl]

I had my hip replaced by Dr Messieh and can truly say that I never experienced a bit of pain after the surgery. But all avenues should be explored before having any body part replaced!

[DONKEY10]

My hip is hurting when I sleep and can't walk many miles without some pain. Now I wonder if it is time to have the hip replaced? I heard there are new ways that would be easy, quick recovery and not much pain. Is this wishful thinking?

If it's bone on bone replace it. My wife had both hips replaced and is in the gym squatting 315 and leg pressing 600LBs. The important thing is to find the right surgeon and to do the rehab. After about 2 months everything will come together and you won't regret it.

[Skoego]

My hip is hurting when I sleep and can't walk many miles without some pain. Now I wonder if it is time to have the hip replaced? I heard there are new ways that would be easy, quick recovery and not much pain. Is this wishful thinking?
I had a hip replacement in August, and it has given me my life back. Dr. Weisstein was amazing, but he is in Colorado. I was on a walker for 4 days, cane for about a week and a half. Pain was immediately relieved. A significant factor in recovery is whether or not you can have “anterior” vs “posterior” hip replacement. Anterior hip replacement is MUCH less invasive in terms of cutting muscle tissue that must heal, and consequently recovery is faster. I had an anterior hip replacement. If you google anterior hip replacement, you will see the differences. I, too, could not sleep, walk much, and golf was difficult. After all was said and done, I was sorry I had not done it sooner. Good luck!

[Win1894]

From what you described you may have osteoarthritis in your hip. This is a degenerative disease of the cartilage and bone tissue of the bearing surfaces of the articular joints. It can be particularly painful for the weight-bearing joints (hips and knees, less commonly the ankle joint). In the hip it is usually (not always) a deep groin pain where bursitis is closer to the lateral surface of the hip. A simple x-ray will be necessary to diagnose the condition of you hip joint. As the cartilage lining the joint degrades and erodes away the bony surfaces of the joint will migrate towards each other causing a lessening of what's called the joint space until enough is worn away that you achieve a condition mentioned in a post above called bone-on-bone. This is easily seen in simple planer x-rays. Here is a link that will explain all this: Hip Osteoarthritis - OrthoInfo - AAOS (https://orthoinfo.aaos.org/en/diseases--conditions/osteoarthritis-of-the-hip/)

Several things to be careful of: injections - there are two types. One is called visco-supplimentation. This is an injection (actually a series of injections) of hyaluronic acid which is a very viscous natural substance that is found all cartiagenous joints. These injections are used more in the knee joint than the hip and can give some temporary relief of pain and improve mobility. There is no real down side to this other than cost. It will not cure degenerative joint disease. The other injections consists of corticosteriods. These injections contains both a analgesic for pain relief and a steroid to lessen the inflamation caused by the arthritis. These are also give temporary relief but there is a limit to the number that you can receive because there are several adverse effects to the steroids. And most surgeons will not perform a hip arthroplasty until some months after your last last sterioid injection.

A couple of other things to keep in mind. Hip surgery is very effective, and the implant products are good enough that the arthroplasty may the rest of your life. Lose weight - if you are over weight the extra load on the joint will exacerbate your pain and the degenerative process. Exercise and stretch as mentioned in previous posts. This may give some relief of pain and if you do need surgery it will lessen the recovery time. Don't smoke or drink to excess. Besides affecting you health in general smoking and drinking adversly affect the healing process and possibly the long-term outcome of the surgery.

There you have it. Go see you doctor and good luck!

[Win1894]

I thought of one other thing to be careful of. These days you see a lot of advertisements for stem cell therapy (SCT) and other alternative therapies. Be very suspecious of these. While SCT may be effective for the most early stages of some degenerative diseases of the hip (the jury is still out on this). There is no evidence that is will help in intermediate or advanced osteoarthritis, and it's very expensive and possibly not covered by insurance.

[bvanider]

I just had my right hip replaced by Dr. Thomas Sullivan, located at the Villages Specialty Clinic, adjacent to the Hospital, on November 18th. He is superb. I had been putting it off, and was experiencing the same type of pain you are. I wish I had had the operation two years ago. I am up and around, and have no pain from day one of being on my feet. Get it done as soon as you can.

[rrb48310]

My hip is hurting when I sleep and can't walk many miles without some pain. Now I wonder if it is time to have the hip replaced? I heard there are new ways that would be easy, quick recovery and not much pain. Is this wishful thinking?

My wife has had both hips replaced, if your pain is in the groin area that points it toward a hip issue. Still like others have said go to a doctor, WebMD ain’t gonna cut it.

[drcar41@aol.com]

Dr. Messieh 352-243-6899 fixed my hip and I recovered after 2 weeks and ready to play golf but dr. Wanted me to wait 6 weeks....He is in his office on Wednesdays only. Highly highly recommend.

I totally agree. He did both of mine about a year apart. All went very well. I also highly recommend him. The phone number for the office is ; 352-243-6899

[yankygrl]

Dr. John Williams advanced orthopedic institute. Check him out

[Sweatman]

Get a diagnosis and don’t delay a replacement if it is recommended (as I did and now regret). Mobility is key to your health. I recommend Dr. Locker in Ocala. I am one year out and could not be more satisfied. With no other health problems, I had the surgery outpatient in his facility across from his office. In at 6 AM and waked out with minimal support at 11 AM. Anterior approach. He is a great doc. Even got down on the floor to demonstrate exercises. Life gets shorter by the day. Don’t sacrifice the things you love to do because of hip pain.

[DOGSAREKEEPERS]

Various doctors have various opinions. We had to go to 3 for my husband's knee replacement since the first 2 had different opinions.
When we moved to the Villages we found a doctor in Travares that really fit with us. He trained in Michigan, is very low key, explains everything in detail, and has a fabulous PA working with him.
My husband had his second replacement with him and had no pain and great mobility from day one.
He doesn't rush for surgery if there are other alternatives but does not jump up with those flashy alternatives that just rack up bills.
He uses Waterman hospital and they are wonderful.
His name is Dr. Jon Radnothy 352-343-2171 at 2051 Mayo Drive.
Easy to get to and well worth the trip.

[Fast Freddy]

Totally agree with most posts. Get the X-ray, will immediately determine need. Don't let anyone talk you into the side leg cut going into the muscle. Anterior recovery is a piece of cake especially if you are in good physical condition. Physical Therapy is easy especially if you are in good physical condition.
My back was hurting because my body was trying to offset the hip pain, after surgery, zero back pain. Had the other done 3 months later, both were bone on bone with calcium growths. Very little post-surgery pain medication.
Playing Pickleball with no consequences.

[Bay Kid]

I thought of one other thing to be careful of. These days you see a lot of advertisements for stem cell therapy (SCT) and other alternative therapies. Be very suspecious of these. While SCT may be effective for the most early stages of some degenerative diseases of the hip (the jury is still out on this). There is no evidence that is will help in intermediate or advanced osteoarthritis, and it's very expensive and possibly not covered by insurance.

I had a call and email about this. No way. Heading to the doctor this afternoon. Thank you for all the advice. I am still chicken, buttttt

[Bay Kid]

Had x-rays yesterday. NO HIP PROBLEM! A little arthritis. Now I can get back to worrying about all my other pains. Thanks to all and Merry Christmas.