Puppy Training - Question

[OCsun]

I have just gotten a new puppy and live in a courtyard villa with no grass, only stones, which were here prior to my moving in. Should I remove some of the stones and add grass or just train the dog to use the stones. Right now it is hit or miss. Has anyone ever put grass in a small box for their pet? Any advise would be appreciated.

[Dana1963]

I have just gotten a new puppy and live in a courtyard villa with no grass, only stones, which were here prior to my moving in. Should I remove some of the stones and add grass or just train the dog to use the stones. Right now it is hit or miss. Has anyone ever put grass in a small box for their pet? Any advise would be appreciated.
Keep it simple. Purchase a piece of artificial turf at Home Depot, Lowes, or Amazon.
Hose it off regularly

[Two Bills]

This thread could go astray!!:icon_wink:

[B-flat]

My experience with our dogs who have been trained would never go on our CYV rocks. We always had to walk them somewhere other than the enclosed courtyard.

[JMintzer]

My experience with our dogs who have been trained would never go on our CYV rocks. We always had to walk them somewhere other than the enclosed courtyard.

Ruh, Roh... The Cracken has been released!

[davem4616]

take them for a walk...that will avoid an odor in your backyard

[mulligan]

take them for a walk...that will avoid an odor in your backyard

So the solution is to leave the odor in someone else's yard ?? Nice!

[Dana1963]

Ruh, Roh... The Cracken has been released!
Another we'll trained owner

[Wyseguy]

Ruh, Roh... The Cracken has been released!

Somewhere other than your patio; :shocked: SUCH AS????

[Wyseguy]

I have just gotten a new puppy and live in a courtyard villa with no grass, only stones, which were here prior to my moving in. Should I remove some of the stones and add grass or just train the dog to use the stones. Right now it is hit or miss. Has anyone ever put grass in a small box for their pet? Any advise would be appreciated.

You are asking people who lived thru the 60's and 70's if they ever put grass in a box? Well, I'd guess yes.

[JMintzer]

Somewhere other than your patio; :shocked: SUCH AS????

https://www.memesmonkey.com/images/memesmonkey/e9/e9a3d58749a71cc3e8008ee4d71811ea.jpeg

[JMintzer]

You are asking people who lived thru the 60's and 70's if they ever put grass in a box? Well, I'd guess yes.

Did you know that these were also used to store film? :1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl:

https://i.redd.it/c28py2zhwerz.jpg

[kaj3459]

My puppies grew up on a xeroscaped yard! Didn't know any difference and do fine!

[Tomptomp]

Dogs don’t like to pee on rocks because it splashes. Just create an environment where it doesn’t pee on itself.

[Happytails057@gmail.com]

Your dog will get use to it and guess what it’s much cleaner for you. Their paws are never dirty. I have taught all of my dogs to relieve themselves on gravel.

[CFrance]

Our puppy was trained in a gravel yard in Key West, then brought to grass in Michigan. Our other dog (rescued at age 8) was trained on grass but does fine on stones, possibly because he saw the puppy (now 14) peeing in the stones.

Train your puppy on the stones. It will be so much more convenient for you. He will switch to grass easily. My results, anyway...

[giorgio1948]

I have just gotten a new puppy and live in a courtyard villa with no grass, only stones, which were here prior to my moving in. Should I remove some of the stones and add grass or just train the dog to use the stones. Right now it is hit or miss. Has anyone ever put grass in a small box for their pet? Any advise would be appreciated.

we replaced it with zoysia grass and love it...no issues w our dog anymore and its friendly for guests too.

[Luggage]

My wife is a dog sitter and would never think to let a dog pee on rocks. My own opinion is that when it gets to be summer in 2 weeks or so it's going to be very hot on the rocks and hurt their paws but other people may tell you different. I would much rather prefer grass to rocks and I have to get a cut once in a while. Dogs also naturally like to walk explore the neighborhood and it's good for you and your health. I'm sure you've also heard they like to Mark the territory with pee. However if all else fails, they've invented puppy pads to put down on anything that have certain smells in them. Please remember to bring disposal bags when you walk the dogs to pick up the poop and I'm sorry neighbors but half the people own pets and the first five feet of most lawns is fair territory. I don't like the fact that some people don't want dogs on my lawns but let's face it the birds poop the squirrels poop the cats poop etc etc and I don't think that half an ounce of urine really does hurt in Lawns nor does anyone going to really look at a 1 in yellow spot as a defect in your character. I have some real nasty people where I live and I just try to avoid their lawn. Santa's not going to come to their home next year

[PoolBrews]

Get a cat and don't worry about it.

[OCsun]

Thanks to everyone who offered their suggestions for my concerns. Also, I am glad I was able to provide a few laughs!🤣

[OCsun]

Thanks to everyone who offered their suggestions for my concerns. Also, I am glad I was able to provide a few laughs!🤣

[Two Bills]

There is quite a large informal group here in TV called 'The friends of the dog walkers.'
They allow dog walkers to use their front yards for dogs to empty on when out walking.
You can recognize the members, by the white crosses displayed in their yard.:icon_wink:

[CFrance]

My wife is a dog sitter and would never think to let a dog pee on rocks. My own opinion is that when it gets to be summer in 2 weeks or so it's going to be very hot on the rocks and hurt their paws but other people may tell you different. I would much rather prefer grass to rocks and I have to get a cut once in a while. Dogs also naturally like to walk explore the neighborhood and it's good for you and your health. I'm sure you've also heard they like to Mark the territory with pee. However if all else fails, they've invented puppy pads to put down on anything that have certain smells in them. Please remember to bring disposal bags when you walk the dogs to pick up the poop and I'm sorry neighbors but half the people own pets and the first five feet of most lawns is fair territory. I don't like the fact that some people don't want dogs on my lawns but let's face it the birds poop the squirrels poop the cats poop etc etc and I don't think that half an ounce of urine really does hurt in Lawns nor does anyone going to really look at a 1 in yellow spot as a defect in your character. I have some real nasty people where I live and I just try to avoid their lawn. Santa's not going to come to their home next year
Our dogs are pretty smart retrievers and head for the shaded rocks. They're 14 and 8--no problems yet. I would never walk them during the day out on the street because of the heat on the flat road surface. And we don't walk on other people's grass, so the stones work fine for them between dawn and dusk.

[DonnaNi4os]

My yard does not have grass and my 4 year old pup has no problem using it. It makes clean up easy as well and there are no brown spots from urine.

[Syd2008]

I have just gotten a new puppy and live in a courtyard villa with no grass, only stones, which were here prior to my moving in. Should I remove some of the stones and add grass or just train the dog to use the stones. Right now it is hit or miss. Has anyone ever put grass in a small box for their pet? Any advise would be appreciated

.

Go on Amazon and check out dog turf. Designed with layers for liquid to go through. Some even have trays to go with them.
Artificial turf a bit to thin.

[jimjamuser]

Your dog will get use to it and guess what it’s much cleaner for you. Their paws are never dirty. I have taught all of my dogs to relieve themselves on gravel.
Wonder what the neighbors thought about the early training examples?

[jimjamuser]

Our puppy was trained in a gravel yard in Key West, then brought to grass in Michigan. Our other dog (rescued at age 8) was trained on grass but does fine on stones, possibly because he saw the puppy (now 14) peeing in the stones.

Train your puppy on the stones. It will be so much more convenient for you. He will switch to grass easily. My results, anyway...
On a serious note, I would imagine that a stone yard would be easier to clean after the D's BM. You could just hose it downward into the ground. When deposited on grass, most people would scoop it up in a plastic bag and put it into a garbage can - so that it does not burn the grass. That seems like more time and work and messy.

[jimjamuser]

My wife is a dog sitter and would never think to let a dog pee on rocks. My own opinion is that when it gets to be summer in 2 weeks or so it's going to be very hot on the rocks and hurt their paws but other people may tell you different. I would much rather prefer grass to rocks and I have to get a cut once in a while. Dogs also naturally like to walk explore the neighborhood and it's good for you and your health. I'm sure you've also heard they like to Mark the territory with pee. However if all else fails, they've invented puppy pads to put down on anything that have certain smells in them. Please remember to bring disposal bags when you walk the dogs to pick up the poop and I'm sorry neighbors but half the people own pets and the first five feet of most lawns is fair territory. I don't like the fact that some people don't want dogs on my lawns but let's face it the birds poop the squirrels poop the cats poop etc etc and I don't think that half an ounce of urine really does hurt in Lawns nor does anyone going to really look at a 1 in yellow spot as a defect in your character. I have some real nasty people where I live and I just try to avoid their lawn. Santa's not going to come to their home next year
Santa is like the birds when he has to go. A special trap door toilet was installed custom-made for his sleigh.

[jimjamuser]

There is quite a large informal group here in TV called 'The friends of the dog walkers.'
They allow dog walkers to use their front yards for dogs to empty on when out walking.
You can recognize the members, by the white crosses displayed in their yard.:icon_wink:
1st place for comments today. Very spiritual humor!

[Garywt]

In Florida we have grass so we just let the dog out back. Up north we have rock and grass and the dog will go on either at anytime.

[golfnut]

take them for a walk...that will avoid an odor in your backyard

that's the perfect solution let them pee on someone else's lawn, until I catch you and you won't come back to my house again

[golfnut]

Your dog will get use to it and guess what it’s much cleaner for you. Their paws are never dirty. I have taught all of my dogs to relieve themselves on gravel.

me too, never been a problem, duh you are the owner

[Rsenholzi]

When I first started to rent in a CYV, the back yard only had rocks. My boys had no trouble going from grass up north to rocks down here. When they had to go , they had to go , period and went whether it was rocks or grass. However, when I bought , I went with the grass. I feel it’s much more comfortable on their feet and legs to go on grass. How would you feel if you had to stand on rock? I know someone who put in a patch of fake grass in their lanai so their dog had a place to go. It’s really up to you, your puppy will adapt to whatever you provide for them . If it were me , I’d get rid of the rocks and go with grass. Good luck