Epley Maneuver - Vertigo

[hawk1021]

My Husband suffers from dizziness constantly someone said something about the Epley Maneuver. Has anyone done this before ? Did it work ? and if so can you recommend a doctor down here in the villages area.

[manaboutown]

I use it now and then. Have him give it a try. Whether it works or not will depend on what is causing his vertigo.

[golfing eagles]

My Husband suffers from dizziness constantly someone said something about the Epley Maneuver. Has anyone done this before ? Did it work ? and if so can you recommend a doctor down here in the villages area.

Please don't put the cart before the horse.
First, see a neurologist and possibly an otolaryngologist to get a proper diagnosis as to the cause of his vertigo. Depending on the symptoms and physical findings he'll probably need an MRI, and possibly brainstem evoked potentials and vestibular testing. That should exclude most of the really, really bad causes.

Then, one possible treatment is the "Epley maneuver", many physical therapists are trained to perform it. In my experience it has been about a 50-50 proposition in terms of success. Hope he gets better.

Lastly, some good advice for everyone: Beware of "someone said something"

[manaboutown]

Mine is benign paroxysmal positional vertigo. I was tested years ago and was diagnosed. Epley maneuver - Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epley_maneuver)

My physician sent me here as I resided in Newport Beach, CA at the time. They strapped me into a chair and rotated it to various positions, much like an Epley maneuver. They also gave me some eye exercises. All this really helped me. Balance Center In Newport Beach, CA | Newport Mesa Audiology Balance & Ear Institute (https://www.dizziland.com)

[golfing eagles]

Mine is benign paroxysmal positional vertigo. I was tested years ago and was diagnosed. Epley maneuver - Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epley_maneuver)

My physician sent me here as I resided in Newport Beach, CA at the time. They strapped me into a chair and rotated it to various positions, much like an Epley maneuver. They also gave me some eye exercises. All this really helped me. Balance Center In Newport Beach, CA | Newport Mesa Audiology Balance & Ear Institute (https://www.dizziland.com)

Exactly!-----you were tested and diagnosed first.

It was not clear from the OP if her husband had been seen for this problem or they just heard "something from someone" about the Epley maneuver. We don't need someone with an undiagnosed malignant acoustic neuroma or posterior cerebral artery aneurysm running around looking for a tilt table.

[ElDiabloJoe]

Mrs. EDJ just had this done in late July. She fell early in July and hit her noggin pretty good. After CT at the ER checked negative for concussion, but she had a traumatic onset of vertigo that was constant whether sitting, standing, or lying down.

The PCP set up an MRI, but in the meantime, referred her to a physical therapist for an Epley Maneuver thinking that there were "crystals" loose in her inner ear.

We are not medical field people, but we are well educated. We had never heard of the Epley maneuver, muchness "crystals" in your ear. Sounded "new age-y" to us.

Anyhow, we mentioned this to a few people in our social circle, and one is a DNP. Not just a Ph.D. in Nursing, but an NP with a doctorate. Anyhow, she and others told us how it had worked miraculously for people they knew. Not always, but often enough. There was something to these loose "crystals" in the ear.

Mrs. EDJ went to the PT. The Epley maneuver took about 2 minutes. It consisted of sitting on a medical table. She was directed to do a few different things, like turn her head to the left and lay back slowly, then sit up rapidly, then repeat with her head turned to the right, etc. Stuff like that. All non-invasive.

She came home from the appointment without much improvement. The next day did not bring much improvement either. However, the second day forward and all the way until today (almost 6 weeks later) the vertigo is gone and has not returned.

Hope this helps.

[petsetc]

I was hospitalized for 3 days this past June because at 8AM one morning, while sitting on my computer, I suddenly lost all sense of balance (not spinning), started slow, quickly got worse, was taken by ambulance to ER and eventually admitted. After MRI and tests nothing. Went to PT where they did the Epley maneuver several times. also determined that my eyes were not tracking smoothly.

After 4 PT sessions at the VA and eye and balance and stride exercises, I am pretty much OK but think I will never again have truly "normal" balance.

Best guess is the the tiny,tiny nerve in my right eye that effects balance, isn't talking to me brain anymore.

Get tested and evaluated, then get PT.

JMHO

[ewstanley]

I suffer from BPPV and do the Epley Maneuver, and I also do the reverse Epley Maneuver. I think that the easiest for me is the Half Somersault Maneuver.
All instructions are available on YouTube.

[mtdjed]

I was hospitalized for 3 days this past June because at 8AM one morning, while sitting on my computer, I suddenly lost all sense of balance (not spinning), started slow, quickly got worse, was taken by ambulance to ER and eventually admitted. After MRI and tests nothing. Went to PT where they did the Epley maneuver several times. also determined that my eyes were not tracking smoothly.

After 4 PT sessions at the VA and eye and balance and stride exercises, I am pretty much OK but think I will never again have truly "normal" balance.

Best guess is the the tiny nerve in my right eye that effects balance, isn't talking to me brain anymore.

Get tested and evaluated, then get PT.

JMHO

Sounds similar to me. MRI, exercises and all. Physical Therapy all said to be associated with my left ear. Much better now but I believe that I am simply able to cope better. Still have a balance issue with sudden moves. Just got back from a river cruise to Germany. Did not do well with cobblestones and hills. But coped and enjoyed.
Have met several other people that claim to have same residual effects of Vertigo.

Important to recognize that Vertigo is not a disease, but rather a symptom.

At the current time , I am convinced that I will have a balance issue forever and must remain vigilant to any fall potentials. Epley procedures are designed to try to reposition crystals but may not be able to totally succeed. Part of the process!

[hotrodgirl]

My Husband suffers from dizziness constantly someone said something about the Epley Maneuver. Has anyone done this before ? Did it work ? and if so can you recommend a doctor down here in the villages area.

I have positional vertigo and use this method. Originally Dr Patel at Active Rehab in Lady Lake helped me with this and taught me how to do it myself. It does work!

[CTKID]

My Husband suffers from dizziness constantly someone said something about the Epley Maneuver. Has anyone done this before ? Did it work ? and if so can you recommend a doctor down here in the villages area.

Multiple occurrences over the last five years or more. PCP sent me to Phy Ther specialist for Vertigo. Put goggles over my eyes, laying on large flat table moved me in multiple positions. The googles were connected to a PC. They were watching the insides of my eyes and how they reacted to the movements. Identified the cause and allowed them to perform the Epley Maneuver immediately. They instructed me not to do the maneuver myself as I could move the crystals further into the canal and make things worse. Got better over the next couple of days. I was a site on the golf course. Fell down multiple times after picking my ball out of the cup. Many have told me they do the maneuver themselves after watching YouTube. I have insurance so I would just go back to a professional if I needed it done again. Hope it helps.

[NotGolfer]

I've had BVVP as well. A couple of times in our 14 yrs of living here, I've experienced vertigo and went to P.T. for treatment. It worked. I also looked on YouTube for the Epley treatment and have done it at home. Yes, see a dr. first before doing it. My first experience years ago, with vertigo was up north. We told a virus was going around with that as one of it's symptoms. Sometimes an inner ear virus also can cause this issue. I still remember trying to walk in our home and it wasn't an easy thing. I don't recall the treatment that they gave me up there as it was so long ago.

[Trishakaye]

Make sure you do the Epley movements correctly. An ENT or good audiologist can diagnose what type of vertigo you’re experiencing.

[Larchap49]

My Husband suffers from dizziness constantly someone said something about the Epley Maneuver. Has anyone done this before ? Did it work ? and if so can you recommend a doctor down here in the villages area.

Skip the regular Dr. Find a Neurologist

[golfing eagles]

Skip the regular Dr. Find a Neurologist

Please read post #3, but thank you for the affirmation :1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl:

[golfing eagles]

Make sure you do the Epley movements correctly. An ENT or good audiologist can diagnose what type of vertigo you’re experiencing.

ENT---yes
Audiologist---not even close to diagnosing anything other than hearing loss.

[Cybersprings]

ENT---yes
Audiologist---not even close to diagnosing anything other than hearing loss.

From Mayo Clinic:
"Through these daily tasks, they work to prevent, diagnose, and manage the hearing and balance disorders of their patients through the use of audiometers, computers, and other testing devices, as well as hearing aids and cochlear implants."

But then again, I do not have a medical degree, so what do I know?

[Betty Wagner]

My Husband suffers from dizziness constantly someone said something about the Epley Maneuver. Has anyone done this before ? Did it work ? and if so can you recommend a doctor down here in the villages area.

I had severe vertigo several years ago after a fall. My doctor, who is no longer at the Colony Care Center, introduced me to the Epley Procedure. After a few sessions with her I started doing this at home. It really worked, Also worked for my brother-in-law.

[golfing eagles]

From Mayo Clinic:
"Through these daily tasks, they work to prevent, diagnose, and manage the hearing and balance disorders of their patients through the use of audiometers, computers, and other testing devices, as well as hearing aids and cochlear implants."

But then again, I do not have a medical degree, so what do I know?

Who is "they"?

[golfing eagles]

Who is "they"?

And if "they" are audiologists, I suppose there may be some really, really specialized audiologists at places like the Mayo Clinic, but they would be far, far removed from your everyday audiologists

[Karen Cruiser]

Dr. James Atkins (neurotology & otolaryngology) at Advent Health down by Disney is the Central Florida specialist for dizziness, etc. All my doctors suggested him. Takes about 2 months to get in and then you can just message him instead of going all the way down there. I’ve had this for 3 yrs. I first went to PT and had the Epley maneuver. Then the therapist sat me up, my arms & legs went wild and I punched her in the mouth. And most of my dizziness was over. Because I also have a very rare eye disease, my therapist said “My eyes are working overtime and the brain is trying to understand the mis-message from my ears. Therefore, movement can be very exhausting”. Go on FB and join a Vertigo Support Group. I had videonystagmography at Dr. Atkins. Results - Benign Paroxysmal Positional Vertigo in right ear and hyperactive labyrinthine dysfunction on left side. I sleep a lot!

[Drakeswood]

Depends on etiology of his vertigo. These work for me (+20 yr) and are quite often performed by a physical therapist. Worth a try.

[Arletti]

Google Epley maneuver, and give it a try a few times a day for a couple of days. Sometimes it’s an easy fix, because it can move the crystals back to where they’re supposed to be, and sometimes it doesn’t help. But try it first, it’s free it’s easy and it often works. So if it doesn’t work for you, then next you can speak to your doctor about which specialist to see to start trying to find a different cause.

[Asheville man]

My Husband suffers from dizziness constantly someone said something about the Epley Maneuver. Has anyone done this before ? Did it work ? and if so can you recommend a doctor down here in the villages area.

I had a period of a month or two when I turned over at night the whole room would spin for 5-10 seconds. I went to my PCP and he told me about the Epley Manuever. He performed it one time which made my eyes roll around and gave me the dizzy feeling for the 5-10 seconds. After the procedure was done, which is really nothing, my dizziness had disappeared. That was 5 months ago and now gone.

Of course, everyone should see their PCP for testing and diagnosis. The procedure was simple and worked wonders for me.

[Cybersprings]

And if "they" are audiologists, I suppose there may be some really, really specialized audiologists at places like the Mayo Clinic, but they would be far, far removed from your everyday audiologists

the "they" was basket weavers. Oh wait. The discussion was about audiologists. It was a Mayo Clinic article regarding common roles and responsibilities of an audiologist

[golfing eagles]

the "they" was basket weavers. Oh wait. The discussion was about audiologists. It was a Mayo Clinic article regarding common roles and responsibilities of an audiologist

Common??? I think not.

If a patient came in with the complaint of vertigo, the second to last referral that would ever cross my mind is to an "audiologist" (chiropractor being the last :1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl:) The patient first of all needs an MRI, probably with gadolinium, to exclude a space occupying lesion or vascular anomaly. They may need brainstem evoked potentials and advanced vestibular testing, which is squarely in the purview of the neurologists and otolaryngologists. Many times the diagnosis comes down to BPPV caused by otoconia in the labyrinth, and may be amenable to the Epley maneuver.

Amazing how some people just go on posting when they don't even know what it is that they don't know. I also think someone just criticized a person with a master's in political science because they claimed some degree of expertise. Regardless, I assure you that I AM an expert, know about a zillion times as much medicine as some that post, and I will be watching, as usual, to make sure no one is misinforming others on this site.

[Cybersprings]

And if "they" are audiologists, I suppose there may be some really, really specialized audiologists at places like the Mayo Clinic, but they would be far, far removed from your everyday audiologists

Look. We get it. Someone has a medical degree and is a retired doctor. Does that make them an expert on every thing and every profession that deals with the human body? You know what percentage of audiologists deal with balance issues? Please share that percentage? and that percentage is true for every community across the U.S.? Please share the source of this data.

Or maybe someone could post something like, from my career as a medical doctor, I recommend that you see an ENT over an audiologist for your vertigo issues. They are medical doctors, and as such have more medical training than an audiologist does and would probably be better able to help you.

This would express your credentials, and provide information without having to degrade a profession. It would not INCORRECTLY state that audiologists do not diagnose or that a good chiropractor is an oxymoron.

[Cybersprings]

Common??? I think not.

If a patient came in with the complaint of vertigo, the second to last referral that would ever cross my mind is to an "audiologist" (chiropractor being the last :1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl:) The patient first of all needs an MRI, probably with gadolinium, to exclude a space occupying lesion or vascular anomaly. They may need brainstem evoked potentials and advanced vestibular testing, which is squarely in the purview of the neurologists and otolaryngologists. Many times the diagnosis comes down to BPPV caused by otoconia in the labyrinth, and may be amenable to the Epley maneuver.

Amazing how some people just go on posting when they don't even know what it is that they don't know. I also think someone just criticized a person with a master's in political science because they claimed some degree of expertise. Regardless, I assure you that I AM an expert, know about a zillion times as much medicine as some that post, and I will be watching, as usual, to make sure no one is misinforming others on this site.

We were cross posting, so I posted my last post before reading this.

I do not question your medical knowledge or experience. I do not know if you were a horrible doctor, great doctor, or something in between. But l have no basis to assume anything other than the best. I have never tried to stack my medical knowledge and experience against yours, it would not be pretty for me.

But I believe that doctors should be precise or people die. And you are far from precise. You make blanket statements that are categorically wrong. And its obvious from many posts that people trust you because you are a doctor. You owe them thoughtful responses if you are going to speak with the authority of a doctor.

[golfing eagles]

Look. We get it. Someone has a medical degree and is a retired doctor. Does that make them an expert on every thing and every profession that deals with the human body? You know what percentage of audiologists deal with balance issues? Please share that percentage? and that percentage is true for every community across the U.S.? Please share the source of this data.

Or maybe someone could post something like, from my career as a medical doctor, I recommend that you see an ENT over an audiologist for your vertigo issues. They are medical doctors, and as such have more medical training than an audiologist does and would probably be better able to help you.

This would express your credentials, and provide information without having to degrade a profession. It would not INCORRECTLY state that audiologists do not diagnose or that a good chiropractor is an oxymoron.

Can anyone spell hyperbole???? That being said I get the impression that some posts are trying to equate medical care with some ancillary services. IT IS NOT THE SAME THING. To suggest that I would advise a patient that “I would recommend you see an ENT rather than an audiologist for your vertigo “ is absolutely bizarre. The concept of referring a vertiginous patient to an audiologist would never, ever enter the mind of even an average physician, only someone with limited knowledge and no experience would even suggest it. It’s no different than the suggestion that seeing a chiropractor for hip pain is the equivalent of seeing an orthopedist. And my concern is that posts that suggest such things could be harmful to some readers out there

[BrianL]

My Husband suffers from dizziness constantly someone said something about the Epley Maneuver. Has anyone done this before ? Did it work ? and if so can you recommend a doctor down here in the villages area.

The Epley Maneuver is to get ear rocks back in their proper position. The ear rocks can have moved out of place from either ear. The following is an excellent description and demonstration of the Epley Maneuver. I have done this myself on two occasions. In both cases, it solve my problem. The Epley Maneuver will only solve the problem if ear rocks are the cause. I've done the maneuver by myself; however, it's probably a little easier if someone helps you. I've done using my bed as the "table."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ZgUx9G0uEs

[Cybersprings]

Can anyone spell hyperbole???? That being said I get the impression that some posts are trying to equate medical care with some ancillary services. IT IS NOT THE SAME THING. To suggest that I would advise a patient that “I would recommend you see an ENT rather than an audiologist for your vertigo “ is absolutely bizarre. The concept of referring a vertiginous patient to an audiologist would never, ever enter the mind of even an average physician, only someone with limited knowledge and no experience would even suggest it. It’s no different than the suggestion that seeing a chiropractor for hip pain is the equivalent of seeing an orthopedist. And my concern is that posts that suggest such things could be harmful to some readers out there

It would not have been a recommendation from you to see an audiologist. It would have been a thoughtful response to someone else recommending it. And everything in it would have been factual. As it is, you got your point across, wrote an incorrect statement that audiologists do not diagnose balance issues(regardless of whether or not they are anywhere close to the best at it), and did it in a way that was degrading to a profession.

Going back to your right wrong right right wrong response to someone else, I don't think you get to be the authority on your bedside manner. If you treated your patients the way you treat others on this site, I am guessing that persons assertion would get a "right"

[Cybersprings]

Common??? I think not.

If a patient came in with the complaint of vertigo, the second to last referral that would ever cross my mind is to an "audiologist" (chiropractor being the last :1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl:) The patient first of all needs an MRI, probably with gadolinium, to exclude a space occupying lesion or vascular anomaly. They may need brainstem evoked potentials and advanced vestibular testing, which is squarely in the purview of the neurologists and otolaryngologists. Many times the diagnosis comes down to BPPV caused by otoconia in the labyrinth, and may be amenable to the Epley maneuver.

Amazing how some people just go on posting when they don't even know what it is that they don't know. I also think someone just criticized a person with a master's in political science because they claimed some degree of expertise. Regardless, I assure you that I AM an expert, know about a zillion times as much medicine as some that post, and I will be watching, as usual, to make sure no one is misinforming others on this site.

All seriousness aside, the humour of your last recommendation was not lost on me. I did actually chuckle.

[golfing eagles]

We were cross posting, so I posted my last post before reading this.

I do not question your medical knowledge or experience. I do not know if you were a horrible doctor, great doctor, or something in between. But l have no basis to assume anything other than the best. I have never tried to stack my medical knowledge and experience against yours, it would not be pretty for me.

But I believe that doctors should be precise or people die. And you are far from precise. You make blanket statements that are categorically wrong. And its obvious from many posts that people trust you because you are a doctor. You owe them thoughtful responses if you are going to speak with the authority of a doctor.

No offense, and I'm really not looking for a p!$$!ng match, but please point out a statement that is "categorically wrong". Some may be exaggerations to make a point, but overall they are accurate. You cannot hunt for rare exceptions and hold that up as a standard. I think I have been pretty consistent---I acknowledged referring patients to chiropractors and other ancillary services when appropriate, but pretty harshly warn against getting evaluated by those fringe practitioners first. Sorry if I ruffle some feathers, but the public sometimes just doesn't "get it". There are a lot of quacks and snake oil salesmen out there, and if I can do some small part to protect the innocent, I'm going to take it.

As far as "having a degree and being retired" goes, I think my career is a bit more than that. For all anyone knows, when they play Dr. Google they may be quoting me from the content that I myself have written. When they need inpatient medical care, they may be receiving treatment under protocols that I have written. So, consider it arrogant if you will, but I feel obligated to utilize my extensive knowledge to benefit others, within certain constraints of law and ethics. And yes, sometimes I get overzealous.

[martyahill]

My Husband suffers from dizziness constantly someone said something about the Epley Maneuver. Has anyone done this before ? Did it work ? and if so can you recommend a doctor down here in the villages area.

I have done the Epley procedure and it did work but I like the foster procedure more.

[Cybersprings]

No offense, and I'm really not looking for a p!$$!ng match, but please point out a statement that is "categorically wrong". Some may be exaggerations to make a point, but overall they are accurate. You cannot hunt for rare exceptions and hold that up as a standard. I think I have been pretty consistent---I acknowledged referring patients to chiropractors and other ancillary services when appropriate, but pretty harshly warn against getting evaluated by those fringe practitioners first. Sorry if I ruffle some feathers, but the public sometimes just doesn't "get it". There are a lot of quacks and snake oil salesmen out there, and if I can do some small part to protect the innocent, I'm going to take it.

As far as "having a degree and being retired" goes, I think my career is a bit more than that. For all anyone knows, when they play Dr. Google they may be quoting me from the content that I myself have written. When they need inpatient medical care, they may be receiving treatment under protocols that I have written. So, consider it arrogant if you will, but I feel obligated to utilize my extensive knowledge to benefit others, within certain constraints of law and ethics. And yes, sometimes I get overzealous.

Three statements categorically wrong:

1. Audiologist---not even close to diagnosing anything other than hearing loss.
2. First of all, the term "good chiropractor" is an oxymoron.
3. I’m pretty sure I have more than just a clue, having spent over 30 years cleaning up their disasters. (referring to chiropractors) How many times in 30 years did you have to clean up disasters from chiropractors? What percentage of your time would you estimate?

[golfing eagles]

Three statements categorically wrong:

1. Audiologist---not even close to diagnosing anything other than hearing loss.
2. First of all, the term "good chiropractor" is an oxymoron.
3. I’m pretty sure I have more than just a clue, having spent over 30 years cleaning up their disasters. (referring to chiropractors) How many times in 30 years did you have to clean up disasters from chiropractors? What percentage of your time would you estimate?

OK

1) I'll amend the statement to 99% cannot diagnose anything other than hearing loss. One of the first steps in assessing vertigo is an MRI. An audiologist is not even permitted to order an MRI (unless the rules have changed in the last 8 years), so how can they even begin to diagnose anything?

2) Withdrawn. It was a hyperbole intended to draw attention to the mistake of starting the assessment of a problem with a chiropractor rather than a qualified doctor. Apologies, especially to 2 good friends of mine that are chiropractors

3) I stand by that assertion. How many disasters, how many dead patients does it take to qualify as not being "categorically wrong"???? I don't measure unnecessary deaths in "percentage of time"

[Cybersprings]

No offense, and I'm really not looking for a p!$$!ng match, but please point out a statement that is "categorically wrong". Some may be exaggerations to make a point, but overall they are accurate. You cannot hunt for rare exceptions and hold that up as a standard. I think I have been pretty consistent---I acknowledged referring patients to chiropractors and other ancillary services when appropriate, but pretty harshly warn against getting evaluated by those fringe practitioners first. Sorry if I ruffle some feathers, but the public sometimes just doesn't "get it". There are a lot of quacks and snake oil salesmen out there, and if I can do some small part to protect the innocent, I'm going to take it.

As far as "having a degree and being retired" goes, I think my career is a bit more than that. For all anyone knows, when they play Dr. Google they may be quoting me from the content that I myself have written. When they need inpatient medical care, they may be receiving treatment under protocols that I have written. So, consider it arrogant if you will, but I feel obligated to utilize my extensive knowledge to benefit others, within certain constraints of law and ethics. And yes, sometimes I get overzealous.


My apologizies (very seriously) for minimizing your career and your benefits to medicine. If not thing else, maybe this thread gave you an opportunity to share a small glimpse of your accomplishments that we should be appreciative of. Too be honest, I still don't know specifics, but thank you for your contributions to the medical community and our benefit.

You say, "You cannot hunt for rare exceptions and hold that up as a standard." I believe that is EXACTLY what you are doing regarding chiropractors. Is only one of us held to that standard?


And I did not hunt for a rare exception. I googled what an audiologist did, I saw the Mayo clinic as the first result and assumed that would be a reputable source (but what doctors can you really trust???:a20::a20::a20:) and posted the result which contradicted your emphatic statement. I didn't try to match my medical knowledge and experience with yours, I used the medical knowledge and experience of what most people think is a reputable institution.

[golfing eagles]

My apologizies (very seriously) for minimizing your career and your benefits to medicine. If not thing else, maybe this thread gave you an opportunity to share a small glimpse of your accomplishments that we should be appreciative of. Too be honest, I still don't know specifics, but thank you for your contributions to the medical community and our benefit.

You say, "You cannot hunt for rare exceptions and hold that up as a standard." I believe that is EXACTLY what you are doing regarding chiropractors. Is only one of us held to that standard?


And I did not hunt for a rare exception. I googled what an audiologist did, I saw the Mayo clinic as the first result and assumed that would be a reputable source (but what doctors can you really trust???:a20::a20::a20:) and posted the result which contradicted your emphatic statement. I didn't try to match my medical knowledge and experience with yours, I used the medical knowledge and experience of what most people think is a reputable institution.

Looks like responses "crossed in the mail" again. Mayo Clinic is a great place, but their structure, protocols and procedures are not the mainstream. They may have glorified audiologists with more capabilities than Podunk, Iowa. But I assure you they would be few and far between. Additionally, how many audiologists do you think even want to take on the responsibility of managing a new, undiagnosed vertiginous patient?

An example---Sloan Kettering is a great oncology institution, but everyone there is on an "experimental" protocol (I did a month rotation there). Unfortunately they almost killed the 23 year old daughter of my mother's friend years ago. Why? She had stage 3B Hodgkin's lymphoma, which had at the time a 96% CURE rate with traditional chemo regimen and mantle + extended Y external beam radiation. Instead they put her on some weird protocol that was ineffective. Fortunately she responded to salvage therapy but had an unnecessarily rough time of it.

[Cybersprings]

OK

1) I'll amend the statement to 99% cannot diagnose anything other than hearing loss. One of the first steps in assessing vertigo is an MRI. An audiologist is not even permitted to order an MRI (unless the rules have changed in the last 8 years), so how can they even begin to diagnose anything?

2) Withdrawn. It was a hyperbole intended to draw attention to the mistake of starting the assessment of a problem with a chiropractor rather than a qualified doctor. Apologies, especially to 2 good friends of mine that are chiropractors

3) I stand by that assertion. How many disasters, how many dead patients does it take to qualify as not being "categorically wrong"???? I don't measure unnecessary deaths in "percentage of time"

1. You are an esteemed doctor. You then make the statement that 99% of audiologists cannot diagnose anything other than hearing loss. You or your proctologist got that statistic from the same place. But people listen to you. And that is why I keep pushing back. Can you please provide any source for that data. If you say your extensive experience, that cannot cover even 1 tenth of 1% of the audiologists/audiology departments.
3. Your assertion was that you"spent your career cleaning up after chiropractors. Either that statement is completely false, or your assertion that much of what we find on google or the procedures we go through at the doctors office were developed by you is completely false. No one disagrees that their are unnecessary deaths( I don't think) and that one is too many. But that was not the assertion. You spent your career cleaning up after chiropractors. I would be a HUGE sum of money that you cleaned up after more medical malpractice in your 30 years than you did cleaning up after chiropractors(maybe none that were as serious as the one case with your nurse). I completely get hyperbole. But, you put it out there in the exact same way you put out there all the steps you should go through for the diagnosis of the cause of vertigo or your 99% statistic above. Was that intended as fact or hyperbole? If it was hyperbole, are you actually using hyperbole to prove a point?

I hope 100% of the people can wade through what you write and get to what you really mean, because I am sure your heart is in the right place. If I went to a doctor and got an xray/MRI and diagnosis, every time I threw my back out, I would be a very poor man, and I would be in pain/incapacitated for much longer than I need to be.
If someone posts that they are looking for a good chiropractor because they are new to the villages, a public service post to make sure a chiropractor is what you need and strongly consider getting a medical opinion first because this is what happened to a nurse patient of mine would be great. You get to help prevent the same thing from re-occurring but you haven't made statements which could preclude people from getting the help that they need. And if you say that no one needs a chiropractor, I will add that to my list of categorically wrong statements.

[Cybersprings]

Looks like responses "crossed in the mail" again. Mayo Clinic is a great place, but their structure, protocols and procedures are not the mainstream. They may have glorified audiologists with more capabilities than Podunk, Iowa. But I assure you they would be few and far between. Additionally, how many audiologists do you think even want to take on the responsibility of managing a new, undiagnosed vertiginous patient?



I didn't post this as refutation to your point about how many can do it, because it is from Audiology associations and organizations. This is to respond to your point that they wouldn't want to. It looks like, from the top resonses on google, that many will welcome you. several sites state that they may/will refer you to a specialist if they are unable to diagnose or see something beyond their capability (paraphrased).

Again, let's look at the big picture. You are more right than me on this obviously with your very clear steps outlined in one of your posts. I stated earlier a way that you could push the person to the correct medical professional without incorrect statements or denigrating.

You keep trying to keep people healthy and I will continue to push back when you make blanket statements that are unnecessary. People will stay healthy (because of you) and maybe every now and then you will think about what you post and the weight it carries. Win win



Why Should You See an Audiologist for Balance Issues?

Advanced Hearing Care
Audiology - Alamogordo, NM - Advanced Hearing Care (https://ahcnm.com) › why-should-you-see-an-audiolog...
what percentage of audiologists can diagnose balance disorders from ahcnm.com
Jul 29, 2022 — Audiologists are experts at diagnosing and treating conditions that affect the inner ear, and this includes balance. So, if you are experiencing ...

Consumers and Patients - American Academy of Audiology

American Academy of Audiology
American Academy of Audiology (https://www.audiology.org) › consumers-and-patients
what percentage of audiologists can diagnose balance disorders from American Academy of Audiology (http://www.audiology.org)
Audiologists are health-care professionals who evaluate, diagnose, treat, and manage hearing loss, tinnitus, and balance disorders in newborns, children, and ...

Recognizing Balance Awareness Week

Associated Audiologists
Kansas City Audiologists: Hearing Center with Top Hearing Doctors (https://www.hearingyourbest.com) › recognizing-balan...
what percentage of audiologists can diagnose balance disorders from Kansas City Audiologists: Hearing Center with Top Hearing Doctors (http://www.hearingyourbest.com)
The good news is that 90 percent of equilibrium disorders can be successfully treated once they have been accurately diagnosed. For more information about ...
‎Recognizing Balance... · ‎Dizziness And Balance Issues... · ‎Risks Of Dizziness And...

What Is an Audiologist

American Academy of Audiology
American Academy of Audiology (https://www.audiology.org) › consumers-and-patients
Audiologists are the primary health-care professionals who evaluate, diagnose, treat, and manage hearing loss and balance disorders in individuals of all ...
‎Five Reasons To See An... · ‎How Can An Audiologist Treat... · ‎Terms You May Hear At Your...

Balance Disorders

The British Academy of Audiology
https://www.baaudiology.org › Public
Audiology professionals are involved in helping to diagnose problems with the vestibular system. Assessment of this system usually involves detailed discussions ...

Who Should I See for Dizziness and Balance Problems?

Associated Audiologists
Kansas City Audiologists: Hearing Center with Top Hearing Doctors (https://www.hearingyourbest.com) › who-should-i-see-...
There are many health professionals who can diagnose and treat dizziness and balance problems. Audiologists must undergo extensive training in hearing and ...

Can An Audiologist Help With Balance Issues?

Colorado Ear Care
https://coloradoearcare.com › can-an-audiologist-help-...
Jul 30, 2021 — Yes! The audiology professionals at Colorado Ear Care specialize in treating issues related to balance and dizziness. Our training goes far ...
‎Colorado Ear Care Provides... · ‎Rotary Chair Testing · ‎Videonystagmography (vng)

About Balance Disorders

Advanced Hearing & Balance Center
https://www.ahbctexas.com › about-balance-disorders
The good news is that 90% of the time, these disorders can be successfully treated once they have been properly diagnosed. Schedule an appointment today for a ...
‎Balance, Dizziness And... · ‎Symptoms And Complaints · ‎Diagnostic Tests

[ton80]

To Golfing Eagles and CyberSpring, I offer a hopefully useful summary on audiologists and Balance Issues.

Based on a Google search of various topics, my observation (Non Doctor) follows:

1. Golfing Eagles Post #3 regarding the sequence of diagnosis steps basically matches what Mayo and others recommend.

2. Audiologists are not medical physicians and therefore do not provide medical-based treatment such as surgery or medication. They can help with doing the tests prescribed by a physician.

3. Audiologists and other rehabilitation professionals can help improve your balance and reduce dizziness and bothersome symptoms. Vestibular rehabilitation may include exercises with specific movements of the head, eyes, and/or body. Certain types of dizziness may be treated with repositioning procedures. (Epley maneuver?)

In summary, Audiologists have a role but are not the primary place to start. They can help with the testing and non medical treatment.

[golfing eagles]

I didn't post this as refutation to your point about how many can do it, because it is from Audiology associations and organizations. This is to respond to your point that they wouldn't want to. It looks like, from the top resonses on google, that many will welcome you. several sites state that they may/will refer you to a specialist if they are unable to diagnose or see something beyond their capability (paraphrased).

Again, let's look at the big picture. You are more right than me on this obviously with your very clear steps outlined in one of your posts. I stated earlier a way that you could push the person to the correct medical professional without incorrect statements or denigrating.

You keep trying to keep people healthy and I will continue to push back when you make blanket statements that are unnecessary. People will stay healthy (because of you) and maybe every now and then you will think about what you post and the weight it carries. Win win



Why Should You See an Audiologist for Balance Issues?

Advanced Hearing Care
Audiology - Alamogordo, NM - Advanced Hearing Care (https://ahcnm.com) › why-should-you-see-an-audiolog...
what percentage of audiologists can diagnose balance disorders from ahcnm.com
Jul 29, 2022 — Audiologists are experts at diagnosing and treating conditions that affect the inner ear, and this includes balance. So, if you are experiencing ...

Consumers and Patients - American Academy of Audiology

American Academy of Audiology
American Academy of Audiology (https://www.audiology.org) › consumers-and-patients
what percentage of audiologists can diagnose balance disorders from American Academy of Audiology (http://www.audiology.org)
Audiologists are health-care professionals who evaluate, diagnose, treat, and manage hearing loss, tinnitus, and balance disorders in newborns, children, and ...

Recognizing Balance Awareness Week

Associated Audiologists
Kansas City Audiologists: Hearing Center with Top Hearing Doctors (https://www.hearingyourbest.com) › recognizing-balan...
what percentage of audiologists can diagnose balance disorders from Kansas City Audiologists: Hearing Center with Top Hearing Doctors (http://www.hearingyourbest.com)
The good news is that 90 percent of equilibrium disorders can be successfully treated once they have been accurately diagnosed. For more information about ...
‎Recognizing Balance... · ‎Dizziness And Balance Issues... · ‎Risks Of Dizziness And...

What Is an Audiologist

American Academy of Audiology
American Academy of Audiology (https://www.audiology.org) › consumers-and-patients
Audiologists are the primary health-care professionals who evaluate, diagnose, treat, and manage hearing loss and balance disorders in individuals of all ...
‎Five Reasons To See An... · ‎How Can An Audiologist Treat... · ‎Terms You May Hear At Your...

Balance Disorders

The British Academy of Audiology
https://www.baaudiology.org › Public
Audiology professionals are involved in helping to diagnose problems with the vestibular system. Assessment of this system usually involves detailed discussions ...

Who Should I See for Dizziness and Balance Problems?

Associated Audiologists
Kansas City Audiologists: Hearing Center with Top Hearing Doctors (https://www.hearingyourbest.com) › who-should-i-see-...
There are many health professionals who can diagnose and treat dizziness and balance problems. Audiologists must undergo extensive training in hearing and ...

Can An Audiologist Help With Balance Issues?

Colorado Ear Care
https://coloradoearcare.com › can-an-audiologist-help-...
Jul 30, 2021 — Yes! The audiology professionals at Colorado Ear Care specialize in treating issues related to balance and dizziness. Our training goes far ...
‎Colorado Ear Care Provides... · ‎Rotary Chair Testing · ‎Videonystagmography (vng)

About Balance Disorders

Advanced Hearing & Balance Center
https://www.ahbctexas.com › about-balance-disorders
The good news is that 90% of the time, these disorders can be successfully treated once they have been properly diagnosed. Schedule an appointment today for a ...
‎Balance, Dizziness And... · ‎Symptoms And Complaints · ‎Diagnostic Tests

I had already checked out those sites as well. The profession is probably evolving, but my gestalt is still that very few community practicing audiologists would want to take this on.

Now here's an interesting idea: There are other physicians on this site, so I ask them to answer the following if they would.
1) How many times have you referred a vertiginous patient to an audiologist?
2) How many time would you recommend a patient with hip pain see a chiropractor first?

I think the answers will be telling

[Cybersprings]

To Golfing Eagles and CyberSpring, I offer a hopefully useful summary on audiologists and Balance Issues.

Based on a Google search of various topics, my observation (Non Doctor) follows:

1. Golfing Eagles Post #3 regarding the sequence of diagnosis steps basically matches what Mayo and others recommend.

2. Audiologists are not medical physicians and therefore do not provide medical-based treatment such as surgery or medication. They can help with doing the tests prescribed by a physician.

3. Audiologists and other rehabilitation professionals can help improve your balance and reduce dizziness and bothersome symptoms. Vestibular rehabilitation may include exercises with specific movements of the head, eyes, and/or body. Certain types of dizziness may be treated with repositioning procedures. (Epley maneuver?)

In summary, Audiologists have a role but are not the primary place to start. They can help with the testing and non medical treatment.

ton80, thanks for the post. I did have to chuckle, because I think as you were writing your post backing up Golfing Eagles with Mayo Clinic reference, Golfing Eagles was typing his post saying Mayo is a little out there.

And at the same time, I was writing my post trying to do what you were trying (I think). Your post was much better, but you didn't have any mea culpas to do like I did.:laugh:

I hope Golfing Eagles (and others) can take from my post that I know he is right in his main point. I have been arguing form over function.

[Cybersprings]

I had already checked out those sites as well. The profession is probably evolving, but my gestalt is still that very few community practicing audiologists would want to take this on.

Now here's an interesting idea: There are other physicians on this site, so I ask them to answer the following if they would.
1) How many times have you referred a vertiginous patient to an audiologist?
2) How many time would you recommend a patient with hip pain see a chiropractor first?

I think the answers will be telling

I think you missed my point in the middle just before the list of sites.
The response to your survey could hammer in the point, but I really have already conceded it.

[golfing eagles]

I think youh missed my point in the middle just before the list of sites.
The response to your survey could hammer in the point, but I really have already conceded it.

My bad. I’m still recovering from COVID and not 100%

[Cybersprings]

My bad. I’m still recovering from COVID and not 100%

I am sorry to hear that. I hope you feel better soon.
By the way, my chiropractor has a great adjustment to prevent COVID. Let me know if you need his name or a referral.

[golfing eagles]

I am sorry to hear that. I hope you feel better soon.
By the way, my chiropractor has a great adjustment to prevent COVID. Let me know if you need his name or a referral.

Thanks, but I have a voodoo witch doctor on speed dial 😂😂😂

[blueash]

Ok, I'll bite. Dr google can give you a very good idea of the symptoms of benign paroxysmal positional vertigo. Why even the Mayo Clinic (https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/vertigo/symptoms-causes/syc-20370055) gives you pretty much all you need to determine if your dizziness fits that diagnosis
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/vertigo/symptoms-causes/syc-20370055
Many other sites will also walk you through the presentation of BPPV.

If your story fits that diagnosis, yes self diagnosis. And you don't have any of the other worrisome accompanying symptoms... I have no problem with you going to you tube and seeing how to do at home Epleys for a few days to see if you get relief.

Every patient does not need an MRI for every symptom. If all you have is BPPV and a couple days of home therapy works... go on with your life without seeing a doctor or having an MRI.

Now, having said that, in our age group a percentage of persons will have unexpected findings on the MRI, up to and including brain tumors.

[golfing eagles]

Ok, I'll bite. Dr google can give you a very good idea of the symptoms of benign paroxysmal positional vertigo. Why even the Mayo Clinic (https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/vertigo/symptoms-causes/syc-20370055) gives you pretty much all you need to determine if your dizziness fits that diagnosis
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/vertigo/symptoms-causes/syc-20370055
Many other sites will also walk you through the presentation of BPPV.

If your story fits that diagnosis, yes self diagnosis. And you don't have any of the other worrisome accompanying symptoms... I have no problem with you going to you tube and seeing how to do at home Epleys for a few days to see if you get relief.

Every patient does not need an MRI for every symptom. If all you have is BPPV and a couple days of home therapy works... go on with your life without seeing a doctor or having an MRI.

Now, having said that, in our age group a percentage of persons will have unexpected findings on the MRI, up to and including brain tumors.

Good answer!

[rogerk]

It can work if done correctly AND depending on the cause of the vertigo. There is a great Doctor in Celebration Florida. The practice is: Vertigo and Balance Treatment, Florida Ear and Balance - (321) 939-3000

They virtually eliminated my vertigo. It is not the most fun treatment but it utilizes the Eply Chair to correctly identify and treat most causes of Vertigo. It works and is not fake science.

This is the only location in the Southeast that has an Eply chair. Call them and draw your own conclusions.

[mtdjed]

Unbelievable how two people hijack a forum. Your first posts said everything you needed to say. The rest is purely self-serving.

[mtdjed]

My bad. I’m still recovering from COVID and not 100%

Unbelievable how two people hijack a forum. Your first posts said everything you needed to say. The rest is purely self-serving.

Golfing Eagles. Sorry for your COVID. I just had my first Covid after a European River Cruise. Fortunately, I did not get it on the cruise and secondly fortunate that I tested for it early, got Paxlovid and had no major symptoms.

Obviously, you know a lot about Vertigo. One of my questions is whether you ever had severe Vertigo?

[margaretmattson]

No offense, and I'm really not looking for a p!$$!ng match, but please point out a statement that is "categorically wrong". Some may be exaggerations to make a point, but overall they are accurate. You cannot hunt for rare exceptions and hold that up as a standard. I think I have been pretty consistent---I acknowledged referring patients to chiropractors and other ancillary services when appropriate, but pretty harshly warn against getting evaluated by those fringe practitioners first. Sorry if I ruffle some feathers, but the public sometimes just doesn't "get it". There are a lot of quacks and snake oil salesmen out there, and if I can do some small part to protect the innocent, I'm going to take it.

As far as "having a degree and being retired" goes, I think my career is a bit more than that. For all anyone knows, when they play Dr. Google they may be quoting me from the content that I myself have written. When they need inpatient medical care, they may be receiving treatment under protocols that I have written. So, consider it arrogant if you will, but I feel obligated to utilize my extensive knowledge to benefit others, within certain constraints of law and ethics. And yes, sometimes I get overzealous. I thank you for taking the time to educate people on this forum. I do not place emotions into your words and find each of your posts thorough. Why people want to argue with an expert is beyond me. Everyone is entitled to get a second opinion. That second opinion should NOT be a layperson who googles something and decides. "Hey, I am now an expert!" How many times have we been told DO NOT TRUST THE INTERNET? If you doubt what GE says, get a second opinion from a MEDICAL DOCTOR.

BTW: I find you bedside manner fine. I would rather have a doctor who is engaged in each of his patients and will be harsh when necessary. Who wants a doctor that holds your hand and tells you only what you want to hear? And says, Oh! You googled I was wrong? My bad! Thanks for updating me. Good luck recovering with a doctor like that!

Please THINK before you go against an expert. Any layperson can find the answer they WANT on the internet. It doesn't mean it is the correct one.

[golfing eagles]

Golfing Eagles. Sorry for your COVID. I just had my first Covid after a European River Cruise. Fortunately, I did not get it on the cruise and secondly fortunate that I tested for it early, got Paxlovid and had no major symptoms.

Obviously, you know a lot about Vertigo. One of my questions is whether you ever had severe Vertigo?

Thanks, finally improving, today is day #9, but I didn't start Paxlovid (for what it's worth) until day 4. The absolute worst was such a severe sore throat that I could only swallow with intense pain. Now just down to fatigue. Still very hard to assess the efficacy of Paxlovid, the success rate is all over the board. I have to admit it was a bit disconcerting when my pulse ox dropped to 84%, but I question the accuracy of that reading since I didn't have any dyspnea. Hope you are getting over it as well.

No, I never had vertigo. Unfortunately, it is difficult to treat when it has an element of chronicity. You can try Epley maneuvers and pump the patient full of meclizine, but it usually recurs. More often I have seen the acute form----acute viral labyrinthitis. Almost anyone can diagnose it---you literally are fine one second and falling to the floor the next. It's more severe than the chronic variety, but also self limited. Best not to get either in the first place.

[golfing eagles]

I thank you for taking the time to educate people on this forum. I do not place emotions into your words and find each of your posts thorough. Why people want to argue with an expert is beyond me. Everyone is entitled to get a second opinion. That second opinion should NOT be a layperson who googles something and decides. "Hey, I am now an expert!" How many times have we been told DO NOT TRUST THE INTERNET? If you doubt what GE says, get a second opinion from a MEDICAL DOCTOR.

BTW: I find you bedside manner fine. I would rather have a doctor who is engaged in each of his patients and will be harsh when necessary. Who wants a doctor that holds your hand and tells you only what you want to hear? And says, Oh! You googled I was wrong? My bad! Thanks for updating me. Good luck recovering with a doctor like that!

Please THINK before you go against an expert. Any layperson can find the answer they WANT on the internet. It doesn't mean it is the correct one.

Thanks, but I'm no saint. I often post responses in an insulting manner, usually intentional for shock value, but also occasionally in anger in response to those who are determined to prove they are idiots.

There is an allure and false air of authority to the internet. It seduces otherwise rational individuals into believing that their 5 minute google search makes them an expert. They fail to realize that much of the content is unverified, and that which is from a legitimate site is often "dumbed down" to the point of losing its true meaning as to make it more understandable to the average person. It is not written for professionals.

Medicine frequently does not follow the rules of common sense and logic, some things are opposite from what one might expect. It is almost impossible to understand medicine without knowing some underlying principles. Then, there is always the difference between what the academicians think and write and what actually is done in the real world.

Most here on this site mean well, but I agree there are some that want to argue with an expert. Arguing an opinion is one thing, fine. Arguing medical facts, well, that generally turns out embarrassing, even if that person doesn't realize it. But like I said, I'm no saint and I'm happy to call them out.

[deborahcme]

I had a vertigo attack about two years ago. I would not have described it as dizziness. It was full on not being able to walk with safety as the room felt like it was spinning around me. Even when lying down, I felt like the bed was tilting crazily and would soon dump me on the floor! Husband took me to ER who referred me to Ear Nose and Throat doctor. After doing a few diagnostic tests, they determined that I did have vertigo and not some other neurological condition. They performed the Epley procedure and taught me how to do it myself in case vertigo returned. It has not. That said, if it does, I'd still err on the side of caution and seek additional testing.

[neilbcox]

My Husband suffers from dizziness constantly someone said something about the Epley Maneuver. Has anyone done this before ? Did it work ? and if so can you recommend a doctor down here in the villages area.

Have a doctor of audiology check it out. The Villages Healthcare has several.

[Cybersprings]

Have a doctor of audiology check it out. The Villages Healthcare has several.

I am not sure if this was meant to be funny or not.
If it was humor, it is very funny.
If it is not an attempt at humor, I am going to guess that you posted after reading the initial post without reading the the whole thread (the one I hijacked).
If that is the case, I would go back and read the whole thread for some great entertainment, and see why I say it was very funny (truly not intended as an insult).

For Golfing Eagles....round 2???

[Cybersprings]

I thank you for taking the time to educate people on this forum. I do not place emotions into your words and find each of your posts thorough. Why people want to argue with an expert is beyond me. Everyone is entitled to get a second opinion. That second opinion should NOT be a layperson who googles something and decides. "Hey, I am now an expert!" How many times have we been told DO NOT TRUST THE INTERNET? If you doubt what GE says, get a second opinion from a MEDICAL DOCTOR.

BTW: I find you bedside manner fine. I would rather have a doctor who is engaged in each of his patients and will be harsh when necessary. Who wants a doctor that holds your hand and tells you only what you want to hear? And says, Oh! You googled I was wrong? My bad! Thanks for updating me. Good luck recovering with a doctor like that!

Please THINK before you go against an expert. Any layperson can find the answer they WANT on the internet. It doesn't mean it is the correct one.

I never once argued with his point regarding what the person should do.
I never thought nor in any way claimed that I was an expert.
Since I hijacked the thread, you have lots of content to use. Please point out a single statement I made that was not 100 % correct.
I will wait....

[golfing eagles]

I am not sure if this was meant to be funny or not.
If it was humor, it is very funny.
If it is not an attempt at humor, I am going to guess that you posted after reading the initial post without reading the the whole thread (the one I hijacked).
If that is the case, I would go back and read the whole thread for some great entertainment, and see why I say it was very funny (truly not intended as an insult).

For Golfing Eagles....round 2???

If you insist, but why do you want to dig yourself an even deeper hole?

[Cybersprings]

If you insist, but why do you want to dig yourself an even deeper hole?

///

[golfing eagles]

I was trying to be humorous and get along.
I am sorry that got missed in translation.
As far as digging an even deeper hole, same request for you as MM: you have a lot of content in this thread to use, please point to any statement(s) I made that were not 100% accurate.
I will wait....

So was I :1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl:

[margaretmattson]

I never once argued with his point regarding what the person should do.
I never thought nor in any way claimed that I was an expert.
Since I hijacked the thread, you have lots of content to use. Please point out a single statement I made that was not 100 % correct.
I will wait....I read the entire thread. There were several people who argued with GE. My post is a general statement that is not directed to anyone specific. My ideology is this: Dont trust what you read on the internet when your life is in danger. I can see hundreds of ways that can go wrong. Go to a medical doctor and get a MEDICAL diagnosis.

[Cybersprings]

So was I :1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl:

In that case, my apologies. I will delete my previous post.
I hope you are feeling better Doc.

[golfing eagles]

In that case, my apologies. I will delete my previous post.
I hope you are feeling better Doc.

No need---this is simply play time, nothing serious going on except for medical content.

[Cybersprings]

I read the entire thread. There were several people who argued with GE. My post is a general statement that is not directed to anyone specific. My ideology is this: Dont trust what you read on the internet when your life is in danger. I can see hundreds of ways that can go wrong. Go to a medical doctor and get a MEDICAL diagnosis.

I agree with your ideology 100% (not that that really makes a difference).

Not sure the OP's life is in danger, but your point is still valid.

No one else argued with GE. Lots of people posted their experiences and some recommendations, but from reading them, those with recommendations hadn't appeared to have read the whole thread before posting, which is very often the case and is not intended to insult them (many people just want to jump in and help, and didn't know the Doc had already laid out an excellent recommendation).
So, really the only person your post could have reasonably applied to is me. I argued in many posts with him (never about his advice).
So again, I ask for any thing I said that was not 100% accurate.
If you cannot provide any example, your post to which I responded has no value and is just plain wrong. If you want to say something along the lines of "I wish people would stop nitpicking statements people/experts make when their primary point is so on target" then I would have to drop my head and take my lumps. Or "some people should read the entire thread before providing recommendations because an expert may have already provided the right answer, that would be reasonable (but would not apply to the people who gave personal experience without providing recommendations).

But to insinuate that I or anyone else claimed to be an expert and argued with the expert and got anything wrong would be complete non-sense, at least as far as this thread goes.

[margaretmattson]

I agree with your ideology 100% (not that that really makes a difference).

Not sure the OP's life is in danger, but your point is still valid.

No one else argued with GE. Lots of people posted their experiences and some recommendations, but from reading them, those with recommendations hadn't appeared to have read the whole thread before posting, which is very often the case and is not intended to insult them (many people just want to jump in and help, and didn't know the Doc had already laid out an excellent recommendation).
So, really the only person your post could have reasonably applied to is me. I argued in many posts with him (never about his advice).
So again, I ask for any thing I said that was not 100% accurate.
If you cannot provide any example, your post to which I responded has no value and is just plain wrong. If you want to say something along the lines of "I wish people would stop nitpicking statements people/experts make when their primary point is so on target" then I would have to drop my head and take my lumps. Or "some people should read the entire thread before providing recommendations because an expert may have already provided the right answer, that would be reasonable (but would not apply to the people who gave personal experience without providing recommendations).

But to insinuate that I or anyone else claimed to be an expert and argued with the expert and got anything wrong would be complete non-sense, at least as far as this thread goes. I will be more careful in the wording of my posts. I only meant to make a general statement (As explained above) I never meant harm.

[Cybersprings]

I will be more careful in the wording of my posts. I only meant to make a general statement (As explained above) I never meant harm.

Thanks for your post. No real (or otherwise) harm was done. As the Doc said in his post, nothing serious is really going on here.
I apologize that my post came across so snarky.

[scooterstang]

While in the service. I went to the base pool that had a 3 miter diving board. I was in the middle of a back flip when I heard my last name called out and dumb me cranked my head towards the voice, and Bam my right ear hit the water flat and busted my tympanic membrane. I was in terrible pain and things were super loud. I went to Wilford hall medical clinic in San Antonio and they diagnosed my issue. They said the membrane would grow back but there would be scar tissue and most likely I would loose a lot of hearing in that ear! I might also get vertigo real bad. I have only had vertigo a few times since then but I am super glad that it is not a more regular thing because it puts you down and is the worse feeling. I have never heard of the Epley proceedure before today(guess back in 78 it wasn't a thing)

[Aviva]

It took me awhile to get to the right type of specialist to find me the right person to treat vertigo. A vestibular physiotherapist is trained to assess your inner ear organs with positional testing which puts your head in different angles to try reproduce your vertigo while carefully noting the related nystagmus or patterns of eye reflexes.
I have Left Particle Vetigo so for me the Epley Maneuver works wonders. I know there are ways to do it yourself but I prefer the Vestibular Physiotherapist do it while he is monitoring my eyes so he can know the particles have moved away. Its been a game changer for me.

My Husband suffers from dizziness constantly someone said something about the Epley Maneuver. Has anyone done this before ? Did it work ? and if so can you recommend a doctor down here in the villages area.

[bp243]

No offense, and I'm really not looking for a p!$$!ng match, but please point out a statement that is "categorically wrong". Some may be exaggerations to make a point, but overall they are accurate. You cannot hunt for rare exceptions and hold that up as a standard. I think I have been pretty consistent---I acknowledged referring patients to chiropractors and other ancillary services when appropriate, but pretty harshly warn against getting evaluated by those fringe practitioners first. Sorry if I ruffle some feathers, but the public sometimes just doesn't "get it". There are a lot of quacks and snake oil salesmen out there, and if I can do some small part to protect the innocent, I'm going to take it.

As far as "having a degree and being retired" goes, I think my career is a bit more than that. For all anyone knows, when they play Dr. Google they may be quoting me from the content that I myself have written. When they need inpatient medical care, they may be receiving treatment under protocols that I have written. So, consider it arrogant if you will, but I feel obligated to utilize my extensive knowledge to benefit others, within certain constraints of law and ethics. And yes, sometimes I get overzealous.

Thank you for taking the time to share your knowledge and, in particular, your compassion for helping others. Your thoughts are appreciated. My vertigo issues occur when tracking movement over an extended period like scrolling on the Internet or watching a video with lots of movement. Is that something that I live with or is there a specialist to recommend who might best evaluate that issue?