Best Milk Shake in The Villages

[jdsl1998]

Where is the best milk shake in The Villages or on the edges?
Thanks

[texasfal]

Steak N Shake. Hands down.

[Chopper]

I agree with Steak n Shake. They also have great milkshakes at Chick-Fil-A.

[rubicon]

Is there such a thing as a bad milkshake

[KayakerNC]

Is there such a thing as a bad milkshake
Beware of concoctions on the menu that are just called "Shakes". (Talking about you, Mickey and King.)

Another vote for Steak 'n Shake. Strawberry, yumm. :icon_hungry:

[momesu]

Definitely Steak 'n Shake!!!!! None better.

Suzanne

[gump1]

:BigApplause:Easily Steak 'n Shake!
Do they still do Happy Hour in the afternoons?

[brostholder]

steak N shake strawberry........perfection in a glass!

[momesu]

:BigApplause:Easily Steak 'n Shake!
Do they still do Happy Hour in the afternoons?

Yep!

Suzanne

[Skip]

Where is the best milk shake in The Villages or on the edges?
Thanks

I say "on the edges". :mmmm:

Skip

[hedoman]

Johnny Rockets Chocolate Peanut butter love 'em but then I pay for it....not talking money.....they are soooooo rich...

[aln]

Has anyone tried the BOSTON MALT(or shake) at Ollies'?

It's a malt of your flavor choice with a sundae in it, again your favorite flavor.

:icon_hungry:

[under55]

Just had a malt and double smokehouse cheeseburger from Johnny Rocktets both were fantastic.

[CTgolfer]

I hadn't had a milkshake in over 3 years, so after this thread of conversation, I thought I should try Steak n' Shake's milkshake. Ordered peanut butter with chocolate ice cream base... it was all right. Nothing that would make me run back before another 3 years have gone by.

[graciegirl]

I hadn't had a milkshake in over 3 years, so after this thread of conversation, I thought I should try Steak n' Shake's milkshake. Ordered peanut butter with chocolate ice cream base... it was all right. Nothing that would make me run back before another 3 years have gone by.

I was gonna check it out. Glad you did it so I didn't have to.

Kinda glad. Maybe I will have to check out the double malt as a public service.

[Reprobate]

The last time I was in Steak & Shake (a few weeks ago) I had a white chocolate shake. It was excellent.

[coffeebean]

I'm craving a strawberry milkshake. Wonder why???

[joanofarctv]

Wow...now you have my mouth watering for something tall and strawberry....steak and shake here I come :icon_twisted:

[Dennis Ga]

After reading the posts here, I know I am coming to the right place. Got to have a really good milk shake. Too late tonight but the sun will be up soon.

[TERPMAN7375]

Steak and Shake

[sralph99]

Steak & Shake is the best. Also try an Egg Cream at Brooklyn Water Bagels.

[Villages PL]

Mmmmm good! Now which is the best hospital for heart by pass surgery? :loco:

[rirlam]

Another vote for Stake & Shake strawberry shakes

[skyguy79]

I have tried desperately to avoid this thread simply because I don't want a supernatural force to latch onto my nostrols and float me all the way up to Steak & Shake just to try their shake. Besides, I've had Mickey D's shakes and I find them perfectly creamy and tasty. Now, I'm not saying that Steak & Shake is not better, I'm just saying that the few times I've had a shake in or around TV it's been Mickey D's., and being how their more than satisfying to me, I can't see being dragged away from my own neighborhood near Colony to go all the way to S&B to find that it's not that much better that it's worth it. Maybe someday when I have an urge for steak, but for now I'll stick with Mickey D's for my rare treat of a shake!
http://www.luxist.com/media/2006/04/maccas-milkshake.jpg

[Bill32]

Steak in Shake

[hedoman]

I have tried desperately to avoid this thread simply because I don't want a supernatural force to latch onto my nostrols and float me all the way up to Steak & Shake just to try their shake. Besides, I've had Mickey D's shakes and I find them perfectly creamy and tasty. Now, I'm not saying that Steak & Shake is not better, I'm just saying that the few times I've had a shake in or around TV it's been Mickey D's., and being how their more than satisfying to me, I can't see being dragged away from my own neighborhood near Colony to go all the way to S&B to find that it's not that much better that it's worth it. Maybe someday when I have an urge for steak, but for now I'll stick with Mickey D's for my rare treat of a shake!
http://www.luxist.com/media/2006/04/maccas-milkshake.jpg

Mickey D's shkes are fakes. S&S makes them like they used to in the day. NOT out of a machine......

[JoeC1947]

Steak in Shake

For the REAL meat eater!

[skyguy79]

Mickey D's shkes are fakes. S&S makes them like they used to in the day. NOT out of a machine......:duck:So is a woman's chest sometimes! What difference does the shakes make if they both contain the same basic ingredients? Don't forget, I didn't say that MD's is necessarily better, just more than adequate and convenient for me!

[CaptJohn]

From the web: The ingredients of a McDonald's milkshake are:

Whole milk, sucrose, cream, nonfat milk solids, corn syrup solids, mono and diglycerides, guar gum, imitation vanilla flavor, carrageenan, cellulose gum, vitamin A palmitate.

[Posh 08]

Milk shake fight! :1rotfl:

[skyguy79]

Milk shake fight! :1rotfl:Toga - toga - toga - toga!!!

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-j80cc0BDCQU/T1UOXY4TOzI/AAAAAAAABdY/8LJEtchycL4/s1600/images.jpg

[hedoman]

:duck:So is a woman's chest sometimes! What difference does the shakes make if they both contain the same basic ingredients? Don't forget, I didn't say that MD's is necessarily better, just more than adequate and convenient for me!

YOU ARE kidding right....milk shake vs a woman's chest? How inappropriate
Have you lost sight on reality? real vs fake? MCD's stuff is all full of "stuff" NOT real...... GET real

[JoeC1947]

YOU ARE kidding right....milk shake vs a woman's chest? How inappropriate
Have you lost sight on reality? real vs fake? MCD's stuff is all full of "stuff" NOT real...... GET real

Shake, Shake, Shake.........Shake, Shake, Shake...Shake your booty, Shake your booty.

[Posh 08]

Wouldn't the world be great if "the best milk shake" was the only contention. Have fun guys. Shaken not stirred.

[skyguy79]

YOU ARE kidding right....milk shake vs a woman's chest? How inappropriate
Have you lost sight on reality? real vs fake? MCD's stuff is all full of "stuff" NOT real...... GET realThanks for you attacks! Actually, I wasn't directly comparing a milk shake to a woman's chest nor was I trying to. I was simply making a comparative point in a somewhat humorous way on your statement that you obviously didn't get or why I did it! So I'll spell it out for you.

When you said "Mickey D's shkes are fakes," you came across to me as using your opinion in a direct and rude way of attacking my opinion. Even if it wasn't directed at me I would have still thought it was a tactless way of expressing your opinion, but wouldn't have responded since you are entitled to your opinion, but just not at someone else's expense! So I used what I thought was humor instead of being rude in return to let you know I didn't appreciate what you did.

Should I have used the same tactic you used to respond back to you? No! Absolutely not! That's not my way of doing things as anyone who really knows me may well realize. Anyway, in the future I'll try to remember not to bother communicating directly with you and I ask you for the same favor in return!

[JoeC1947]

Thanks for you attacks! Actually, I wasn't directly comparing a milk shake to a woman's chest nor was I trying to. I was simply making a comparative point in a somewhat humorous way on your statement that you obviously didn't get or why I did it! So I'll spell it out for you.

When you said "Mickey D's shkes are fakes," you came across to me as using your opinion in a direct and rude way of attacking my opinion. Even if it wasn't directed at me I would have still thought it was a tactless way of expressing your opinion, but wouldn't have responded since you are entitled to your opinion, but just not at someone else's expense! So I used what I thought was humor instead of being rude in return to let you know I didn't appreciate what you did.

Should I have used the same tactic you used to respond back to you? No! Absolutely not! That's not my way of doing things as anyone who really knows me may well realize. Anyway, in the future I'll try to remember not to bother communicating directly with you and I ask you for the same favor in return!

Skyguy.... You win the B OO BY prize for that one!:censored::1rotfl:

[skyguy79]

Skyguy.... You win the B OO BY prize for that one!:censored::1rotfl:Be careful! I'm a JoeS1947 and that means we could be related. http://1181drivers.com/smf/Smileys/smileys4smf/snicker.gif

[Posh 08]

I'd be happy to moderate a milk shake summit at johnny rocket on june 18th. If something stronger is wanted, pick the watering hole in LSL. :beer3:

[skyguy79]

I'd be happy to moderate a milk shake summit at johnny rocket on june 18th. If something stronger is wanted, pick the watering hole in LSL. :beer3:I'd suggest Hooters would be a more appropriate place... http://kenoshamargetwo.files.wordpress.com/2012/03/laughing-smiley-pointing.gif?w=497
:throwtomatoes:
...but I wouldn't bother to travel within TV to go to a Hooters let alone Ocala!

[JoeC1947]

[QUOTE=skyguy79;478148]I'd suggest Hooters would be a more appropriate place... http://kenoshamargetwo.files.wordpress.com/2012/03/laughing-smiley-pointing.gif?w=497
:throwtomatoes:
...

Now that right there is funny, I don't care who you are!:1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl:

[Villages PL]

Is there such a thing as a bad milkshake

What makes a milkshake taste so good?

Let's look at McDonald's Chocolate Thick Shake (32 oz. cup)

Calories: 1,160

Sugar: 42 teaspoons (168.0g)

Sodium: 510mg

Total fat: 27 grams

Saturated fat: 16 grams

[Aloha]

I have two favorite places for Milk Shakes. The first one is Steak and Shake for their Strawberry Milk Shake. However, if you really want to taste more of the real Strawberry flavor, Sonic makes a really good one. You can't go wrong with either one.

http://sonicmenu.s3.amazonaws.com/2581351355725.53708.png

[Cantwaittoarrive]

Well I think the best is at my house but if you are looking to buy one then I vote for Steak n Shake

[jblum315]

Another vote for Steak N Shake

[geonagle]

Steak and Shake is the best in my opinion hands down.

I love the side by side chocolate and mocha. Plus the discount during happy hour.

My two cents.

[bluedog103]

I have tried desperately to avoid this thread simply because I don't want a supernatural force to latch onto my nostrols and float me all the way up to Steak & Shake just to try their shake. Besides, I've had Mickey D's shakes and I find them perfectly creamy and tasty. Now, I'm not saying that Steak & Shake is not better, I'm just saying that the few times I've had a shake in or around TV it's been Mickey D's., and being how their more than satisfying to me, I can't see being dragged away from my own neighborhood near Colony to go all the way to S&B to find that it's not that much better that it's worth it. Maybe someday when I have an urge for steak, but for now I'll stick with Mickey D's for my rare treat of a shake!
http://www.luxist.com/media/2006/04/maccas-milkshake.jpg

Senior moment Sky?:1rotfl::jester::loco:

11-25-2012, 05:38 PM
skyguy79
Sage Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Village of Hadley {From NYS Southern Saratoga County}
Posts: 3,884



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I've rarely downplayed any place I've had food from, but I tried Steak and Shakes once. ONCE! The shake was great, but the burgers? Forget it! They were eatable, but I don't think I've ever had burgers that I've liked less! I'd describe them, but I actually found them forgettable... and I love burgers, not like Wimpy does, but I do! As I've stated before though... don't just take my opinion about them... try them and decide for yourself sometime.
__________________

"Try not to take things personally, what people often say is a reflection of them and not you!"
"Some call me insane and that's OK with me. But I'd prefer the term mentally halarious!"
"SMILE... TOMORROW MAY BE EVEN WORSE!"

[petco882]

I give my vote for the best strawberry milkshake to Chick Fil A. Their peach in the summer is to die for.

[Mack184]

I was gonna check it out. Glad you did it so I didn't have to.

Kinda glad. Maybe I will have to check out the double malt as a public service.
Were there no Steak-n-Shakes in your corner of Ohio? We had them in Toledo when I lived there. Don't know what I'll do once we're permanently down south with one near-by. I'll probably weigh 600 pounds. Love S&S!!

[bbatts]

Stake & Shake is great but my final vote is for Johnny Rockets. Now if Johnny Rockets would only do 1/2 price in the afternoons to match Stake & Shake.

[DougB]

I'd suggest Hooters would be a more appropriate place... http://kenoshamargetwo.files.wordpress.com/2012/03/laughing-smiley-pointing.gif?w=497
:throwtomatoes:
...but I wouldn't bother to travel within TV to go to a Hooters let alone Ocala!

Shakes, female breasts, hooters? You got my attention!

[sueandskip]

Ollies

[ROCKETMAN]

Steak and shake-choclate chip cookoe dough or peanut butter cup. $1.88 between 2pm and 4pm weekdays

[ureout]

Steak and Shake....and between 2 to 4 pm bogo