Who should be a judge on Idol?

[Happinow]

Who would you like to see as a Jude on Idol??? I miss Simon, as crude and mean as he could be, but he always told the truth. I'd like to Carrie Underwood judge.

[Taltarzac725]

Who would you like to see as a Judge on Idol??? I miss Simon, as crude and mean as he could be, but he always told the truth. I'd like to see Carrie Underwood judge.

Carrie Underwood would be a good judge on AI. She is probably too busy though.

Mariah Carey would be a great choice. Ozzy Osbourne. Gwneth Paltrow.

[Patty55]

Joe Jackson and Phil Specter (via Skype)

[rubicon]

I don't thinks posters are taking this thread seriously enough...but then we re talking about american Idol I think any three of the guys on Shark Tank would work.

[Patty55]

I'm totally serious. Phil Spector is legendary for developing talent, plus I think he's available (via Skype).

We all know what Joe Jackson is capable of.

[Cgirmo]

Adam Lambert has been in talks with Fox. He has charisma, knowledge of the Idol system and has been in the contestents places not that long ago.

[Bill-n-Brillo]

Graciegirl. :shocked:

Bill :wave:

[asianthree]

elvis

[George Bieniaszek]

Did anyone hear the rumors about AI considering Charlie Sheehan as a potential judge?? Are they serious?

[Patty55]

Adam Lambert has been in talks with Fox. He has charisma, knowledge of the Idol system and has been in the contestents places not that long ago.

Can't stand watching him-that's why I voted 612 times for the other guy.

[Patty55]

elvis

I think he's booked.

[graciegirl]

Graciegirl. :shocked:

Bill :wave:

I don't like American Idol. It is too old for me. ;) I don't hang with wrinklies.

[zcaveman]

Billy Ray Cyrus and Travis Tritt.

[2BNTV]

Brittany Spears or is she to busy with the X Factor?

I have read she pans peolple like Simon Cowell does. Direct and to the point.

[skyguy79]

I nominate the Swedish Chef. You may not understand what he says, but it wouldn't be the first time we couldn't understand what an Idol judge was saying!

http://smileyshack.files.wordpress.com/2010/12/smileyslaughing_lol_dielaughing_100-101.gif

Listen to the Swedish Chef Sing (http://youtu.be/lWohdwiLFbI)

[Dr Winston O Boogie jr]

How about Clive Davis?

[collie1228]

Judge Judy
Rosanne Barr
Simon Cowell

Wouldn't need any contestants to be entertained . . .