Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   Medical and Health Discussion (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/medical-health-discussion-94/)
-   -   slow ambulance service today (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/medical-health-discussion-94/slow-ambulance-service-today-210664/)

Jimmydoodlebug 09-22-2016 11:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fmendelsohn (Post 1292032)
cardiac arrest at rohan today during morning pickleball league. someone called 911 and it took 30 minutes for ambulance to arrive. Did not seem to be in any hurry. Gentleman still in ICU. if it had not been for people on court giving cpr probably a different sad story. This was my second experience with pickleball player going down on courts and slow ambulance service. Medical personel when asked to hurry said "we don't hurry for anyone." Dont get hurt in villages.

Utter fantasy.

HMLRHT1 09-22-2016 01:17 PM

Hi everyone, I'm the person who went down at the Rohan Pickleball courts on Monday morning. I want everyone to know that I greatly and eternally appreciate the response of the Pickleball players, the staff from Rohan Rec Center, the Sumter County EMS and the TVPS. As a past medic and current member of CERT I know how the system operates and the great effectiveness of it as I am living proof that it works the way it should.

Villager Joyce 09-22-2016 01:23 PM

:beer3:
Quote:

Originally Posted by HMLRHT1 (Post 1293590)
Hi everyone, I'm the person who went down at the Rohan Pickleball courts on Monday morning. I want everyone to know that I greatly and eternally appreciate the response of the Pickleball players, the staff from Rohan Rec Center, the Sumter County EMS and the TVPS. As a past medic and current member of CERT I know how the system operates and the great effectiveness of it as I am living proof that it works the way it should.

:beer3:

784caroline 09-22-2016 08:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HMLRHT1 (Post 1293590)
Hi everyone, I'm the person who went down at the Rohan Pickleball courts on Monday morning. I want everyone to know that I greatly and eternally appreciate the response of the Pickleball players, the staff from Rohan Rec Center, the Sumter County EMS and the TVPS. As a past medic and current member of CERT I know how the system operates and the great effectiveness of it as I am living proof that it works the way it should.

Certainly glad you made through this incident BUT 30 minute response time....not acceptable. The 6 minute PR response time is a "mean" average that excludes abnormalities such as this. Thats fine as long as you or I are not the person waiting for an EMT.

Highly suggest you contact Chief Cain to find out what really happened that resulted in a delayed response ! He can then add the findings to his collection to improve things.

ColdNoMore 09-22-2016 08:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HMLRHT1 (Post 1293590)
Hi everyone, I'm the person who went down at the Rohan Pickleball courts on Monday morning. I want everyone to know that I greatly and eternally appreciate the response of the Pickleball players, the staff from Rohan Rec Center, the Sumter County EMS and the TVPS. As a past medic and current member of CERT I know how the system operates and the great effectiveness of it as I am living proof that it works the way it should.

Excellent to hear you are doing well! :beer3:

Not that it really matters in the big scheme of things (you surviving is the most important), but conflicting posts have me confused.

Did it in fact take the 'professionals' 30 minutes to get there while other Villagers took care of you, or were there other 'professional' first responders there in 6 minutes...and it was only the ambulance that took 30 minutes to arrive? :confused:

Anyway, once again it doesn't really matter as you being well enough to come on here and post...is all that really matters. :bigbow:

dbussone 09-22-2016 08:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 784caroline (Post 1293790)
Certainly glad you made through this incident BUT 30 minute response time....not acceptable. The 6 minute PR response time is a "mean" average that excludes abnormalities such as this. Thats fine as long as you or I are not the person waiting for an EMT.



Highly suggest you contact Chief Cain to find out what really happened that resulted in a delayed response ! He can then add the findings to his collection to improve things.



If you were to go back a few posts you would learn the following:
1 there was not a 30 minute response time.
2 initially CPR/AED trained individuals reacted to the event
3 TVPSD first responders (EMTs) arrived within their 6 minute average
4 the standard process is for TVPSD to provide immediate care, drugs, stabilizing treatment
5 after the patient is stable & able to be transported, an ambulance is used to transport the patient to the hospital
6 the initial civilian response, and immediate response by TVPSD, are crucial to successful recovery
7 step 6 occurred as perfectly as it could have been
8 the patient appears to be doing well, as a result of step 6
9 the OP didn't have accurate information at all



Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

dbussone 09-22-2016 08:36 PM

slow ambulance service today
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ColdNoMore (Post 1293803)
Excellent to hear you are doing well! :beer3:



Not that it really matters in the big scheme of things (you surviving is the most important), but conflicting posts have me confused.



Did it in fact take the 'professionals' 30 minutes to get there while other Villagers took care of you, or were there other 'professional' first responders there in 6 minutes...and it was only the ambulance that took 30 minutes to arrive? :confused:



Anyway, once again it doesn't really matter as you being well enough to come on here and post...is all that really matters. :bigbow:



please reread all the posts to note that the response time was 6 minutes, not 30; the OP didn't have a clue what happened.
TVPSD EMTs are the first responders. The provide treatment, drugs, care and stabilize the patient. Once stabilized the patient is transported by a secondarily called ambulance.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

ColdNoMore 09-22-2016 08:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dbussone (Post 1293805)
If you were to go back a few posts you would learn the following:
1 there was not a 30 minute response time.
2 initially CPR/AED trained individuals reacted to the event
3 TVPSD first responders (EMTs) arrived within their 6 minute average
4 the standard process is for TVPSD to provide immediate care, drugs, stabilizing treatment
5 after the patient is stable & able to be transported, an ambulance is used to transport the patient to the hospital
6 the initial civilian response, and immediate response by TVPSD, are crucial to successful recovery
7 step 6 occurred as perfectly as it could have been
8 the patient appears to be doing well, as a result of step 6
9 the OP didn't have accurate information at all

So in other words, the EMT's (professionals) arrived within 6 minutes...but not by ambulance?

I wasn't aware that we had EMT's that didn't have ambulances.

Learn something new every day.

twoplanekid 09-22-2016 08:55 PM

From previous posts ->
Please reread all the posts to note that the response time was 6 minutes, not 30; the OP didn't have a clue what happened.
I wasn't aware that we had EMT's that didn't have ambulances.


So, while EMT’s were there in 6 minutes, the patient had to wait another 20 or so minutes for the ambulance to arrive for transportation to the hospital. In Urbana, the fire department ambulance arrives with EMT’s to immediately transport one to a medical facility.

Which system is best? Is cost an overriding factor?

HMLRHT1 09-22-2016 09:43 PM

The Villages Fire Dept or better known as TVPSD has every vehicle staffed with Paramedics and EMTs. They provide advanced life support upon arrival. This generally takes 6 mins or so. The ambulance is also staffed with a Paramedic and an EMT. The ambulances don't have fixed stations and at times have to come from the far side or outside TV. Usually it is TVPSD who arrives first with all the needed equipment and training. Regardless, whoever gets there first starts treatment on the patient. Treatment on scene is the most important time for a victim such as myself or other medical issues and most accidents except level 1 trauma victims. It is rare that ambulances do a " load and go "

Barefoot 09-22-2016 09:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dbussone (Post 1293810)
please reread all the posts to note that the response time was 6 minutes, not 30; the OP didn't have a clue what happened.
TVPSD EMTs are the first responders. The provide treatment, drugs, care and stabilize the patient.

Thanks for finding out the facts.
It's good to know that EMTs were on the scene within six minutes.

outlaw 09-23-2016 06:59 AM

Never heard of an EMT showing up without an ambulance or a fire engine. I read in the DS that the average response time in TV was something like 2 or 3 minutes. Why 6 minutes to 30 minutes?

RickeyD 09-23-2016 07:10 AM

Been watching this post befuddled as to what the OP stated. I'm so glad the truth came out and I won't have to sell my house.

Villager Joyce 09-23-2016 07:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by goodtimesintv (Post 1293150)
I

I hope from seeing these reports, that residents too cheap to contribute a few bucks a year--to their neighborhood, volunteer AED equipment, responder training and dispatch costs--wake up and see that the fire department amubulances could be out on other calls already. This is why the dozens of effective neighborhood AED groups have been formed, and why the survival rate here in TV is much higher than anywhere else!

I would like to respond to your comments on "...residents too cheap". If someone specifically made that statement to you, then respond to that person. Don't lump in others. tbere are recent widows who are scared to death they can't afford to live here. Not cheap. Scared. There are grandparents who have had to take on the task of raising grandchildren because of family dynamics. There are recent retirees who are earning to balance miney in and money out. There are people who were just diagnosed with a disease and they don't know what tbe cost will do to their budget. There are many reasons why people can't pay. How dare you suggest it is cheapness on their part. Sometimes it us, but your generalization is highly offensive. Again, if someone tells you they are too cheap, grow some and discuss it face to face. Don't generalize and profile others into that category.

RickeyD 09-23-2016 07:36 AM

Some people simply are cheap. I had a rotten fence come down so I asked my adjoining neighbor to chip in. He refused, so I removed the fence without replacing it. Within 3 weeks he put up a new fence at his expense. I didn't feel compelled to offer any money.

CFrance 09-23-2016 07:38 AM

I do believe it was about 6 minutes for the EMTs to arrive at our house last month (everything is fine; good outcome). However, when playing pickleball at Hibiscus last fall, it took a half-hour for them to arrive to assist a player who was fainting. We could hear the sirens coming and going, but they had trouble locating Hibiscus courts. There is no phone at the courts, and the rec center is across busy Bailey Trail and a parking lot. The group had called on their cell phones, which is understandable given the distance to the rec center, and finally had to call again and talk the ambulance in.

Now I'm thinking Duh, there is a starter shack by the tennis courts that probably has a land line. You see what happens to your logical thinking during an emergency...

pooh 09-23-2016 07:51 AM

Have had 4 occasions dealing with 911 calls. Two times for a family member here in TV, the other two times, cardiac arrests for our street's AED alert system. Each time, fire dept vehicles with EMT's arrived extremely quickly. All events took place on my street. Ambulance arrived shortly afterwards. All responders were fast, professional, caring.

My house backs to Morse Blvd and each and every day I can see and hear ambulances, fire trucks, going to and from the fire station. What is troubling is watching cars not give the Emergency vehicle clear passage. Oh I imagine sometimes the traffic may prevent someone from pulling over quickly, but most of the time, that doesn't seem to be the case. Emergency vehicles must make additional siren blasts to get cars in front of them to move. Crossing the bridge and a couple of traffic circles can slow down a large vehicle without additional traffic, it is so much slower when waiting for vehicles to get out of the way.
There will be delays, sadly, getting emergency personnel to the emergency sometimes. This community has many fire stations, many EMTs, AED devices located in neighborhoods, community facilities....much more than many other locations for responders, stations, EMT professionals. Doesn't hurt to take a CPR course, it's great to have AED's in your neighborhood. Pay if you can, don't pay if that's your preference. If you are in need of AED intervention, I'm sure neighborhood responders don't check a list to see if you've contributed. If you have, good, you've done something helpful for your fellow man. If you haven't, well, who are we to judge.

asianthree 09-23-2016 07:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HMLRHT1 (Post 1293841)
The Villages Fire Dept or better known as TVPSD has every vehicle staffed with Paramedics and EMTs. They provide advanced life support upon arrival. This generally takes 6 mins or so. The ambulance is also staffed with a Paramedic and an EMT. The ambulances don't have fixed stations and at times have to come from the far side or outside TV. Usually it is TVPSD who arrives first with all the needed equipment and training. Regardless, whoever gets there first starts treatment on the patient. Treatment on scene is the most important time for a victim such as myself or other medical issues and most accidents except level 1 trauma victims. It is rare that ambulances do a " load and go "

Thanks for correct information. Most don't realize first responders role. As one who has been involved with numerous CPR events, 6 minute window is a gift for those performing CPR.

Matzy 09-23-2016 08:46 PM

extending information
 
nkrifats explained it correctly. The ambulances are usually dispatched from the next AVIABLE station, but when they are in use at that time, the next closest to the emergency place ambulance will get the call. Unfortunately, sometimes (pretty often) non of the ambulance are available when needed right away (loading/unloading patients, emergency somewhere, cleaning/disinfection, etc.). Sometimes, there are just not enough ambulances around. I could tell stories about how difficult it could be (or it is)...... I worked voluntarily 25 years in EMS.

twoplanekid 09-24-2016 07:52 AM

As TV has very unique demographics and as TV has a tremendous growth rate, I assume and hope that private ambulance providers are able to keep up with the needs of this community. I understand that we are fortunate to have many locals with training and a good TVPSD.

In addition to our local fire department ambulances in Ohio, we have Care Flight helicopters operating out of our local airport for transportation. While I understand that initial stabilization of the patient is very important, I don’t want to be able to read a book before taken to a hospital for further treatment.

As I haven’t found data to say for sure one way or the other, quick transportation to a hospital may or may not be an issue. If needed, I hope it isn't.

rjm1cc 09-24-2016 08:27 AM

Marion County tracks response time and also has target times they want to meet. Staffing is a problem which relates back to the amount of money they have to spend. You will probably find that they have good response time but they would like to do better but do not have the resources.

Barefoot 09-24-2016 10:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by twoplanekid (Post 1294413)
In addition to our local fire department ambulances in Ohio, we have Care Flight helicopters operating out of our local airport for transportation.

On more than one occasion, I've seen a helicopter land at a golf course near my Villages home.
I assume the helicopter is meeting an ambulance and airlifting a needy patient to another hospital.
I always say a little prayer when I see the emergency helicopter.

lanabanana73 09-24-2016 11:26 AM

I was at the craft fair at Colony Plaza today when an older lady lost consciousness. She was laid on the ground while one person was on the phone with the 911 operator and the ambulance was there within 5 minutes. I was very impressed with that particular response time!

The lady came around by the time the ambulance arrived and while I was asking her questions, she said, "I just pulled a Hillary!". At that point, I knew she was going to be just fine. :a040:

dbussone 09-24-2016 09:16 PM

slow ambulance service today
 
We have 3 air ambulance services that I know of: Tampa General (3 helos), Shands, and Orlando. There is another that has previously been based in Wildwood, but it has recently moved. I wouldn't sweat getting where you might need to go. Central FL is well covered.

dbussone 09-24-2016 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lanabanana73 (Post 1294546)
I was at the craft fair at Colony Plaza today when an older lady lost consciousness. She was laid on the ground while one person was on the phone with the 911 operator and the ambulance was there within 5 minutes. I was very impressed with that particular response time!



The lady came around by the time the ambulance arrived and while I was asking her questions, she said, "I just pulled a Hillary!". At that point, I knew she was going to be just fine. :a040:



Thank you for monitoring her. That is exactly what we need, along with CPR/AED trained Villagers.

Bogie Shooter 09-29-2016 08:01 AM

It is worth noting that Janet Tutt, District Manager said in The Daily Sun Sept 29, that this was a false rumor.
She advised if you hear or read something, take a minute to question it.
She suggests to call 753-4508 and get the rest of the story.
Her email address; janet.tutt@districtgov.org

Villager Joyce 09-29-2016 08:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bogie Shooter (Post 1297466)
It is worth noting that Janet Tutt, District Manager said in The Daily Sun Sept 29, that this was a false rumor.
She advised if you hear or read something, take a minute to question it.
She suggests to call 753-4508 and get the rest of the story.
Her email address; janet.tutt@districtgov.org

Before she is inundated with emails, please tell us what she told you. Lots easier for all involved IMHO.

Bogie Shooter 09-29-2016 12:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bogie Shooter (Post 1297466)
It is worth noting that Janet Tutt, District Manager said in The Daily Sun Sept 29, that this was a false rumor.
She advised if you hear or read something, take a minute to question it.
She suggests to call 753-4508 and get the rest of the story.
Her email address; janet.tutt@districtgov.org

Quote:

Originally Posted by Villager Joyce (Post 1297487)
Before she is inundated with emails, please tell us what she told you. Lots easier for all involved IMHO.

She told me nothing. I read it in the paper. And I posted what was in the article. I could look up the section and page number if that would be helpful??
Why would she get a lot of emails on something that she said was a rumor..........

Villager Joyce 09-29-2016 01:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bogie Shooter (Post 1297680)
She told me nothing. I read it in the paper. And I posted what was in the article. I could look up the section and page number if that would be helpful??
Why would she get a lot of emails on something that she said was a rumor..........

My apologies. I read your post quickly and thoight you gave her telephone number and email address so people could call and find out the rest of the story.

CFrance 09-29-2016 03:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bogie Shooter (Post 1297680)
She told me nothing. I read it in the paper. And I posted what was in the article. I could look up the section and page number if that would be helpful??
Why would she get a lot of emails on something that she said was a rumor..........

Maybe because some folks don't trust her
or the Daily Sun to tell a story without a slant?

dbussone 09-29-2016 04:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CFrance (Post 1297816)
Maybe because some folks don't trust her

or the Daily Sun to tell a story without a slant?



CF - you know me fairly well I think. The story about the slow response time is absolutely false. I know the gentleman who was the patient in this instance. And I know the leadership of TVPSD and asked them about this.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Bogie Shooter 09-29-2016 04:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CFrance (Post 1297816)
Maybe because some folks don't trust her
or the Daily Sun to tell a story without a slant?

I really get tired of everything always framed as some conspiracy!
The some folks that don't trust her need to get a life.

CFrance 09-29-2016 04:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dbussone (Post 1297857)
CF - you know me fairly well I think. The story about the slow response time is absolutely false. I know the gentleman who was the patient in this instance. And I know the leadership of TVPSD and asked them about this.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Coming from you, that's all I need,
DB.

HMLRHT1 10-03-2016 11:13 AM

Hi all, I was the patient in this discussion. I went to TVPSD 44 (headquarters) today and asked to have a copy of the run report for my call. They were very happy to give me a copy of all the paperwork. The responding units to Rohan came from Sta 45 across the street from Eisenhower Rec Center. Both the fast attack piece (Paramedic & EMT) and ladder were dispatched at 10:35 and arrived at 10:41. 6 minutes total. The Sumter County EMS ambulance (Paramedic & EMT) was enroute to scene at 10:35 and arrived at scene 10:47. 12 minutes total. Not the 20 or 25 or 30 minutes everyone keeps insisting on. As has been stated before, The Villages has a very good EMS setup and it responds as quickly and efficiently as possible. The Sumter County EMS ambulance is also a well organized and an integral part of the EMS system here in The Villages. Thank you to all who responded to my needs.

CFrance 10-03-2016 11:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HMLRHT1 (Post 1300226)
Hi all, I was the patient in this discussion. I went to TVPSD 44 (headquarters) today and asked to have a copy of the run report for my call. They were very happy to give me a copy of all the paperwork. The responding units to Rohan came from Sta 45 across the street from Eisenhower Rec Center. Both the fast attack piece (Paramedic & EMT) and ladder were dispatched at 10:35 and arrived at 10:41. 6 minutes total. The Sumter County EMS ambulance (Paramedic & EMT) was enroute to scene at 10:35 and arrived at scene 10:47. 12 minutes total. Not the 20 or 25 or 30 minutes everyone keeps insisting on. As has been stated before, The Villages has a very good EMS setup and it responds as quickly and efficiently as possible. The Sumter County EMS ambulance is also a well organized and an integral part of the EMS system here in The Villages. Thank you to all who responded to my needs.

So glad for your happy outcome. Be well!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:10 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.