Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   Current Events and News (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/current-events-news-541/)
-   -   This COVID19 surge is FL first wave. (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/current-events-news-541/covid19-surge-fl-first-wave-308412/)

CoachKandSportsguy 06-28-2020 09:01 PM

This COVID19 surge is FL first wave.
 
Originally Posted by golfing eagles
Quote:

We don't yet know if this uptick in cases is a true second wave or just a statistical blip on the radar. However, based on the last several days of posts on TOTV, it looks like the second wave of paranoia has already begun.
Disagree with this statement. FL never had a first wave like the northeast due to the seasonal activity differences. With the virus spread primarily indoors, in the northeast, Feb/Mar/Apr were relatively cold monthly, and people were aggregating indoors and spread the virus. At that time, in FL, activities were mostly outside with little spread. Now in the north, there is little indoor activities and mostly outdoor activities, where the spread is reduced. Down here, people are now migrating indoors for air conditioning, as its very hot outside, which promotes spread of the virus. Hat tip Coachk for picking up on that subtle point by Desantis this afternoon.

So, that is why the South has not been as infected as the North over the same time period, but the behaviors are reversing and the South is spreading due to more indoor activities to escape the heat. So this surge is effectively the south's first wave, which makes the south luckier in that the more deadly virus which kills its host and has a shorter life span, has a faster diminishing R0, and not as prevalent and the less deadly or milder is the current most persistent virus.

However, Friday, Fauci also said that this type of virus with such large variation of outcomes, has never been seen before in infectious disease studies. So don't assume that there are any guarantees of simple or safe outcomes just because the average age of infections is trending towards the average age of the population, the only assumption is better treatments for most serious shorter hospital stays. Apparent mild cases are still ending up dead at home.

And these statements are not paranoia, just data points and analysis from individual outcomes, and medical observations and analysis, as reported in a hospital setting by Coachk, who reviews individual deaths many times a week for statutory reporting. And CoachK listens in every morning on senior staff conference calls at the medical center, discussing all aspects of the hospital current daily status and updates.

sportsguy

golfing eagles 06-29-2020 07:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CoachKandSportsguy (Post 1794128)
Originally Posted by golfing eagles


Disagree with this statement. FL never had a first wave like the northeast due to the seasonal activity differences. With the virus spread primarily indoors, in the northeast, Feb/Mar/Apr were relatively cold monthly, and people were aggregating indoors and spread the virus. At that time, in FL, activities were mostly outside with little spread. Now in the north, there is little indoor activities and mostly outdoor activities, where the spread is reduced. Down here, people are now migrating indoors for air conditioning, as its very hot outside, which promotes spread of the virus. Hat tip Coachk for picking up on that subtle point by Desantis this afternoon.

So, that is why the South has not been as infected as the North over the same time period, but the behaviors are reversing and the South is spreading due to more indoor activities to escape the heat. So this surge is effectively the south's first wave, which makes the south luckier in that the more deadly virus which kills its host and has a shorter life span, has a faster diminishing R0, and not as prevalent and the less deadly or milder is the current most persistent virus.

However, Friday, Fauci also said that this type of virus with such large variation of outcomes, has never been seen before in infectious disease studies. So don't assume that there are any guarantees of simple or safe outcomes just because the average age of infections is trending towards the average age of the population, the only assumption is better treatments for most serious shorter hospital stays. Apparent mild cases are still ending up dead at home.

And these statements are not paranoia, just data points and analysis from individual outcomes, and medical observations and analysis, as reported in a hospital setting by Coachk, who reviews individual deaths many times a week for statutory reporting. And CoachK listens in every morning on senior staff conference calls at the medical center, discussing all aspects of the hospital current daily status and updates.

sportsguy

Time will tell. Look for the hospitalizations and deaths about 2 weeks from now and see if it parallels the "new" case rate.

I don't agree that you can dismiss March and April by denying it was the "first wave". It's not possible to compare the severity of the initial pandemic in different locations. Florida was less severe than New York for multiple reasons, just as NY was less severe than Northern Italy at the same time.

And no one suggested that your analysis is "paranoia". I define paranoia as driving alone in you car with the windows up and a mask on---whatever THAT is supposed to accomplish. Or a foursome that went by a few days ago, all in individual carts, all wearing a mask, even though the outdoor human to human transmission rate with social distancing appears to be 0.07%. Some guy in Raleigh, NC was driving alone with a N95 mask, he must have retained CO2, possibly due to underlying COPD, and drove his car into a tree. At least he didn't spread COVID-19.

Again, time will tell. Stay safe.

charlieo1126@gmail.com 06-29-2020 07:43 AM

Excuse me but indoor fl
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by CoachKandSportsguy (Post 1794128)
Originally Posted by golfing eagles


Disagree with this statement. FL never had a first wave like the northeast due to the seasonal activity differences. With the virus spread primarily indoors, in the northeast, Feb/Mar/Apr were relatively cold monthly, and people were aggregating indoors and spread the virus. At that time, in FL, activities were mostly outside with little spread. Now in the north, there is little indoor activities and mostly outdoor activities, where the spread is reduced. Down here, people are now migrating indoors for air conditioning, as its very hot outside, which promotes spread of the virus. Hat tip Coachk for picking up on that subtle point by Desantis this afternoon.

So, that is why the South has not been as infected as the North over the same time period, but the behaviors are reversing and the South is spreading due to more indoor activities to escape the heat. So this surge is effectively the south's first wave, which makes the south luckier in that the more deadly virus which kills its host and has a shorter life span, has a faster diminishing R0, and not as prevalent and the less deadly or milder is the current most persistent virus.

However, Friday, Fauci also said that this type of virus with such large variation of outcomes, has never been seen before in infectious disease studies. So don't assume that there are any guarantees of simple or safe outcomes just because the average age of infections is trending towards the average age of the population, the only assumption is better treatments for most serious shorter hospital stays. Apparent mild cases are still ending up dead at home.

And these statements are not paranoia, just data points and analysis from individual outcomes, and medical observations and analysis, as reported in a hospital setting by Coachk, who reviews individual deaths many times a week for statutory reporting. And CoachK listens in every morning on senior staff conference calls at the medical center, discussing all aspects of the hospital current daily status and updates.

sportsguy

hmmm outside bars, boating, golf,beaches , malls , peace demonstrations , what indoor activities are we talking about even here in the villages many of us are active outside all day

Joelack99 06-29-2020 07:51 AM

Yes, this is the middle of the first wave.

What has become apparent is that transmission rates are different depending on how people act. If we continue to act as we have been, the virus will be totally out of control, much like a forest fire, and will eventually burn out (assuming immunity you get from surviving it lasts for awhile, NOT proven,) but do terrible damage (read many will die) in the process. Not paranoia, math.

The “reproductive rate” of the virus is between 2.5 and 6 if you do nothing, meaning each infected person will infect that many more people. At R0=1, the epidemic doesn’t grow or shrink, so we have to do whatever it takes to reduce that number. Cloth masks are ~60% effective, essential but not good enough by itself. (2.5 times .6 is still >1)

Social distancing improves this, so if most people wear masks, the R0 rate can be brought below 1, according to those pesky scientists who spend their entire lives studying these things. This is the only way we get our epidemic in control. The math is simple and clear.

Wear the mask. Socially distance. Be patient. If the outbreak is bad enough, stay home, no matter how much you hate it.

The alternative is really, really, ugly.

PennBF 06-29-2020 07:54 AM

Critical Knowledge
 
I think the statistics on it spreading is a little scary! A question I would have is why
do you think the Village newspaper stopped and continues to avoid publishing the
the data on where it is popping up more. (e.g. counties, etc). That would be helpful
to the Residents to know? Have any idea's??:ho:

CoachKandSportsguy 06-29-2020 10:14 AM

And there goes the younger narrative:
Bloomberg - Are you a robot?
still the first wave. . .

interesting how links now may or may not show up properly. here is the url without the linking, which was showing up and then disappeared. . . so the bloomberg link inserted the Are you a robot after I saved. . but the link should still work. . .

sportsguy

CoachKandSportsguy 06-29-2020 10:30 AM

As far as who publishes what statistics, there are multiple interpretations of data, analytics and statistics. . . always the ability to segregate and twist the data to tell a narrative. There are also biases with any and every commercial enterprise. . I have spend too many years in corporate america watching the machine make saugage, so assume that there are commercial reasons for not publishing data, and assume that the publishers don't want a perceived outcome or a responsibility for the article.

The worst are the stock market explanations for why the market goes up or down in any particular day. I have a predictive model which identified particular days which go up and then which go down, regardless of the news. So when the prediction comes true as in the pattern has repeated the same way for 20 years, and the narrative is different every time, why do really listen to the publicized reasons?

Likewise, having been an insider in several companies, and having worked on valuation of companies for buying and selling, what the general public hears or reads is usually only a very small piece of the reality inside. So unless you have "reliable" insider information, which is not illegal, then you really are only getting a desired narrative. Same with medical narratives, same with corporate marketing narratives, same with financial results narratives, same with political narratives.

Best to work on one's handicap instead of relying on commercial enterprise news.

sportsguy

CoachKandSportsguy 06-29-2020 10:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by charlieo1126@gmail.com (Post 1794322)
hmmm outside bars, boating, golf,beaches , malls , peace demonstrations , what indoor activities are we talking about even here in the villages many of us are active outside all day

What you are doing is generalizing a narrative scenario, and those options are available, true, but not everyone is living and working that scenario all the time, all day long, especially with the current heat index. Indoor gyms, indoor restaurants, indoor pro shops, indoor salons, indoor supermarkets, at some point or another, the news has reported that these types of places have been reported to have infections, not all at once, and not all of them, for the black and white thinkers who tend to see only binary all or nothing outcomes. . . but as the governor pointed out over the weekend, the transition to more indoors for air conditioning to avoid the heat is creating more infections throughout the state.

which is why we are leaving to travel north as soon as we are ready. . . because wife working in a medical center up north has seen hospital demand higher than capacity, and has had field medical stations set up in a convention center to accomodate the overflow.

When that happens in FL, you will know that your are near or at the peak of the first wave. Just hope you aren't one of them in the overflow, and they are flying in medical staff to support the overflow, because there is not regularly planned pandemic overflow staffing just waiting to go to work in a risky environment.

good luck

sportsguy

GoodLife 06-29-2020 11:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CoachKandSportsguy (Post 1794485)
And there goes the younger narrative:
Bloomberg - Are you a robot?
still the first wave. . .

interesting how links now may or may not show up properly. here is the url without the linking, which was showing up and then disappeared. . . so the bloomberg link inserted the Are you a robot after I saved. . but the link should still work. . .

sportsguy

There goes the younger narrative? Complete nonsense. The median age of new cases in Florida has been between 32 and 37 for more than two weeks now. The median age of new cases in March, April, May was 55-60. Know why? Because back then they were testing only people with symptoms. 70-80% of covid 19 cases under 60 years old are asymptomatic, so until recently the only people that age who got tested were the ones with some preexisting condition like hypertension etc.

As of today, 86% of all covid 19 cases in Florida have been under 65 years old. 85% of all deaths in Florida have been from cases of people over 65 years old. They are the ones the disease can kill easily.

This epidemic has always been driven by the young and asymptomatic. We are just finding out about them now because of mandatory workplace testing, mandatory testing if you go to ER or hospital, give blood etc etc. One day if we do antibody tests on everyone, we will find that millions and millions more were exposed to covid 19, never got sick or had symptoms.

And of course the surge of young aged cases will infect some older people. They always have. But the uptick in over 65 new cases is small compared to the uptick in younger aged people. Why do you think the median age of new cases dropped 20-25 years?

http://ww11.doh.state.fl.us/comm/_pa...rts_latest.pdf

GoodLife 06-29-2020 12:24 PM

1 Attachment(s)
I wonder why this happened in Minnesota?

Attachment 84894

martynpat 06-30-2020 06:09 AM

Does it matter which wave it is? It is serious and warrants being vigilant and careful at all times. Masks and distancing are good and should be among everyone's weapons to fight this virus.

Beyond The Wall 06-30-2020 06:24 AM

Fauci has been right less then 50% of time. Not creditable . Neither are CDC and WHO. Inside spread is valid. However rioting and protesting were DEFINITELY trigger points. Data showing that you can not stop the spread, just try to control rate.
As aside, King Cuomo is an ass! Just saying

Irishmen 06-30-2020 06:58 AM

Read yesterday doctors sent in 10 qty placebo test, they all came back positive. Fake names fake everything all came back positive. You sheep being played.

Dana1963 06-30-2020 06:58 AM

It’s been over 1 month since demonstrations/riots the protesting cities are not showing the spikes we are seeing in Az, Tx Fl. Here in the Villages we survived about 60 days with closures. We are now open and many idiots dropped their guard what they have learned and are infected. All that was suggested social distancing wear a mask BUT to many here it was a joke.

Mendy 06-30-2020 07:00 AM

Masks Make a Difference
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by CoachKandSportsguy (Post 1794128)
Originally Posted by golfing eagles


Disagree with this statement. FL never had a first wave like the northeast due to the seasonal activity differences. With the virus spread primarily indoors, in the northeast, Feb/Mar/Apr were relatively cold monthly, and people were aggregating indoors and spread the virus. At that time, in FL, activities were mostly outside with little spread. Now in the north, there is little indoor activities and mostly outdoor activities, where the spread is reduced. Down here, people are now migrating indoors for air conditioning, as its very hot outside, which promotes spread of the virus. Hat tip Coachk for picking up on that subtle point by Desantis this afternoon.

So, that is why the South has not been as infected as the North over the same time period, but the behaviors are reversing and the South is spreading due to more indoor activities to escape the heat. So this surge is effectively the south's first wave, which makes the south luckier in that the more deadly virus which kills its host and has a shorter life span, has a faster diminishing R0, and not as prevalent and the less deadly or milder is the current most persistent virus.

However, Friday, Fauci also said that this type of virus with such large variation of outcomes, has never been seen before in infectious disease studies. So don't assume that there are any guarantees of simple or safe outcomes just because the average age of infections is trending towards the average age of the population, the only assumption is better treatments for most serious shorter hospital stays. Apparent mild cases are still ending up dead at home.

And these statements are not paranoia, just data points and analysis from individual outcomes, and medical observations and analysis, as reported in a hospital setting by Coachk, who reviews individual deaths many times a week for statutory reporting. And CoachK listens in every morning on senior staff conference calls at the medical center, discussing all aspects of the hospital current daily status and updates.

sportsguy


Twitter

Irishmen 06-30-2020 07:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dana1963 (Post 1794993)
It’s been over 1 month since demonstrations/riots the protesting cities are not showing the spikes we are seeing in Az, Tx Fl. Here in the Villages we survived about 60 days with closures. We are now open and many idiots dropped their guard what they have learned and are infected. All that was suggested social distancing wear a mask BUT to many here it was a joke.

In the beautifully safe and lovely cities, health workers were specifically instructed under penalty of termination not to reveal riot and protest participation. Fake test give fake results.

Joe C. 06-30-2020 08:00 AM

Until we get an effective vaccine, maybe we should just get out and get on with life, and let the virus do what it's GOING TO DO ANYWAY. Then we will be done with it till the next (and probably more deadly) virus comes along.

I'm not a doctor, but I did spend a night at a Holiday Inn Express.

Jazzman 06-30-2020 08:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CoachKandSportsguy (Post 1794508)
As far as who publishes what statistics, there are multiple interpretations of data, analytics and statistics. . . always the ability to segregate and twist the data to tell a narrative. There are also biases with any and every commercial enterprise. . I have spend too many years in corporate america watching the machine make saugage, so assume that there are commercial reasons for not publishing data, and assume that the publishers don't want a perceived outcome or a responsibility for the article.

The worst are the stock market explanations for why the market goes up or down in any particular day. I have a predictive model which identified particular days which go up and then which go down, regardless of the news. So when the prediction comes true as in the pattern has repeated the same way for 20 years, and the narrative is different every time, why do really listen to the publicized reasons?

Likewise, having been an insider in several companies, and having worked on valuation of companies for buying and selling, what the general public hears or reads is usually only a very small piece of the reality inside. So unless you have "reliable" insider information, which is not illegal, then you really are only getting a desired narrative. Same with medical narratives, same with corporate marketing narratives, same with financial results narratives, same with political narratives.

Best to work on one's handicap instead of relying on commercial enterprise news.

sportsguy

Agree with your assessment. When it comes to data you are correct as you can massage rather data to a point where it shows exactly what you want it to be. As far as statistics, what doesn’t happen in the media or with Fauci is a drill down. When you look at stats from the 30,000 foot level, you can interpret that the sky is falling. After a drill down through the details, many times things don’t look to bad. That’s why I would like to see more of Dr. Birx than Dr. Fauci. Birx is data driven and that’s the info we need. Isn’t it funny she never is asked to testify before Congress and probably has had one tenth of media interviews versus her colleague Fauci. In my opinion, the reason is she can identify the specific hotspots and not blame the whole state for example for an uptick. That’s what people need to see and hear.

regas56 06-30-2020 10:32 AM

Seems to me that if in the beginning they were testing only 100's of thousands and an X number tested positive, wouldn't now since they've tested over 33 MILLION that positive test rate number also sky rocket? More tests, more positives, seems like simple math..I still believe it's the mortality rate we need to watch closely..

Barefoot 06-30-2020 10:41 AM

[QUOTE=Joe C.;1795103I'm not a doctor, but I did spend a night at a Holiday Inn Express.[/QUOTE]

:1rotfl:

charlieo1126@gmail.com 06-30-2020 12:44 PM

Please tell me where
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Irishmen (Post 1795067)
In the beautifully safe and lovely cities, health workers were specifically instructed under penalty of termination not to reveal riot and protest participation. Fake test give fake results.

you got this information , they must have more fairytales to share

talleyjm 06-30-2020 01:33 PM

Where can one find out how many Villagers have died from COVID-19? My son who lives in NY read in the Orlando newspaper that 5 people to date who live in TV have died. I remember reading about a male pickleball player who was hospitalized- never heard anymore about him, only the two women who died. Does anyone know what happened to the pickleball player?

sallybowron 06-30-2020 02:19 PM

I thought we were told to ride in different carts to golf. Since four players play in a group they would/ should all be driving alone.

Quixote 06-30-2020 04:32 PM

We can speculate from now until the cows come home; we can listen to the authorities guessing as best as they can, we can ignore the speculations of lay people, but the bottom line will still be dates, facts, and numbers. And I suspect (my opinion) we're nowhere—NOWHERE—near that bottom line yet....

TomPerrett 06-30-2020 10:03 PM

You may as well face it. It’s hear, it’s going to do a lot of health damage , it’s going to kill many more and the economy it badly trashed in this state.
Local municipalities have closed down their areas and are requiring face mask in a desperate move to protect residents. They expected leadership from the governor but it never come.
Denying this is no longer an option. God help us.

graciegirl 07-01-2020 07:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Beyond The Wall (Post 1794941)
Fauci has been right less then 50% of time. Not creditable . Neither are CDC and WHO. Inside spread is valid. However rioting and protesting were DEFINITELY trigger points. Data showing that you can not stop the spread, just try to control rate.
As aside, King Cuomo is an ass! Just saying

I think Governor Cuomo did a pretty good job and the only error I can see is directing convalescent cases toward convalescent centers. I also think Ohio's governor did a good job despite opposition from several areas. I think Dr. Fauci is the bomb. He is a smart and diplomatic man who has faced extremely unusual resistance from what a year ago I would have considered surprising areas.

Not all wisdom on this subject rests in one area and really, it is ALL mostly common sense and self control.

We all know that shutting down people, shuts down the economy which is the life blood of people and their bread and butter and their shelter and the entire structure of society. We are as a country, between a rock and a hard place and we olders are arguably in the best position to choose safety, IF WE WANT TO.

People who help us and hindered us have seats on both sides of the aisle. I think science trumps all. It is a little iddy biddy bug and it's killing us and many are letting it.

Irishmen 07-01-2020 07:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by charlieo1126@gmail.com (Post 1795343)
you got this information , they must have more fairytales to share

COVID Contact Tracers Don’t Ask About Floyd Protest Participation - THE CITY

Irishmen 07-01-2020 08:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by charlieo1126@gmail.com (Post 1795343)
you got this information , they must have more fairytales to share

NYC contact tracers told not to ask if people have attended a protest - Business Insider

Barefoot 07-01-2020 09:36 AM

...

Aloha1 07-01-2020 02:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by graciegirl (Post 1795645)
I think Governor Cuomo did a pretty good job and the only error I can see is directing convalescent cases toward convalescent centers. I also think Ohio's governor did a good job despite opposition from several areas. I think Dr. Fauci is the bomb. He is a smart and diplomatic man who has faced extremely unusual resistance from what a year ago I would have considered surprising areas.

Not all wisdom on this subject rests in one area and really, it is ALL mostly common sense and self control.

We all know that shutting down people, shuts down the economy which is the life blood of people and their bread and butter and their shelter and the entire structure of society. We are as a country, between a rock and a hard place and we olders are arguably in the best position to choose safety, IF WE WANT TO.

People who help us and hindered us have seats on both sides of the aisle. I think science trumps all. It is a little iddy biddy bug and it's killing us and many are letting it.

GG, I have to respectfully disagree with you on Cuomo . Like you, at first I thought he seemed like he had a good grasp on things and seemed reasoned. Then the truth came out about the thousands who died in NY nursing homes due to the fact he ordered positive patients back into those facilities. His response was to blame everyone and everything but himself, even callously saying at one point, "people die". Even members of his own party are now calling for an independent investigation. He lost all credibility with me when he refused to take responsibility. Dr. Fauci, is indeed a respected scientist. But he too has made mistakes going back to the early days of the crisis. He stated we had nothing to worry about, that this would never become a pandemic, go on a cruise, etc. He seems to have learned his lesson but now appears to be cautious to an extreme. I'm not sure whether to believe him anymore. The one I do respect is Dr. Birx. She has a solid grasp of the data and shows it.

vermonster 07-01-2020 03:13 PM

Hurrah
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Joelack99 (Post 1794329)
Yes, this is the middle of the first wave.

What has become apparent is that transmission rates are different depending on how people act. If we continue to act as we have been, the virus will be totally out of control, much like a forest fire, and will eventually burn out (assuming immunity you get from surviving it lasts for awhile, NOT proven,) but do terrible damage (read many will die) in the process. Not paranoia, math.

The “reproductive rate” of the virus is between 2.5 and 6 if you do nothing, meaning each infected person will infect that many more people. At R0=1, the epidemic doesn’t grow or shrink, so we have to do whatever it takes to reduce that number. Cloth masks are ~60% effective, essential but not good enough by itself. (2.5 times .6 is still >1)

Social distancing improves this, so if most people wear masks, the R0 rate can be brought below 1, according to those pesky scientists who spend their entire lives studying these things. This is the only way we get our epidemic in control. The math is simple and clear.

Wear the mask. Socially distance. Be patient. If the outbreak is bad enough, stay home, no matter how much you hate it.

The alternative is really, really, ugly.

Your comments are logical, factual, and sensible. It is nice to read a reasoned factual analysis on this site.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:22 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.