Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   Current Events and News (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/current-events-news-541/)
-   -   Earth Receives Message from 10 Million Miles Away (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/current-events-news-541/earth-receives-message-10-million-miles-away-345609/)

Randall55 11-21-2023 11:50 PM

Earth Receives Message from 10 Million Miles Away
 
1 Attachment(s)
NASA confirmed Deep Space Optical Communications (DSOC) experiment beamed a near-infrared laser encoded with data nearly 10 million miles away to the Hale Telescope in San Diego. Known as "first light" this achievement paves the way toward higher-data-rate communications, high-definition imagery, and streaming video that can be transmitted throughout the solar system. If there are different life forms out there, are we asking for trouble? What would Spock advise us?

margaretmattson 11-22-2023 01:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Randall55 (Post 2276440)
NASA confirmed Deep Space Optical Communications (DSOC) experiment beamed a near-infrared laser encoded with data nearly 10 million miles away to the Hale Telescope in San Diego. Known as "first light" this achievement paves the way toward higher-data-rate communications, high-definition imagery, and streaming video that can be transmitted throughout the solar system. If there are different life forms out there, are we asking for trouble? What would Spock advise us?

It is interesting to witness the advancements in artificial Intelligence and laser beams. The technology seems quite similar to episodes of Star Trek. I think Spock would say "with the unknown there is always a potential for danger." Let's hope there aren't Klingons and Romulans intercepting our data. Or, Chinese and Russians. Before I die, I would love to be BEAMED to any city in the world. That certainly beats a cramped airplane!

MorTech 11-22-2023 03:30 AM

It is all taxpayer-funded fun and games until someone loses an eye.

Two Bills 11-22-2023 04:51 AM

Earth Receives Message from 10 Million Miles Away

That's nothing.
I received a letter from my brother 10,000 miles away in Australia, that is practically a Nobel Prize event!

Randall55 11-22-2023 05:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Two Bills (Post 2276456)
Earth Receives Message from 10 Million Miles Away

That's nothing.
I received a letter from my brother 10,000 miles away in Australia, that is practically a Nobel Prize event!

That is quite a difference than 10 MILLION miles. But, I get your humor. Thanks for the laugh. I'm still waiting on a text or email from my daughter in Michigan. I wonder how long that is going to take!

NoMo50 11-22-2023 06:26 AM

If they haven't already, they will find a way to weaponize it.

Byte1 11-22-2023 06:44 AM

I doubt any "intelligent" life form would wish to open a conversation with anyone on Earth. After all, if humans cannot communicate with each other in peace, how can anything out there think it would be any different with them? Interesting subject but likely a big waste of money better used elsewhere.

ureout 11-22-2023 07:15 AM

very few know this but the communication was when costco will be coming to the villages

Keefelane66 11-22-2023 07:18 AM

May be the end of religion as we know it.

Bill14564 11-22-2023 07:28 AM

10 million miles? Sounds like a big number until you realize Venus is 67 million miles away, the sun is 95 million miles away, and mars is 142 million miles away. 10 million miles is really just a little past our property line.

The success here was being able to aim the laser accurately enough to hit the receiver on the earth while both are moving and the earth is turning.

dtennent 11-22-2023 08:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Randall55 (Post 2276440)
NASA confirmed Deep Space Optical Communications (DSOC) experiment beamed a near-infrared laser encoded with data nearly 10 million miles away to the Hale Telescope in San Diego. Known as "first light" this achievement paves the way toward higher-data-rate communications, high-definition imagery, and streaming video that can be transmitted throughout the solar system. If there are different life forms out there, are we asking for trouble? What would Spock advise us?

I assume the higher data rate transmission is for space related communication. For those of us living on earth in the developed world, the existing optical fiber network provides a very high data rate transmission that is not dependent on atmospheric conditions.

On the other hand, maybe we can expose the entire solar system to 200 channels of TV that has nothing on there that anyone would want to watch.:laugh::laugh:

Taltarzac725 11-22-2023 09:03 AM

ET! Phone home.

Taltarzac725 11-22-2023 09:07 AM

Wrong number.

Battlebasset 11-22-2023 12:46 PM

It would take 4.3 years moving at the speed of light to reach the nearest star. Space is really big. Bigger than anyone can imagine.

Add in the additional issues of the power needed, and all of the issues of time and relativity when traveling at the speed of light, it is a pretty good bet that we have never been visited, and we will never visit them or hear from them, assuming there is anything out there other than us.

And if you want to look at it from a Judeo-Christian religious perspective, there is no need for other intelligent life other than humans.

bopat 11-22-2023 03:39 PM

I'd think they'd get more bang for their buck with quantum entanglement and teleportation.
Laser transmissions are so 1990's.

ThirdOfFive 11-22-2023 04:27 PM

I was watching a rather grainy YouTube video last night on how to use the latest in cutting-edge technology--the dial telephone! I still remember what the dial phone replaced: the old wooden box on the wall with a black horn that you spoke into, while listening with the receiver held to your ear, and you rang people up with a little hand-crank: longs and shorts. Calling anyone not on our "party line" meant ringing up "central", with the worker (Audrey, in our case) physically connected your line with the line of the person you were calling. Audrey only worked 40 hours a week though, so you had to plan your calls accordingly. Stone-age technology, relatively speaking, when compared to sending information 10 million miles on a beam of light. But those old phones themselves were cutting-age technology mere decades before dial phones came available.

Just checked my wrist: the watch I'm wearing is a computer multiples upon multiples more powerful than what took the Apollo 11 astronauts to the moon and back. Heck, my watch CHARGER is more powerful.

Knowledge begets knowledge. Today's miracles are only destined to be tomorrow's antique curiosities. I have no doubt that in the lifetimes of my grandchildren we will have the capability (whether or not we have the will is another question) not only for interplanetary but for interstellar travel. No doubt an antique curiosity from our age, Voyager 1, will one day grace the Smithsonian Air and Space Museum. Remember we couldn't fly--until we did.

"There is no "never". Only "not yet". Words I recall seeing on an old German silent-film - era science fiction movie. Less than a hundred years ago--do you think they really had any inkling, compared to today, just how prophetic those words were?

star20166@yahoo.com 11-23-2023 04:49 AM

Spock would say' that is illogical, Captain."

toeser 11-23-2023 06:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Randall55 (Post 2276440)
NASA confirmed Deep Space Optical Communications (DSOC) experiment beamed a near-infrared laser encoded with data nearly 10 million miles away to the Hale Telescope in San Diego. Known as "first light" this achievement paves the way toward higher-data-rate communications, high-definition imagery, and streaming video that can be transmitted throughout the solar system. If there are different life forms out there, are we asking for trouble? What would Spock advise us?

Other beings already know we are here. Fortunately, the ones that do don't think we taste good.

Get real 11-23-2023 08:36 AM

Build a wall now.

Fastskiguy 11-23-2023 09:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Randall55 (Post 2276440)
NASA confirmed Deep Space Optical Communications (DSOC) experiment beamed a near-infrared laser encoded with data nearly 10 million miles away to the Hale Telescope in San Diego. Known as "first light" this achievement paves the way toward higher-data-rate communications, high-definition imagery, and streaming video that can be transmitted throughout the solar system. If there are different life forms out there, are we asking for trouble? What would Spock advise us?

Ah the dark forest theory. There may be something to it! On the other hand, space is really big so we've got that going for us. As Douglas Adams wrote...

"“Space is big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist's, but that's just peanuts to space.” "

Joe

Bay Kid 11-23-2023 09:37 AM

Probably from a new Dollar General store.

nn0wheremann 11-23-2023 10:20 AM

So why are we measuring in miles when the whole world is measuring in klicks?

HORNET 11-23-2023 10:48 AM

Maybe we ought to worry about Planet Earth, and get the leaders worry about us. Let’s save the monies and take care of our own. We have people going to bed hungry and worrying about paying their bills. Let’s worry about others out there.

Blueblaze 11-23-2023 11:29 AM

10 million, you say? Yawn.

Call me when they receive a signal from 24,963,500,379,000 miles away -- about 25 TRILLION miles. That's how far it is to the NEAREST star!

Randall55 11-23-2023 03:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blueblaze (Post 2276832)
10 million, you say? Yawn.

Call me when they receive a signal from 24,963,500,379,000 miles away -- about 25 TRILLION miles. That's how far it is to the NEAREST star!

There is a possibility there are advanced life forms out there. Who knows what type of knowledge and technology they possess. Slim chance of this? Possibly. No chance? Never say never.

Blueblaze 11-24-2023 08:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Randall55 (Post 2276862)
There is a possibility there are advanced life forms out there. Who knows what type of knowledge and technology they possess. Slim chance of this? Possibly. No chance? Never say never.

With a billion-billion stars in the VISIBLE universe, I would estimate that "slim chance" at something on the order of 99.9999999999...%

But with 25 trillion miles to the nearest star, I would estimate the chance of ever encountering one of those advanced life forms at about 0.00000000...1%

JMintzer 11-24-2023 10:24 AM

They've been able to decode the message...

https://y.yarn.co/95f8cd5c-c6fd-48d7...fc219_text.gif

ThirdOfFive 11-24-2023 12:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blueblaze (Post 2276832)
10 million, you say? Yawn.

Call me when they receive a signal from 24,963,500,379,000 miles away -- about 25 TRILLION miles. That's how far it is to the NEAREST star!

True, but considering that radio waves travel at the speed of light (as do TV signals), those signals have already reached 75 star systems, with that number growing all the time. If there are intelligent beings within that range who are capable of at least the science we have, it is a good bet that they know about us--at least to the extent that our media represents our civilization, which come to think of it is pretty negative most of the time.

Maybe they figure that we're not worth striking up a conversation. If all I knew of us is what is on our news and entertainment media, I know I'd come to that conclusion.

Taltarzac725 11-24-2023 08:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ThirdOfFive (Post 2277084)
True, but considering that radio waves travel at the speed of light (as do TV signals), those signals have already reached 75 star systems, with that number growing all the time. If there are intelligent beings within that range who are capable of at least the science we have, it is a good bet that they know about us--at least to the extent that our media represents our civilization, which come to think of it is pretty negative most of the time.

Maybe they figure that we're not worth striking up a conversation. If all I knew of us is what is on our news and entertainment media, I know I'd come to that conclusion.

They have probably been here over the past billions of years and probably planted the seeds of life at some point. I kind of doubt we were the first in the universe with life.

And they need not worry about us unless our technology develops a lot more and we can also travel at much faster speeds.

Taltarzac725 11-25-2023 10:49 PM

Age of the universe - Wikipedia

Putting things in perspective.

Two Bills 11-26-2023 05:45 AM

When I was a kid, we laughed at the absurdity of Dick Tracy and his two-way radio watch.
We now have them, and can practically run our lives with the things.

"Beam me up Scotty" became a joke expression.
The way things are going, wont be long before the first thread on TOTV appears about reckless transporters going the wrong way while beaming around space roundabouts!

cjrjck 11-26-2023 02:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Battlebasset (Post 2276567)
It would take 4.3 years moving at the speed of light to reach the nearest star. Space is really big. Bigger than anyone can imagine.

Add in the additional issues of the power needed, and all of the issues of time and relativity when traveling at the speed of light, it is a pretty good bet that we have never been visited, and we will never visit them or hear from them, assuming there is anything out there other than us.

And if you want to look at it from a Judeo-Christian religious perspective, there is no need for other intelligent life other than humans.

Well said. Einstein showed that the speed limit in space is the speed of light. Not only is it not feasible that our messages will reach some life form that would be able to understand them, it is not feasible they could ever visit us even if they wanted to. Personally, I think we are alone aside from those creatures mentioned in the bible. I challenge anyone to prove me wrong aside from some mathematical hypothesis.

frayedends 11-26-2023 03:01 PM

Einstein also thought the speed of light is constant but we now know it’s not. We thought we knew the age of the universe sine the Big Bang. But now the Webb telescope has brought this belief into question. We don’t know what we don’t know. If the being that created our simulation decides to have aliens visit us, they will visit us.

ThirdOfFive 11-26-2023 04:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frayedends (Post 2277543)
Einstein also thought the speed of light is constant but we now know it’s not. We thought we knew the age of the universe sine the Big Bang. But now the Webb telescope has brought this belief into question. We don’t know what we don’t know. If the being that created our simulation decides to have aliens visit us, they will visit us.

"We don’t know what we don’t know."

Sums it up perfectly.

And until we know what we don't, it seems pretty close-minded to conclude that we never will.

cjrjck 11-26-2023 05:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frayedends (Post 2277543)
Einstein also thought the speed of light is constant but we now know it’s not. We thought we knew the age of the universe sine the Big Bang. But now the Webb telescope has brought this belief into question. We don’t know what we don’t know. If the being that created our simulation decides to have aliens visit us, they will visit us.

We know that the speed of light is not constant? From Wikipedia: it has been suggested in various theories that the speed of light may have changed over time. No conclusive evidence for such changes has been found, but they remain the subject of ongoing research.

From theorized by some to "we know" is about as far apart as one side of the universe is to the other in the realm of science.

frayedends 11-26-2023 07:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cjrjck (Post 2277562)
We know that the speed of light is not constant? From Wikipedia: it has been suggested in various theories that the speed of light may have changed over time. No conclusive evidence for such changes has been found, but they remain the subject of ongoing research.

From theorized by some to "we know" is about as far apart as one side of the universe is to the other in the realm of science.

Newer research has found speed of light can be slowed. No evidence so far it can go faster but it’s not always constant. Wikipedia isn’t the best source for all updated info. Speed of light not so constant after all

Blueblaze 11-27-2023 01:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ThirdOfFive (Post 2277084)
True, but considering that radio waves travel at the speed of light (as do TV signals), those signals have already reached 75 star systems, with that number growing all the time. If there are intelligent beings within that range who are capable of at least the science we have, it is a good bet that they know about us--at least to the extent that our media represents our civilization, which come to think of it is pretty negative most of the time.

Maybe they figure that we're not worth striking up a conversation. If all I knew of us is what is on our news and entertainment media, I know I'd come to that conclusion.

No doubt, there is a race of spacefaring monsters out there, glued to their TV's, and on the verge of attacking the moment they discover that Dallas season 9 was just a dream -- which is exactly the plot of a Futurama episode. "Lrrrr", ruler of Omicron Persei 8, invades, conquers Earth, and goes away -- and Earth goes right back to the same lunacy we consider normal, here on our planet of backward lunatics.

The fact is, here in the real world, those radio waves would have degraded so far by the time they made it to the first star system, that even if it happened to be inhabited by an "advanced" civilization, they probably wouldn't have recognized what it was, even if they knew what to look for. Think about it -- this thread started with someone marveling that NASA managed to communicate over a mere 10 million miles -- and they had to use a focused laser to do it, with someone at the other end looking for it. Meanwhile, the nearest star is 500 thousand times farther than NASA's little experiment.

The most likely scenario is that, in a universe of a billion-billion stars, Earth TV transmissions probably won't make it to an advanced civilization until centuries after we're radioactive dust. That's how unimaginably huge the Universe is. There are undoubtedly millions of advanced civilizations in the Universe. The fact that we didn't detect one of them the moment SETI switched on the giant Arecibo antenna, tells you that we will never hear from any of them.

Villagevip 11-27-2023 01:39 PM

Right on predicted schedule from the seditious N.W O. deep state, NASA included...Don't be bamboozled again, election year ahead don'cha know...

ThirdOfFive 11-27-2023 02:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blueblaze (Post 2277718)
No doubt, there is a race of spacefaring monsters out there, glued to their TV's, and on the verge of attacking the moment they discover that Dallas season 9 was just a dream -- which is exactly the plot of a Futurama episode. "Lrrrr", ruler of Omicron Persei 8, invades, conquers Earth, and goes away -- and Earth goes right back to the same lunacy we consider normal, here on our planet of backward lunatics.

The fact is, here in the real world, those radio waves would have degraded so far by the time they made it to the first star system, that even if it happened to be inhabited by an "advanced" civilization, they probably wouldn't have recognized what it was, even if they knew what to look for. Think about it -- this thread started with someone marveling that NASA managed to communicate over a mere 10 million miles -- and they had to use a focused laser to do it, with someone at the other end looking for it. Meanwhile, the nearest star is 500 thousand times farther than NASA's little experiment.

The most likely scenario is that, in a universe of a billion-billion stars, Earth TV transmissions probably won't make it to an advanced civilization until centuries after we're radioactive dust. That's how unimaginably huge the Universe is. There are undoubtedly millions of advanced civilizations in the Universe. The fact that we didn't detect one of them the moment SETI switched on the giant Arecibo antenna, tells you that we will never hear from any of them.

Yet, the SETI program continues.

Is it possible that the folks in charge of that program have a bit more insight into the possibilities of contact being made than either you or I?

Dusty_Star 11-27-2023 04:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ThirdOfFive (Post 2277736)
Yet, the SETI program continues.

Is it possible that the folks in charge of that program have a bit more insight into the possibilities of contact being made than either you or I?

Probably maintaining their jobs & benefits, are their prime insight.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:32 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.