Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   Current Events and News (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/current-events-news-541/)
-   -   Washington's Birthday (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/current-events-news-541/washingtons-birthday-356670/)

retiredguy123 02-18-2025 10:45 AM

Washington's Birthday
 
Yesterday was a Federal holiday named Washington's Birthday. The holiday was created in 1879. It was not President's Day and it never has been. Also, there has never been a Federal holiday to celebrate Lincoln's Birthday.

Stu from NYC 02-18-2025 11:01 AM

Something wrong when the greatest American are not honored by their own special day

manaboutown 02-18-2025 12:54 PM

To me yesterday was Washington's Birthday. When I lived and worked in the D.C. area in the mid to late 1960s the Washington's Birthday sales in the stores on F Street were incredible. I remember buying a formal coat and tails which fit me like it was tailored for me for $22. I gave it to a close friend my size who played in the National Symphony. He wore it at performances requiring such attire.

MarshBendLover 02-18-2025 02:12 PM

I believe GW was born on the 22nd same as me, not the same year, I was a few years later. But since federal employees wanted a long weekend, it was moved to the Monday nearest his day which was renamed Pres Day to avoid confusion of his actual birthday. Which really just did create even more confusion, which is odd considering the government never creates confusion.

retiredguy123 02-18-2025 02:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CigarMaster (Post 2410253)
I believe GW was born on the 22nd same as me, not the same year, I was a few years later. But since federal employees wanted a long weekend, it was moved to the Monday nearest his day which was renamed Pres Day to avoid confusion of his actual birthday. Which really just did create even more confusion, which is odd considering the government never creates confusion.

Wrong. The holiday was moved to a Monday, as well as other Federal holidays. But the Federal holiday was never changed to President's Day. It is named Washington's Birthday and it always has been. There is no Federal holiday named President's Day.

Some state holidays are named President's Day, but not the Federal holiday. There is a lot of misinformation in the media about this subject.

OrangeBlossomBaby 02-18-2025 03:28 PM

I'm okay with there being just one day a year to celebrate the birthday, deathday, wedding anniversary, bar mitzvah, mom's favorite boy's special dinner option day, or whatever else. The last thing we all need is ANOTHER paid day off for the government and banks, and ANOTHER reason to close schools and halt their education for another day, ALL for the celebration of a single individual.

I'd be okay with an Election Day becoming a Federal holiday. But no, not a day to celebrate any individual president. President's Day is a great idea. Federalize it, and ditch Washington and Lincoln and whoever else. And maybe they could add "Presidents of the United States" as a mandatory curriculum item in school history classes, the month before that day (whenever it is).

retiredguy123 02-18-2025 03:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 2410275)
I'm okay with there being just one day a year to celebrate the birthday, deathday, wedding anniversary, bar mitzvah, mom's favorite boy's special dinner option day, or whatever else. The last thing we all need is ANOTHER paid day off for the government and banks, and ANOTHER reason to close schools and halt their education for another day, ALL for the celebration of a single individual.

I'd be okay with an Election Day becoming a Federal holiday. But no, not a day to celebrate any individual president. President's Day is a great idea. Federalize it, and ditch Washington and Lincoln and whoever else. And maybe they could add "Presidents of the United States" as a mandatory curriculum item in school history classes, the month before that day (whenever it is).

Fine, but there are some in the media who want to do away with President's Day, when it doesn't even exist. There is no President's Day and there never has been, except for some state holidays. Some people on national TV are spreading false information that there is a national President's Day that needs to be eliminated.

sowilts 02-19-2025 08:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 2410196)
Yesterday was a Federal holiday named Washington's Birthday. The holiday was created in 1879. It was not President's Day and it never has been. Also, there has never been a Federal holiday to celebrate Lincoln's Birthday.

Retired, everyday is a Holiday for me.

CybrSage 02-19-2025 08:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 2410203)
Something wrong when the greatest American are not honored by their own special day

Washington was the greatest president we ever had. Without him, there would be no United States.

If Lincoln lost the war, there would still be the US, just smaller than today.

Rick Steeber 02-19-2025 10:08 AM

Presidents Day
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by CigarMaster (Post 2410253)
I believe GW was born on the 22nd same as me, not the same year, I was a few years later. But since federal employees wanted a long weekend, it was moved to the Monday nearest his day which was renamed Pres Day to avoid confusion of his actual birthday. Which really just did create even more confusion, which is odd considering the government never creates confusion.

You are correct Washington was born on Feb 22nd. Also Lincoln was born on February 12th. They combined the two Presidents birthdays to make it Presidents Day and set it for the Monday in between the two Presidents. Making it a Monday, so Federal employees could have a long weekend...

Stu from NYC 02-19-2025 10:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CybrSage (Post 2410385)
Washington was the greatest president we ever had. Without him, there would be no United States.

If Lincoln lost the war, there would still be the US, just smaller than today.

They both deserve their own day. Get rid of one or two more recent federal holidays.

Colts Fan 02-19-2025 10:29 AM

If Lincoln had lost the war we wouldn’t presently be living in the US.

cegallup 02-19-2025 10:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CigarMaster (Post 2410253)
I believe GW was born on the 22nd same as me, not the same year, I was a few years later. But since federal employees wanted a long weekend, it was moved to the Monday nearest his day which was renamed Pres Day to avoid confusion of his actual birthday. Which really just did create even more confusion, which is odd considering the government never creates confusion.

Just another perverse narrative which points to the indifference we place on our great heroes of American history. Without the amazing courage and tenacity of this leader we would NOT have our "FREE" country. (the same respect should be shown to Abraham Lincoln.)

manaboutown 02-19-2025 10:38 AM

George Washington was born in Virginia on February 11, 1731, according to the then-used Julian calendar. In 1752, however, Britain and all its colonies adopted the Gregorian calendar which moved Washington's birthday a year and 11 days to February 22, 1732.

From: George Washington's Birthday | National Archives.

blueash 02-19-2025 10:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 2410278)
Fine, but there are some in the media who want to do away with President's Day, when it doesn't even exist. There is no President's Day and there never has been, except for some state holidays. Some people on national TV are spreading false information that there is a national President's Day that needs to be eliminated.

If you want to nitpick details and formalities... Washington was not born on Feb 22nd. He was born on what a calendar in 1731 would tell you was Feb 11th. Julian calendar recalculation did a job on messing up dates.

President Clinton might have disagreed with your assertion that there is no Presidents' Day when in 2000 he issued a Presidential Proclamation

Quote:



PRESIDENT'S DAY PROCLAMATION


I am pleased to join all Americans in observing Presidents' Day.

Today we salute the leadership and achievements of all those who have held America's highest elected office, and we celebrate with special pride the rich legacies of Presidents Washington and Lincoln.
Of grammatical interest... the proclamation uses both options for placement of the apostrophe. Or somebody didn't notice

And our Federal government Presidents' Day | GovInfo has a webpage giving the history of Presidents' Day. It does explain that no Federal rule has given it that name but the common usage, everyone's calendar, and society have settled on assigning Presidents' Day to the 3rd Monday in February.

Quote:

While the name change has never been authorized by Congress, it has gained a strong hold on the public consciousness to honor all U.S. Presidents, and is generally used on calendars, in advertising, and even by many government agencies.

retiredguy123 02-19-2025 01:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rick Steeber (Post 2410416)
You are correct Washington was born on Feb 22nd. Also Lincoln was born on February 12th. They combined the two Presidents birthdays to make it Presidents Day and set it for the Monday in between the two Presidents. Making it a Monday, so Federal employees could have a long weekend...

Wrong. Who is they? Only Congess can create a Federal holiday. They never created a Federal holiday named President's Day, and they never created a Federal holiday for Lincoln.

Babbs1957 02-19-2025 10:11 PM

Yes he was born Feb 22nd. The wrong birthday due to the British calendar was just a theory just like the theory he fathered a child from his slave.

Lyndon Johnson in 1968 moved 4 holidays to Mondays so there would be a 3 day weekend. Washington's birthday was moved to a Monday on that. It was known as the Uniform Monday Holiday Act.

Argument has long been that once it was moved to Monday it no longer actually celebrated his birthday, so it came to be known as Presidents Day. Of course Clinton verified it.

At GSA it was Presidents Day and it was a day off.

OrangeBlossomBaby 02-19-2025 10:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 2410278)
Fine, but there are some in the media who want to do away with President's Day, when it doesn't even exist. There is no President's Day and there never has been, except for some state holidays. Some people on national TV are spreading false information that there is a national President's Day that needs to be eliminated.

I'm not seeing the problem here. If it doesn't exist in the first place, then why would anyone care if everyone wants it eradicated?

However, it IS a Federal holiday. It's one of the 11 holidays recognized by the Federal Reserve, which is why banks nationwide are closed on Presidents' Day. It's why there's no mail that day, the DMV and all non-essential government offices are closed that day.

OrangeBlossomBaby 02-19-2025 10:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 2410417)
They both deserve their own day. Get rid of one or two more recent federal holidays.

I'd get rid of Christmas day as a Federal holiday, because it's a religious holiday and Christianity is not an official National Religion.

I'd also get rid of Labor Day, because it is a hypocritical "holiday" forcing retail and other service employees to work EXTRA that day. It doesn't honor labor at all.

J1ceasar 02-20-2025 07:46 AM

Where were the flags
 
I don't care what day you make it and what you call it but when you talk about celebrating some of the most wonderful presidents we had, why don't they put up flags?

Topspinmo 02-20-2025 08:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 2410275)
I'm okay with there being just one day a year to celebrate the birthday, deathday, wedding anniversary, bar mitzvah, mom's favorite boy's special dinner option day, or whatever else. The last thing we all need is ANOTHER paid day off for the government and banks, and ANOTHER reason to close schools and halt their education for another day, ALL for the celebration of a single individual.

I'd be okay with an Election Day becoming a Federal holiday. But no, not a day to celebrate any individual president. President's Day is a great idea. Federalize it, and ditch Washington and Lincoln and whoever else. And maybe they could add "Presidents of the United States" as a mandatory curriculum item in school history classes, the month before that day (whenever it is).

reason to close schools and halt their education for another day!

Agree, public education get enough days off with all semester/ holidays breaks. Why we are behind in education vs dollars spent.

Topspinmo 02-20-2025 08:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 2410559)
I'd get rid of Christmas day as a Federal holiday, because it's a religious holiday and Christianity is not an official National Religion.

I'd also get rid of Labor Day, because it is a hypocritical "holiday" forcing retail and other service employees to work EXTRA that day. It doesn't honor labor at all.

Naa not really only reason business are open to make money. They don’t have to close on any holiday, employees know this when they got hired on. Easter not federal holiday yet many businesses Are closed not to mention public school holiday. IMO they should be only two federal holidays, Memorial Day, and Veterans Day. They only ones who sacrificed for country. But we know how far opinions go…

Janie123 02-20-2025 09:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 2410266)
Wrong. The holiday was moved to a Monday, as well as other Federal holidays. But the Federal holiday was never changed to President's Day. It is named Washington's Birthday and it always has been. There is no Federal holiday named President's Day.

Some state holidays are named President's Day, but not the Federal holiday. There is a lot of misinformation in the media about this subject.

Washington’s Birthday: the Federal Holiday – Pieces of History

daverabin 02-20-2025 11:38 AM

Geoge's Birthday
 
Isn't Georges birthday February 22 and Lincoln's is February 12:crap2:

Stryker 02-20-2025 07:34 PM

Is it celebrated in the gulf of america?

OrangeBlossomBaby 02-20-2025 07:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Topspinmo (Post 2410632)
Naa not really only reason business are open to make money. They don’t have to close on any holiday, employees know this when they got hired on. Easter not federal holiday yet many businesses Are closed not to mention public school holiday. IMO they should be only two federal holidays, Memorial Day, and Veterans Day. They only ones who sacrificed for country. But we know how far opinions go…

Easter isn't a public school holiday. Easter is always on a Sunday. Public schools are always closed on Sunday. Easter being a holiday has zero effect on public schools at all.

You should honor veterans every day. If you need a specific day of the year to honor them, then you're doing it wrong.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:55 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.