Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   The Villages, Florida, General Discussion (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/)
-   -   Do you care about your carbon footprint? (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/do-you-care-about-your-carbon-footprint-52132/)

jimbo2012 04-22-2012 07:04 PM

Do you care about your carbon footprint?
 
In researching TV and deciding to move here later this year I was bit surprised to see what in my opinion is the disregard of folks driving gas powered golf carts around town.

Of the 50,000+ carts there are approximately half gas/elec.

I researched a bit as what the exhaust gases are contributing to the air you breathe.

In 2004 Princeton University reported on the possibility of reducing the amount of gas emissions from the University fleet. A total of 92 golf carts. on campus provided the largest amount of harmful emissions - carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and other gases.

Not to post a bunch of calculations and bore you with numbers but 1 gas cart produces about the same emissions as 6 Ford Taurus'

In 2010 Go Green College, calculated based on their 100 carts half gas half elec the following;

50 gas carts generates 161,200 pounds of CO2 a year!
50 electric powered carts generates only 41,700 pounds of CO2 a year!

So about 4 times the about.

So here 25,000 gas carts produce 500 times that amount or 80 million pounds of CO2 a year!

Did I do that math right? 80 million lbs

John_W 04-22-2012 07:34 PM

One of the first things I did after moving into our home was to remove the 3 incandescent 40 watt light bulbs from the driveway lampost and replace them with 3 flourescent 40 watt bulbs that use 9 watts each. That's 120 watts versus 27 watts that burn everynight in front of every home in TV, just imagine if the builder had done that to the over 40,000 homes in TV, how much electricity could be saved in a single evening.

jimbo2012 04-22-2012 07:37 PM

Great,

Go a step further LED bulbs, now you're really saving.

cappyjon431 04-22-2012 07:40 PM

We care very much. Our cart is electric. We recycle about three times the volume of what we put out as trash. We compost. We bought all new energy efficient appliances.

My one regret is that I still have my SUV. We try to use it as little as possible and mainly use the cart. I eventually will replace it with something more fuel efficient. In the mean time, I need something that size to haul all of my dive gear and my paddleboards.

l2ridehd 04-22-2012 08:18 PM

And as usual in this argument not all the facts are presented. How much CO2 does the coal fired power plant produce to generate the electricity to charge the batteries in 25000 golf carts every night? How is the disposal of the 6 batteries average per cart replaced on average every 3.5 years or 2,142,857 pounds of batteries disposal every year contribute to the environment?

Each type of cart has problems. If it bothers you that much, go find a place to live where you can walk everywhere. All of us chose The Villages because of the lifestyle. And that lifestyle is sold, advertised and branded as a golf cart community. So don't now try to tell me the type of cart I have to drive.

This very dumb argument will continue forever. Everyone has an opinion on one side of this or the other and they will never give it up. We should all try to minimize our use of resources. Use lower wattage bulbs where it makes sense, walk when possible, recycle as much as possible and many other things. But the gas vs electric cart just seems to go on forever. I personally own one of each. Love them both and they both have a place in The Villages use requirements.

jimbo2012 04-22-2012 08:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by l2ridehd (Post 483032)
And as usual in this argument not all the facts are presented. How much CO2 does the coal fired power plant produce to generate the electricity to charge the batteries in 25000 golf carts every night?

The figures above included that energy
"50 electric powered carts generates only 41,700 pounds of CO2 a year!"

Even at that, the elec uses 1/4 that of gas carts, agree?

Quote:

How is the disposal of the 6 batteries average per cart replaced on average every 3.5 years or 2,142,857 pounds of batteries disposal every year contribute to the environment?
According to battery council international
Environmental Benefits
Lead-acid batteries are the environmental success story of our time. More than 97 percent of all battery lead is recycled. lead-acid batteries top the list of the most highly recycled consumer product.

http://www.gravitaexim.com/images/ba...ng_process.jpg

Quote:

So don't now try to tell me the type of cart I have to drive.
I didn't think I was telling anyone that ?
Drive what you wish it's your carbon footprint

.

sandybill2 04-22-2012 08:40 PM

We have an electric cart----one of the reasons is that our grown son is asthmatic---he was here for a week recently and actually had a problem with his breathing due to driving through the golf cart tunnels and the gas fume odors that seem to linger there. We recycle everything that is allowed. We also drive a Prius.

lovesports 04-22-2012 10:24 PM

We care very much about our carbon footprint.
We drive an electric golf cart and hate to be behind a gas cart.
Our cart holds its charge for so long, we go from one end of the Villages to the other and still have tons of charge left.
We have a young grandchild and we want her to have a healthy Earth as her home.
Jimbo, Thanks for posting this on Earth Day.

CMANN 04-22-2012 10:27 PM

The religion I hate most: Greenism!:pray:

ilovetv 04-22-2012 10:38 PM

Ah, yes. The "wonderful" COAL-FIRED golf cart.

I'd like an electric one in addition to our gas one, and maybe we'll just do that one of these days.

And yes, CMann.....it IS a "religion".

CarGuys 04-22-2012 11:00 PM

Yes!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbo2012 (Post 482996)
In researching TV and deciding to move here later this year I was bit surprised to see what in my opinion is the disregard of folks driving gas powered golf carts around town.

Of the 50,000+ carts there are approximately half gas/elec.

I researched a bit as what the exhaust gases are contributing to the air you breathe.

In 2004 Princeton University reported on the possibility of reducing the amount of gas emissions from the University fleet. A total of 92 golf carts. on campus provided the largest amount of harmful emissions - carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and other gases.

Not to post a bunch of calculations and bore you with numbers but 1 gas cart produces about the same emissions as 6 Ford Taurus'

In 2010 Go Green College, calculated based on their 100 carts half gas half elec the following;

50 gas carts generates 161,200 pounds of CO2 a year!
50 electric powered carts generates only 41,700 pounds of CO2 a year!

So about 4 times the about.

So here 25,000 gas carts produce 500 times that amount or 80 million pounds of CO2 a year!

Did I do that math right? 80 million lbs

Yes you did well. And you are right! However you and I are a minority on alternative fuel transportation.

I agree with you on the Carts. You make valid points but as I2RdHD has commented the debate will go on forever!

Just available if anyone is interested my local talkshow. CarGuys www.cnytalkradio.com Saturdays 8-9 1390 WFBL Syracuse NY - streaming on the web

Hey you can go green and still be macho. check out the Green Grand Prix. Welcome To The Official Green Grand Prix Web Site

A Clean sities associate of mine took second place at Watkins Glen in a Compressed Natural Gas Ford F250. :thumbup: I should have Barry Carr on this Saturday from Clean Cities and I will be calling to do my show from TV.

jimbo2012 04-22-2012 11:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sandybill2 (Post 483040)
our grown son is asthmatic---he was here for a week recently and actually had a problem with his breathing due to driving through the golf cart tunnels and the gas fume odors that seem to linger there.

Interesting point, unfortunately.

Quote:

Originally Posted by lovesports (Post 483059)
We care very much about our carbon footprint.
We drive an electric golf cart and hate to be behind a gas cart.

Glad you care and I guess it's like being behind a bus.

Quote:

We have a young grandchild and we want her to have a healthy Earth as her home.
Jimbo, Thanks for posting this on Earth Day.
:BigApplause:

jimbo2012 04-22-2012 11:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CarGuys (Post 483070)
However you and I are a minority on alternative fuel transportation.
I agree with you on the Carts. You make valid points but as I2RdHD has commented the debate will go on forever

not sure yet how much of a minority we may be yet, I'll know more when I move there in few months.

I saw the same naysayers posting the same arguments before however they can't support those positions with facts.

I just impeached the lead waste argument.
biggest advantage is that elec carts don't release harmful toxins into the air and R quieter.

I think anyone can make their own choice, but I hope they make the right choice for what they may be leaving for their children & grandchildren.

We don't really have much choice for somethings that affect the carbon footprint,
but we sure have a choice in a golf cart that does the same function if it's gas or elec.

Not sure if the local dealers are pushing gas over elec based on profit.



.

thekeithfan 04-23-2012 05:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbo2012 (Post 482996)
In researching TV and deciding to move here later this year I was bit surprised to see what in my opinion is the disregard of folks driving gas powered golf carts around town.

Of the 50,000+ carts there are approximately half gas/elec.

I researched a bit as what the exhaust gases are contributing to the air you breathe.

In 2004 Princeton University reported on the possibility of reducing the amount of gas emissions from the University fleet. A total of 92 golf carts. on campus provided the largest amount of harmful emissions - carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and other gases.

Not to post a bunch of calculations and bore you with numbers but 1 gas cart produces about the same emissions as 6 Ford Taurus'

In 2010 Go Green College, calculated based on their 100 carts half gas half elec the following;

50 gas carts generates 161,200 pounds of CO2 a year!
50 electric powered carts generates only 41,700 pounds of CO2 a year!

So about 4 times the about.

So here 25,000 gas carts produce 500 times that amount or 80 million pounds of CO2 a year!

Did I do that math right? 80 million lbs

I guess it won't be long now before the environmental wackos will legislate "cleaner" golf carts and that will beat the carts mpg down and the cost up. Me? gas cart when i'm not in that I'm in a 450 horsepower diesel truck hauling a fifth wheel reacreational vehicle spewing carbon all over the USA. I have a gas mower too.

Barefoot 04-23-2012 06:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lovesports (Post 483059)
We care very much about our carbon footprint.
We drive an electric golf cart and hate to be behind a gas cart.
Our cart holds its charge for so long, we go from one end of the Villages to the other and still have tons of charge left.

We also have an electric cart which seems to hold a charge forever, even with golfing and driving all over TV. I personally find gas carts to be noisy and smelly, but it is a personal choice, and many people I respect choose gas carts. On a positive note, I've learned to hold my breath for a really long time! Before I enter a tunnel, I take a deep breath, and I don't take another breath until I clear the tunnel. That takes care of my allergy problem.

JoeC1947 04-23-2012 06:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John_W (Post 483010)
One of the first things I did after moving into our home was to remove the 3 incandescent 40 watt light bulbs from the driveway lampost and replace them with 3 flourescent 40 watt bulbs that use 9 watts each. That's 120 watts versus 27 watts that burn everynight in front of every home in TV, just imagine if the builder had done that to the over 40,000 homes in TV, how much electricity could be saved in a single evening.

One of the first things I did was to unscrew two of the bulbs a little and just use one at a time. When that one burns out I just reach in and screw the next "spare bulb" in. When all three are burnt out I replace them all and start over.

salpal 04-23-2012 06:24 AM

energy waster
 
On another note, I am surprised at the number of refrigerators I see in garages. Do two people in one home really need two refrigerators? I understand about the convenience of keeping one's beverages cold, but refrigerators are big energy wasters. Okay, let the attacks begin. :sigh:

JoeC1947 04-23-2012 06:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Barefoot (Post 483104)
We also have an electric cart which seems to hold a charge forever, even with golfing and driving all over TV. I personally find gas carts to be noisy and smelly, but it is a personal choice, and many people I respect choose gas carts. On a positive note, I've learned to hold my breath for a really long time! Before I enter a tunnel, I take a deep breath, and I don't take another breath until I clear the tunnel. That takes care of my allergy problem.

The fumes also attract love bugs.

jimbo2012 04-23-2012 06:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by salpal (Post 483109)
On another note, I am surprised at the number of refrigerators I see in garages. Do two people in one home really need two refrigerators? I understand about the convenience of keeping one's beverages cold, but refrigerators are big energy wasters.

Perhaps the space is needed by their lifestyle but there's no alternative to powering a fridge.

There R alternatives in carts, either one accomplishes the same task and the costs to buy - about the same.

senior citizen 04-23-2012 06:46 AM

...

senior citizen 04-23-2012 07:01 AM

...

Dirigo 04-23-2012 07:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbo2012 (Post 482996)
In researching TV and deciding to move here later this year I was bit surprised to see what in my opinion is the disregard of folks driving gas powered golf carts around town.

Of the 50,000+ carts there are approximately half gas/elec.

I researched a bit as what the exhaust gases are contributing to the air you breathe.

In 2004 Princeton University reported on the possibility of reducing the amount of gas emissions from the University fleet. A total of 92 golf carts. on campus provided the largest amount of harmful emissions - carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and other gases.

Not to post a bunch of calculations and bore you with numbers but 1 gas cart produces about the same emissions as 6 Ford Taurus'

In 2010 Go Green College, calculated based on their 100 carts half gas half elec the following;

50 gas carts generates 161,200 pounds of CO2 a year!
50 electric powered carts generates only 41,700 pounds of CO2 a year!

So about 4 times the about.

So here 25,000 gas carts produce 500 times that amount or 80 million pounds of CO2 a year!

Did I do that math right? 80 million lbs

What about all the exhaust from the lawn mowers, edgers, and leaf blowers used in TV? Aren't they worse polluters than gas golf carts?

Pehaps a new business start-up could cut lawns with an old fashioned people-powered reel mower and rake lawns and sweep driveways and walkways? They could also compost the clippings and leaves.

Of course the price for all that manual labor would be quite high compared to the way it is being done now, but there may be a business opportunity catrering to those who are concerned about their carbon footprint.

graciegirl 04-23-2012 07:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dirigo (Post 483142)
What about all the exhaust from the lawn mowers, edgers, and leaf blowers used in TV? Aren't they worse polluters than gas golf carts?

Pehaps a new business start-up could cut lawns with an old fashioned people-powered reel mower and rake lawns and sweep driveways and walkways? They could also compost the clippings and leaves.

Of course the price for all that manual labor would be quite high compared to the way it is being done now, but there may be a business opportunity catrering to those who are concerned about their carbon footprint.


We eat leftovers. Every little bit helps the old lady said as she pees in the sea.

jimbo2012 04-23-2012 07:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dirigo (Post 483142)
What about all the exhaust from the lawn mowers, edgers, and leaf blowers used in TV? Aren't they worse polluters than gas golf carts?

I would think they are just as bad, any gas engine with or without emission controls is bad for our environment.

However, there aren't 25,000 + of them running around day and night.

looneycat 04-23-2012 08:05 AM

it is approx 16 miles from rt42 to rt 44 on Buena Vista
the average electric golf cart can make that round trip once.
the 'new' 60 mile range carts can make that trip maybe 1.5 times since I've yet to hear of anyone getting much more than 45 miles a charge.
So, with a standard electric cart you can get around pretty good but not drive around all day and must always keep your range in mind (we have all seen the carts being towed in because the batteries died).
In a gas cart you do not need to think about range as long as you have a full tank you can drive for days. I have electric now, when I replace it I will get gas!

billethkid 04-23-2012 08:11 AM

NO!

btk

looneycat 04-23-2012 08:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dirigo (Post 483142)
What about all the exhaust from the lawn mowers, edgers, and leaf blowers used in TV? Aren't they worse polluters than gas golf carts?

Pehaps a new business start-up could cut lawns with an old fashioned people-powered reel mower and rake lawns and sweep driveways and walkways? They could also compost the clippings and leaves.

Of course the price for all that manual labor would be quite high compared to the way it is being done now, but there may be a business opportunity catrering to those who are concerned about their carbon footprint.

and you have to give up eating beef since cows arguably have the worst carbon footprint of food animals.....oh no not my burgers!!

skyguy79 04-23-2012 09:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by looneycat (Post 483163)
and you have to give up eating beef since cows arguably have the worst carbon footprint of food animals.....oh no not my burgers!!

It would seem to me that if we stopped eating beef that the cattle population would increase and it would therefore be a reasonable conclusion that the if the cattle population increases, so would the carbon footprint. Smile looney, your Whimpy burgers are safe!
http://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:A...I4MGG52eGu5mZQ

looneycat 04-23-2012 09:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by skyguy79 (Post 483185)
It would seem to me that if we stopped eating beef that the cattle population would increase and it would therefore be a reasonable conclusion that the if the cattle population increases, so would the carbon footprint. Smile looney, your Whimpy burgers are safe!
http://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:A...I4MGG52eGu5mZQ

burgers, burgers, yum...I would gladly pay you tuesday for a hamburger you give me today...:mmmm:

I was speaking to the car'boners' that want to reduce the herds as well...all in the name of carbon footprint!
:oops:

skyguy79 04-23-2012 09:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by looneycat (Post 483192)
burgers, burgers, yum...I would gladly pay you tuesday for a hamburger you give me today...:mmmm:

I was speaking to the car'boners' that want to reduce the herds as well...all in the name of carbon footprint!
:oops:

That wouldn't surprise me as there are some who would want to do similarily to the human population for whatever their motivation might be! 60 Plus Association

Golfer in Sanibel 04-23-2012 09:40 AM

I don't care. I think it's all BS. Bad science based on wrong assumptions. Just saying because you asked. :confused:

angiefox10 04-23-2012 09:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by skyguy79 (Post 483185)
It would seem to me that if we stopped eating beef that the cattle population would increase and it would therefore be a reasonable conclusion that the if the cattle population increases, so would the carbon footprint. Smile looney, your Whimpy burgers are safe!
http://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:A...I4MGG52eGu5mZQ

That's why I say... Spay and neuter your cow!

looneycat 04-23-2012 09:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by angiefox10 (Post 483206)
That's why I say... Spay and neuter your cow!

and that's no bull!

jimbo2012 04-23-2012 09:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by looneycat (Post 483151)
it is approx 16 miles from rt42 to rt 44 on Buena Vista
the average electric golf cart can make that round trip once.
the 'new' 60 mile range carts can make that trip maybe 1.5 times since I've yet to hear of anyone getting much more than 45 miles a charge.

I saw this posted here

Quote:

Originally Posted by ajbrown (Post 475522)
My 6 volt T105 batteries turned two years old and I wanted to share some range testing

My test runs:
  • Front window was down as it was hot, but this would decrease wind resistance and increase range.
  • Only weight in cart was a husky man, lab assistant Caly, and possibly a couple of beverages with enough ice to keep them cold.
  • All driving was on tar paths or roads.
  • All mileage was not continuous. I stopped for periods of 15-30 minutes at various places to visit and take voltages of the pack.
  • Voltages were measured after the pack rested for 15-30 minutes post arrival at a destination. (Future post will have details of voltages for the truly curious)
  • The distance was measured with the cart speedometer and a GPS app on my Blackberry, I used the lower number.

Test run one: 42+ miles, ending voltage was 48.6 volts (~55% SOC)
Test run two: 63+ miles, ending voltage was 47.6 volts (~37% SOC) (last run of 9.5 miles had lights on)

I was extremely pleased with these numbers.

Now with solar just over the horizon, we should see 75+ mile ranges soon.


.

looneycat 04-23-2012 09:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbo2012 (Post 483144)
I would think they are just as bad, any gas engine with or without emission controls is bad for our environment.

However, there aren't 25,000 + of them running around day and night.

actually I would bet that the total of all the gas run lawn implements used daily would probably be in the 8,000-10,000 range between the private homes, golf courses and public land in the 100+ square miles of the villages.

Wing-nut2 04-23-2012 10:14 AM

No.

looneycat 04-23-2012 10:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbo2012 (Post 483216)
I saw this posted here



Now with solar just over the horizon, we should see 75+ mile ranges soon.


.

atypical but thanks for pointing this post out. If you had good practical experience, i.e. lived here, you'd know. sorry.

thekeithfan 04-23-2012 10:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by senior citizen (Post 483121)
Our adult children and grandchildren are HUGE into the green movement.

Ditto for other relatives in California who keep sending us circulating emails about not having the pipeline come down from Alaska, etc., etc., etc.

For those who live in a colder climate who must use home heating oil and have seen the prices escalate to as much as their yearly property taxes, gasoline isn't really the big deal in a small walkable town that has all the services one needs, meaning not a lot of driving unless heading off to visit or on vacation. We use very little gasoline but a lot of home heating oil.

But there are folks in New England who go CRAZY trying to avoid purchasing heating oil........so yank out their baseboard hot water heating system to put in pellet stoves and regular wood stoves, plus wood furnaces all over the house.......then have to chop and split **wood all year long to keep the fires going (and the smoke does contribute to breathing issues).........I find it a lot easier to turn one of the four themostats either up or down. **not killing the trees.

We have kids who have taught their kids "not to flush" if it is yellow.

So, we've lived in both these worlds. They recycle. It's all admirable.

We have switched from paper cards to electronic ecards ........that saves paper and postage.

We've always bought smaller sized cars, but brand new. After this last visit to The Villages, my husband so admired the SMOOTH ROADS down there that he immediately purchased a full sized new gas guzzler car similar to the one he rented at Orlando International Airport. It was retired man's one luxury.

Upon returning and picking up our one year old car at the long term parking, he realized how bad our pot holed roads are up here.........so he's going the opposite way from "being into saving of the planet."

The planet doesn't need saving when it is done with us it will shudder and like the dinasoars we will be gone and 200 years after that there will be little trace that humans were ever here.
Being from New England I did cut wood and burned wood to keep warm not to mention saving a little on a $750.00 per month oil bill. It kept me in shape as well. Burning wood is not killing trees firewood is basically wood from trees that are dying or trees that need to be removed so that other trees grow more healthy and to make room for new seedlings. Not to mention the fact that most of the wood comes from the great N'oreasters blowing the trees down and we need to cut them up and dispose of them.

jimbo2012 04-23-2012 10:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by looneycat (Post 483217)
actually I would bet that the total of all the gas run lawn implements used daily would probably be in the 8,000-10,000 range between the private homes, golf courses and public land in the 100+ square miles of the villages.

Not sure how you figured that?

50,000 homes once a month for 15Min I guess more like 75 landscapers working a day.

It's more like 50 square miles I think.

jimbo2012 04-23-2012 10:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by looneycat (Post 483223)
atypical but thanks for pointing this post out. If you had good practical experience, i.e. lived here, you'd know. sorry.

I spent the last 5 winters south of TV, where there were golf carts.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:36 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.