Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   Investment Talk (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/investment-talk-158/)
-   -   Who feels it necessary to keep their securities distributed among several brokerages? (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/investment-talk-158/who-feels-necessary-keep-their-securities-distributed-among-several-brokerages-344073/)

manaboutown 09-12-2023 10:18 AM

Who feels it necessary to keep their securities distributed among several brokerages?
 
Recently I picked up a book by Charles Schwab, 'Invested'.

To say it was an eye opener is an understatement. It starts with why and how he got into discount brokerage as one of its pioneers. It then goes on to report the ups, downs and very scary times his company went through. I had no idea!

I know many people, particularly those who trade a lot, use Schwab. Although I have kept a small account at Schwab for years I rarely used it. Then last year and earlier this year I sold a couple commercial real estate properties and deposited the proceeds into Schwab, primarily because I wanted to put it into T-bills. Schwab allows a retail investor to buy and sell them whereas the other two brokerages where I have historically kept most of my securities do not.

Then, surprise, surprise, I started getting phone calls from a Schwab 'Advisor' which I ignored for a time. Eventually I returned a call just to let him know I existed. When he discovered I was not a newbie and had other accounts he urged, just short of insisted, I transfer them to Schwab. I declined and told him I had a pretty good memory and remember Lehman Bros. and others which he seemed to grasp. I thereafter discovered Schwab at that time held some long term treasuries which were destined to go down as interest were rising so I still feel a little skittish about it all.

Anyway after reading this book to sleep at night I feel I need to continue to keep my securities distributed among several wirehouses and wonder if others feel the same.

Nell57 09-12-2023 10:23 AM

I’ve been wondering about this, too.
Hope there is some good discussion….

retiredguy123 09-12-2023 10:27 AM

I use Vanguard Investments and Fidelity Investments. Stock, bond, and money market mutual funds. No individual stocks or bonds.

manaboutown 09-12-2023 11:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 2255830)
I use Vanguard Investments and Fidelity Investments. Stock, bond, and money market mutual funds. No individual stocks or bonds.

I use Vanguard, too. For both historic and recent reasons I will not use Fidelity. I use Ameriprise too because I have had several entity accounts with them going back to their 1980s days as Olde Discount. They charge a small brokerage fee but I rarely buy or sell.

The book I cited reveals how ridiculously high various fees were charged retail customers before May Day 1975 when discount brokers started to come into the picture.

Stu from NYC 09-12-2023 12:58 PM

Looking for good performing funds we use several families

retiredguy123 09-12-2023 01:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 2255904)
Looking for good performing funds we use several families

Go with index funds. They are cheap and effective. Vanguard S&P 500 Stock Index fund, Vanguard Short Term Bond Index fund, and Vanguard Total Bond Market fund. I also have some money in the Vanguard High Yield Corporate Bond fund.

Smalley 09-12-2023 06:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 2255830)
I use Vanguard Investments and Fidelity Investments. Stock, bond, and money market mutual funds. No individual stocks or bonds.

Fidelity and Vanguard are our companies as well.

Pugchief 09-12-2023 07:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by manaboutown (Post 2255864)
For both historic and recent reasons I will not use Fidelity.

Care to elaborate?

I find Fidelity superior to Vanguard in just about every metric except expense ratios on money market funds (which leads to sightly lower yields).

Ecuadog 09-12-2023 09:38 PM

We have been with Vanguard. Not too long ago. we opened some accounts at Fidelity. I was getting concerned about the SIPC insurance covering our accounts or "separate capacities" at Vanguard. I was also interested in sending international bank transfers, for which Fidelity doesn't charge.

I like Fidelity's platform much more than Vanguard's, but the sweep accounts and money market funds earn more at Vanguard. I also favor a couple of Vanguard's funds.

I don't know if it's still true, but I found that Vanguard will not let you designate beneficiaries for a joint account, while Fidelity allows it.

tophcfa 09-12-2023 10:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 2255830)
I use Vanguard Investments and Fidelity Investments. Stock, bond, and money market mutual funds. No individual stocks or bonds.

Same here

spinner1001 09-13-2023 03:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by manaboutown (Post 2255821)
Anyway after reading this book to sleep at night I feel I need to continue to keep my securities distributed among several wirehouses and wonder if others feel the same.

Objectively, the probability of Schwab, a large NYSE listed firm, failing to make its investment account holders whole is very remote.

First, in the hierarchy of who suffers losses, stockholders loose first. Investment account holders like you loose only after stockholders.

Second, practically speaking, the U.S. government and Federal Reserve would not let the account holders loose for policy reasons because Schwab’s failure would cause a global financial crisis like we have never seen.

Third, Schwab has about $512 billion in assets as of June 30, 2023 (latest data available) and the market value of its common stock today is about $110 billion. Of the $512 billion in assets, $73 billion is cash and equivalents and $295 billion are in investments. Those investments would need to fall in value by roughly 1/3 (very unlikely) to take out the stockholders first and then get to account holders.

Psychologically, if you feel much better diversifying your assets across multiple financial institutions, then do it. If you can’t sleep at night and excessively worry over having your investments in one place, diversify.

mdmurrell 09-13-2023 05:05 AM

Putting money in diversified investments
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by manaboutown (Post 2255821)
Recently I picked up a book by Charles Schwab, 'Invested'.

To say it was an eye opener is an understatement. It starts with why and how he got into discount brokerage as one of its pioneers. It then goes on to report the ups, downs and very scary times his company went through. I had no idea!

I know many people, particularly those who trade a lot, use Schwab. Although I have kept a small account at Schwab for years I rarely used it. Then last year and earlier this year I sold a couple commercial real estate properties and deposited the proceeds into Schwab, primarily because I wanted to put it into T-bills. Schwab allows a retail investor to buy and sell them whereas the other two brokerages where I have historically kept most of my securities do not.

Then, surprise, surprise, I started getting phone calls from a Schwab 'Advisor' which I ignored for a time. Eventually I returned a call just to let him know I existed. When he discovered I was not a newbie and had other accounts he urged, just short of insisted, I transfer them to Schwab. I declined and told him I had a pretty good memory and remember Lehman Bros. and others which he seemed to grasp. I thereafter discovered Schwab at that time held some long term treasuries which were destined to go down as interest were rising so I still feel a little skittish about it all.

Anyway after reading this book to sleep at night I feel I need to continue to keep my securities distributed among several wirehouses and wonder if others feel the same.

I have some investments in Schwab but prefer Vanguard as my primary. I follow Dan Weiner as an investment advisor. He is smart, knows alot about Vanguard and doesn't charge much.

Mrfriendly 09-13-2023 06:11 AM

Prior to China virus I interviewed Vanguard, Trowe Price, Fidelity and American Century to discuss consolidating my accounts I had with each. Went to the Big V mostly due to their low expenses and plenty of solid funds both Bonds and Stocks. Now holding on for a new US administration and market upturn

itsanne 09-13-2023 06:14 AM

I have just been transferred to Schwab from TD Ameritrade as of September 1st. So, no experience with them yet. I will keep roughly 50/50 between them and Fidelity. No institution is big enough not to fail as we have seen in the past.

Blackbird45 09-13-2023 06:26 AM

My view has always been that even though it is good to get advice from others, when it come to your finances, no one is going to track your money as well as you will. The only advice I would give is to sit down and decide what type of return you want from your investments.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:43 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.