We went there last night with a party of six. Everyone got something different and we all were satisfied with our choices. I think it's a nice addition to The Villages restaurants, even it's not quite within The Villages.

The Irish stew might be cold too. All my friends that ordered it, had to send it back. The kitchen is pretty slow too.

Skip

Split a pitcher of Yuengling Yuengling with a neighbor and it was on $6. Same for domestics, but they went the extra mile and including Y/Y. We
thoroughly enjoyed our dinner - meat loaf, chicken pot pie, reuben, and a burger! Boy was I full!!!

First negative post.............................after 77 positive posts. They will most likely stay open!

Cold Stew Too
 

Four us went Monday night for dinner. Our first time there. It was OK but would go elsewhere if I had a choice. My stew was cold and I did not like the look of a shamrock piped in sour cream on my stew (sent back to be nuked). That said, it did taste good. One person's fired haddock was so breaded and fried really dark and hard that she took the breading off and the fries looked overcooked. The potpie looked good and my friend said it was good. Hubby said the meatloaf was passable but would not order again. Can't comment on the beer as we had other drinks. Didn't notice if the kitchen was slow but it was pretty crowded at 6:30. We were seated with a reasonable wait and the food came out in a reasonable time. The print on the menu is very small. I wear glasses and it was hard for all of us at the table to read clearly. I think lighting has a lot to do with it as the place where we sat was a bit dark. The staff was very friendly and attentive. I hope the business does well and stays around and I am glad so many others like and return to the business. Just our first impressions.

Anyone know who the owners are?
Hopefully not an ex cop from the East Coast.
Some of the comments sound similar to a now closed Irish Pub in Orlando.

His name is Wayne and Mike is the GM

Where in Highland, NY? We too live in Highland and have a home in Sanibel.

I hear that there is live Irish music tonite at 7:30 Love it. Cinco de Mayo this weekend with great Mexican food and a special Mother's Day Menu. What's there not to like.

What does that mean ??????

I guess that means that someone didn't like an owner of a place in Orlando. Had a problem at my table, so I had a chance to meet the owner of O'Shea's the other night. Let me tell you, what a great guy. Really cares about the employees and the job they are doing. His name is Wayne and is from the Chicago area. Knows they are not perfect but trying to get better each day.

Love to see something other than a chain or "the usuals" making it here. Have been there, loved it, and will return.

Went there last night didn't like it food was cold and menu was very small couldn't read it even with glasses on...The waitress said they made mistake on them they have to change them and it was very noisey

Will have to put O'Shea's on my "must try list" when I get back to TV later on this month.

Yes, you definitely have to try it. Hopefully the word will spread & we'll have another awesome place to go to for a long time !!