Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   Restaurant Discussions (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/restaurant-discussions-90/)
-   -   New York Style Pizza (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/restaurant-discussions-90/new-york-style-pizza-294055/)

It's Hot There 06-27-2019 07:08 AM

Chicago, deep-dish pizza is the best.

:popcorn:

dewilson58 06-27-2019 07:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by It's Hot There (Post 1660491)
Chicago, deep-dish pizza is the best.

:popcorn:






:bigbow:

Chi-Town 06-27-2019 01:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by It's Hot There (Post 1660491)
Chicago, deep-dish pizza is the best.



:popcorn:

You are totally correct. But Chicago also has the best thin crust pizza, and one can be enjoyed at the Great Chicago Fire Brewery & Tap Room in Leesburg.

As far as pizza here in The Villages Giovanni's is good if you order double cheese.

Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk

dewilson58 06-27-2019 01:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chi-Town (Post 1660567)
You are totally correct. But Chicago also has the best thin crust pizza, and one can be enjoyed at the Great Chicago Fire Brewery & Tap Room in Leesburg.

As far as pizza here in The Villages Giovanni's is good if you order double cheese.

Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk




Lou.


Uno


Due

JSR22 06-27-2019 01:38 PM

Best pizza
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chi-Town (Post 1660567)
You are totally correct. But Chicago also has the best thin crust pizza, and one can be enjoyed at the Great Chicago Fire Brewery & Tap Room in Leesburg.

As far as pizza here in The Villages Giovanni's is good if you order double cheese.

Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk

It is all dependent on where you moved from. I am from NJ and went to College in Illinois. I did not like the deep dish pizza and dislike the the thin crust cut in squares. For me the best pizza is Bravos and I add salt and oregano. That is the closest tasting pizza from where I grew up. When dorm mates from Chicago came to visit in NJ they were not impressed with the pizza.

John_W 06-27-2019 02:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chi-Town (Post 1660567)
You are totally correct. But Chicago also has the best thin crust pizza, and one can be enjoyed at the Great Chicago Fire Brewery & Tap Room in Leesburg.

As far as pizza here in The Villages Giovanni's is good if you order double cheese.

Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk

I had a pizza last year at Chicago Fire in Leesburg and I agree, it's excellent. My only complaint was he only had one size, 12" which probably enough for one person, but not enough for two, and buying two is a little too much. He came on the message board and I asked about that and he said, he only has a small oven and that's the biggest he can bake.

Giovanni's is good, I agree also and it's very gooey and foldable. My favorite is at Sammy Joe's at Mulberry Plaza, it's thin, more like Chicago Fire and they have 14" and 16", we go every week or two.

MorTech 06-27-2019 02:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by It's Hot There (Post 1660491)
Chicago, deep-dish pizza is the best.

:popcorn:

Yup...Don't know why people bang on about NY pizza :)

Spikearoni 06-27-2019 03:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kerry Azz (Post 1660282)
Nothing like Regina’s pizza in the Norh End, then off to Modern pastries on Hanover Street.

You bet! We traveled there from NH and often stood in a line, outside, in frigid and windy weather to have Regina's pizza. It was worth the shivering!

Vladimir 06-27-2019 06:00 PM

Well, Sammy's Italian on rt 301 advertises a $8.99 special on Thursday and claim they have NYC authentic pizza. I'm from lower east side NYC so I just got the pizza pie and promptly threw it out.
The crust was thick and tasted like cardboard. The sauce was some sort of sweet spaghetti sauce mixture and the cheese was ugh!
Bellview pizza place is better than all others so far but I dont think I'll ever find good pizza in FL...I'll try the new place Robertos in Pinellas once it opens up

OrangeBlossomBaby 06-27-2019 06:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spikearoni (Post 1660598)
You bet! We traveled there from NH and often stood in a line, outside, in frigid and windy weather to have Regina's pizza. It was worth the shivering!

There was a place on the way to Regina, same side of the road, might've been called Frankie's or Franco's? Had kickass cannolis and robust espressos with lemon twists.

Had a friend who lived in the North End when we were in college together there. I asked her didn't she feel unsafe, living alone in the North End. She explained it was the safest place for a young unmarried woman to live. "Da Family" (the REAL ONE) kept "their own" safe. If you lived there and didn't make trouble for them, you were safe. Period.

Fine pizza too, Regina's was just the most famous but definitely not the only one on the street.

I've been to all the places IN the Villages that sells pizza and every single one of them is a joke compared to the New York/Boston/New Haven style.

The sauces are lackluster and some are actually sugary - they're not pizza sauce at all, I don't know what they are. Maybe Ragu, or some other equally nasty jarred crap. The thin crusts aren't really thin crusts, they're just thinner than the usual crusts, and not cooked properly. The thicker-crusted styles are gummy. They don't use fresh mozzarella, they use the prepackaged crap that turns to mush when heated. One place actually used a combination of shredded American cheese, Mozarella, and mild Cheddar. It was disgusting. They use oregano from huge plastic jars that probably came from Costco/Sam's/BJ's that was harvested 4 years ago and has been sitting in a jar ever since. I don't think any of them would know fresh basil if they fell into a garden of it.

I haven't been to a pizzeria near the Villages that wasn't actually in the Villages yet, but we'll be checking out a couple of the suggestions here soon.

pauld315 06-27-2019 06:57 PM

I don't think it will be NY Style but people here are going to be very happy when Piesano's opens down on 44. They have a restaurant in Ocala that we have been to and they are very good. They will definitely have the bet pizza around here.

Unfortunately, it will be very hard to get into once they do open since that area is a food oasis and now they will actually have a very good restaurant there.

Rrgolf 06-27-2019 09:43 PM

Not..NY pizza

Chi-Town 06-28-2019 08:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John_W (Post 1660580)
I had a pizza last year at Chicago Fire in Leesburg and I agree, it's excellent. My only complaint was he only had one size, 12" which probably enough for one person, but not enough for two, and buying two is a little too much. He came on the message board and I asked about that and he said, he only has a small oven and that's the biggest he can bake.



Giovanni's is good, I agree also and it's very gooey and foldable. My favorite is at Sammy Joe's at Mulberry Plaza, it's thin, more like Chicago Fire and they have 14" and 16", we go every week or two.

You're right, the 12" pizza won't feed two hungry people. Best to share a menu item while waiting for the pizza to come out. And if you have leftover slices they are great the next day.

I'll have to try Sammy Joe's. Thanks for the tip.

Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk

Topspinmo 06-28-2019 02:39 PM

Florida has pizza? Could of fooled me! Not what I call it. Pretty sad when you’re are looking for little Cesar’s for pizza. I find frozen sams club 5 meat pizza doctored up and cooked at home is the best pizza I can find around here.

Bobbyrosebowl 06-28-2019 07:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RAAndre (Post 1659980)
Could not find decent "Northeast" style pizza in the villages. Good pizza not only comes from New York, but add New England to the region that knows good pizza - Boston, Providence, New Haven . . . name it.
Now, where is the best pizza and Italian food in this area? In my Northend Boston opinion go to Belleview Pizza up in Belleview. It's the best we have found. BOGO PASTA DINNERS 3 -5 weekdays!
WARNING: Doesn't open until 3PM. CASH ONLY!

I am from Chicago. Our thin crust beats anything in the Northeast. Not even close.

JSR22 06-28-2019 07:18 PM

No
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobbyrosebowl (Post 1660844)
I am from Chicago. Our thin crust beats anything in the Northeast. Not even close.

I am from NJ and went to college in IL. I still remember how awful IL pizza was.

Nucky 06-28-2019 09:08 PM

Sammy Joe's gets Eight and a half Stars outta 10 Stars. Big Bob's Pizzeria & Restaurant 12909 E Highway 25, Ocklawaha, FL 32179-5115 352-288-4200 gets 9 and a half Stars outta 10 Stars. It's about 9 miles past the Main Post Office and the outside of it tempted us to not go in but I certainly glad we did.

I was talking to the Owner and asked him Why the Hell Did You Name This Place Bob's? Why not Vito, Rocco's? He said my name is Bob! You won't be disappointed. The place is in a small strip mall with a couple of abandoned Gas Pumps out front. Not beautiful outside but inside its O.K. but the food is GREAT!

John_W 06-29-2019 08:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nucky (Post 1660868)
Sammy Joe's gets Eight and a half Stars outta 10 Stars. Big Bob's Pizzeria & Restaurant 12909 E Highway 25, Ocklawaha, FL 32179-5115 352-288-4200 gets 9 and a half Stars outta 10 Stars. It's about 9 miles past the Main Post Office and the outside of it tempted us to not go in but I certainly glad we did.

I was talking to the Owner and asked him Why the Hell Did You Name This Place Bob's? Why not Vito, Rocco's? He said my name is Bob! You won't be disappointed. The place is in a small strip mall with a couple of abandoned Gas Pumps out front. Not beautiful outside but inside its O.K. but the food is GREAT!

On Yelp they have a lot of info about Big Bob's. You gave them a 1/2 star more than Sammy Joe's, I'll try it if I get up that way. Although the photos look a lot thicker than Sammy Joe's, more NY style. At SJ you can tell them to make it to the edge, and you'll get no crust, just all pizza. Bob's looks really nice, much nicer than Sammy Joe's.

https://s3-media4.fl.yelpcdn.com/bph...yL6LbI2A/o.jpg

https://s3-media1.fl.yelpcdn.com/bph...AaLbqybg/o.jpg

Big Bob’s Italian Restaurant and Pizza - 32 Photos & 36 Reviews - Pizza - 12909 E Hwy 25, Ocklawaha, FL - Restaurant Reviews - Phone Number - Yelp

Nucky 06-29-2019 10:36 AM

Great job with the pictures John W. I guess they are going to be busy tonight. We were headed there last night when the skies opened up. Momma suggested we stay home. Yes Dear, DiGiorno that fine Dear! Maybe today or tomorrow. Can't wait!

graciegirl 08-20-2019 11:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jazuela (Post 1660616)
There was a place on the way to Regina, same side of the road, might've been called Frankie's or Franco's? Had kickass cannolis and robust espressos with lemon twists.

Had a friend who lived in the North End when we were in college together there. I asked her didn't she feel unsafe, living alone in the North End. She explained it was the safest place for a young unmarried woman to live. "Da Family" (the REAL ONE) kept "their own" safe. If you lived there and didn't make trouble for them, you were safe. Period.

Fine pizza too, Regina's was just the most famous but definitely not the only one on the street.

I've been to all the places IN the Villages that sells pizza and every single one of them is a joke compared to the New York/Boston/New Haven style.

The sauces are lackluster and some are actually sugary - they're not pizza sauce at all, I don't know what they are. Maybe Ragu, or some other equally nasty jarred crap. The thin crusts aren't really thin crusts, they're just thinner than the usual crusts, and not cooked properly. The thicker-crusted styles are gummy. They don't use fresh mozzarella, they use the prepackaged crap that turns to mush when heated. One place actually used a combination of shredded American cheese, Mozarella, and mild Cheddar. It was disgusting. They use oregano from huge plastic jars that probably came from Costco/Sam's/BJ's that was harvested 4 years ago and has been sitting in a jar ever since. I don't think any of them would know fresh basil if they fell into a garden of it.

I haven't been to a pizzeria near the Villages that wasn't actually in the Villages yet, but we'll be checking out a couple of the suggestions here soon.

Ricciardi's?

Shimpy 08-20-2019 05:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John_W (Post 1660112)
The lady that owns the place also just recently sold her other restaurant Son Rise Cafe to Darrels, so now she has been adding more items to the menu.

https://static.wixstatic.com/media/1...1cd75~mv2.webp

I truly miss her "Son Rise Cafe" since I ate breakfast there at least once a week.

600th Photo Sq 08-20-2019 07:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by capecoralbill (Post 1659991)
I tried NYPD Pizza on 466, just east of 301, it is the 2nd worst pizza i have ever eaten. First worst was Jerry's in Mt Pleasant Ia in 1968.

NYPD Pizza is a chain...and honestly, they should be arrested for impersonating NYPD... It is TERRIBLE !!

Cuff them " Dan O "

Northwoods 08-20-2019 08:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mikeod (Post 1660037)

:bigbow:

Yung Dum 08-20-2019 10:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aw Man (Post 1659985)
Have you tried NYPD Pizza on 446, just east of 301?
They have Sicilian thick crust pie AND ALSO have New York style hand-tossed, thin crust pie baked in a stone oven. The thin crust folds nicely for a nice big bite.

Also, did you know that you can order thin crust pizza at Giovanni's Ristorante a little farther east on 446?
You have to ask for the thin crust as their normal pizza has a thicker non-foldable crust. The thin crust style folds nicely and has what I think is a pretty good mix of sauce and cheese.

You've got to be kidding.

Chatbrat 08-21-2019 06:26 AM

If the crust can be folded over, you're half way there--IMHO, Chicago deep dish pizza is not a pizza its a casserole, would you call a chicken pot pie covered in Italian red sauce a pizza ?

BK001 08-21-2019 10:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chatbrat (Post 1660134)
Chain restaurant pizza is the pits--From Domino's , down--its only good when your stuck on a road trip & they're the only show in town-we had to eat it when we got back to our hotel after riding the Durango narrow gauge steam train

I couldn't agree with you more. However, like you, we were in a bind and ordered a thin-crust marinara pizza from Papa John's and found it to be "the cream of the crap".

Nonni252 08-21-2019 03:36 PM

Bravo!!! in Sumter Landing has fantastic pizza. It's foldable, has a thin crust and just the right amount of oil on the top. We ate there twice in our very short visit to TV to look at homes. There's a good selection of toppings including a white pie (my favorite) and Sicilian style also. Complimentary garlic knots with marinara while you're waiting is a nice touch.

Chatbrat 08-21-2019 03:41 PM

Far from fantastic, its OK, unless you've experience a real coal fired pizza like Tortonno's in Brooklyn, or a pizza like Grimaldi's--there is no comparison

When we lived in Cary,NC--Bella Mia was just as good--they sold the business--it failed--its now A World of Beer

Nonni252 08-21-2019 03:45 PM

We're originally from NY and NJ and we've had the best of the best including most pizzerias in NYC's Little Italy (in the old days.) It's always a personal thing when it comes to taste but I definitely recommend Bravo!!!

Chatbrat 08-21-2019 03:50 PM

Glad you enjoyed

JSR22 08-21-2019 03:52 PM

I am from NJ and I really like Bravo's pizza crisp.

Nonni252 08-21-2019 10:17 PM

...

Northwoods 08-22-2019 10:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nonni252 (Post 1675169)
North, if you read my comments you would know that I was not complaining I was raving. Raving is a good thing. It's like a recommendation and a recommendation can lead to someone trying a new place and liking it! I'd say when that happens, something has changed ... for the better ... and that's a good thing too. There are threads on the message board that don't interest me so I don't read them but as long as other posters are posting on those threads, they serve a purpose and I'm happy for the residents who enjoy their discussions. I hope you continue to enjoy the posts that interest you and don't let the ones that aren't of any interest to you, bother you so much.

??? Not sure what you are talking about. I just reposted a "cartoon" about New Yorkers complaining about pizza. I don't believe I quoted any post.

Nonni252 08-22-2019 10:47 PM

North, a few posts after the cartoon there was a post by your name that said most people are tired of the complaining about the different pizzas, that nothing ever changes and that most people aren't interested in the topic anyway. For some reason that post is no longer there, so no wonder you didn't know what I was referring to in my post.

PugMom 11-07-2019 09:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gatorbill1 (Post 1659964)
Can't get NY pizza in FLA - just people who say they have NY pizza

Pasiano's!!:MOJE_whot:

Pinball wizard 11-07-2019 12:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rjm1cc (Post 1659974)
Try Sammy's Italian

Address: 9668 N, US-301, Wildwood, FL 34785

IMHO Sammy's is the best. He's from Brooklyn and is pie is great. The rest of the food there is good too! Get the garlic knots.

Kerry Azz 11-08-2019 07:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RAAndre (Post 1659980)
Could not find decent "Northeast" style pizza in the villages. Good pizza not only comes from New York, but add New England to the region that knows good pizza - Boston, Providence, New Haven . . . name it.
Now, where is the best pizza and Italian food in this area? In my Northend Boston opinion go to Belleview Pizza up in Belleview. It's the best we have found. BOGO PASTA DINNERS 3 -5 weekdays!
WARNING: Doesn't open until 3PM. CASH ONLY!

Reginas in the North End serves the best pizza in the country! And there’s always Louie Juice available something only a true Bostonian would know. If i want good pizza here in the villages I start with making the dough myself.

B-flat 11-08-2019 08:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kerry Azz (Post 1693810)
Reginas in the North End serves the best pizza in the country! And there’s always Louie Juice available something only a true Bostonian would know. If i want good pizza here in the villages I start with making the dough myself.

Good point, love Regina have been there many times, years back that was one of our first stops when visiting Quincy Market/Fanuiel hall. Oh yea and Belleview is very good too.

mikemalloy 11-08-2019 04:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheWarriors (Post 1660043)
Good pizza is like a good woman, everyone has different tastes, thank God 😆

Though woman are different the all taste good to me. Of course if they're with me the have bad taste.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:24 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.