Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   Restaurant Discussions (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/restaurant-discussions-90/)
-   -   Outback Steakhouse Wildwood (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/restaurant-discussions-90/outback-steakhouse-wildwood-358571/)

bsloan1960 05-07-2025 09:36 AM

Beginning 15 years ago we'd go often- always a GREAT meal. We stopped going for a while, and when we began to go again 5 years ago the food was awful- like what you'd expect from a Chain that figured out how to maximize profit and minimize quality. I'm not at all surprised that people are reporting underwhelming food there.
Quote:

Originally Posted by DBaty (Post 2429866)
We had dinner there last Saturday evening around 7:30. It was a terrible experience. I ordered an 18 ounce bone-in ribeye ($32). The steak I received had a bone of no more than 2 inches and at least a third of the steak was a big blob of fat. When I asked for the manager, I was told "ok, we will get you another one." No apology. The replacement steak that I received looked like a bone-in ribeye but was only about 1/2 thick and also had a huge blob of fat - almost 4 inches in diameter. And the steak had little flavor. It was worse than a cheap breakfast steak you get at a low quality diner. And then the service. It too was terrible. We ordered drinks from our waiter. Three of the 4 drinks arrived via another server. We told him one of the drinks was omitted. About 10 minutes later, I summoned a bus boy and asked for our waiter because we were missing a drink. The drink arrived about 10 minutes later, just before our meals were served. Then we never saw our waiter again until he brought the check. I am forgiving on challenged service when a restaurant is real busy, I can excuse substandard service. But the place was only about 3/4 full. Overall an unacceptable experience and a "never return."


retiredguy123 05-07-2025 09:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Risuli (Post 2430100)
USDA Prime? I've yet to see prime cuts at Publix. They have only been USDA Choice.

This brings up a question I've had since moving here a couple of years ago. With all the cattle raised in and around the Villages, why are there no actual butcher shops to be found? Closest thing to a butcher shop is Fresh Market but nothing else.

I buy USDA Prime filet mignons at Publix. I shop at the Colony Plaza store often, and when they have them (usually 2-3 times per week), I buy them and freeze them. I never run out.

I have checked all of the high end restaurant menus in the area, and none of them sell a USDA Prime filet mignon, except Ruth Chris. This includes Chophouse, Mark's, and Prime 3.

Aces4 05-07-2025 09:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Risuli (Post 2430100)
USDA Prime? I've yet to see prime cuts at Publix. They have only been USDA Choice.

This brings up a question I've had since moving here a couple of years ago. With all the cattle raised in and around the Villages, why are there no actual butcher shops to be found? Closest thing to a butcher shop is Fresh Market but nothing else.

To butcher what, Florida beef? I wouldn't waste my time, personally, it's just not the same quality.

jimhoward 05-07-2025 10:08 AM

Amongst the big chain Steak Houses, I think Ruth Chris and Capital grill are equally good. But they are 35 miles+ away. A prime bone-in ribeye costs about $89 ala carte. You might then add a salad and some sides and a drink.

The villages is a working class retirement community. Putting aside occasions, people mostly go to dinner where the prices are cheap. I know I do. Restaurants sell the lowest possible quality steaks, and season them so you can't taste the meat anyway. They operate with minimal staff. But they sell steaks for only $32. So we go.

Once in a while a pleasant surprise happens and the meal is great, not usually.

elle123 05-08-2025 05:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DBaty (Post 2429866)
We had dinner there last Saturday evening around 7:30. It was a terrible experience. I ordered an 18 ounce bone-in ribeye ($32). The steak I received had a bone of no more than 2 inches and at least a third of the steak was a big blob of fat. When I asked for the manager, I was told "ok, we will get you another one." No apology. The replacement steak that I received looked like a bone-in ribeye but was only about 1/2 thick and also had a huge blob of fat - almost 4 inches in diameter. And the steak had little flavor. It was worse than a cheap breakfast steak you get at a low quality diner. And then the service. It too was terrible. We ordered drinks from our waiter. Three of the 4 drinks arrived via another server. We told him one of the drinks was omitted. About 10 minutes later, I summoned a bus boy and asked for our waiter because we were missing a drink. The drink arrived about 10 minutes later, just before our meals were served. Then we never saw our waiter again until he brought the check. I am forgiving on challenged service when a restaurant is real busy, I can excuse substandard service. But the place was only about 3/4 full. Overall an unacceptable experience and a "never return."

What do you expect--it's Outback. No one who demands a good piece of meat and attentive service would eat there.

RustyandEthel 05-08-2025 05:38 AM

This is probably what happened in the kitchen.

https://youtu.be/SKi1-e8R9RA?si=wuMWX40Ku--BpS77

Michael 61 05-08-2025 06:54 AM

Grilling your own will generally always deliver far superior results to what you get in most restaurants. (And will be much more economical ). I will rarely order a steak when dining out.

paulajr 05-08-2025 07:03 AM

Ribeye
 
Ribeye ALWAYS is a fatty cut…


Quote:

Originally Posted by DBaty (Post 2429866)
We had dinner there last Saturday evening around 7:30. It was a terrible experience. I ordered an 18 ounce bone-in ribeye ($32). The steak I received had a bone of no more than 2 inches and at least a third of the steak was a big blob of fat. When I asked for the manager, I was told "ok, we will get you another one." No apology. The replacement steak that I received looked like a bone-in ribeye but was only about 1/2 thick and also had a huge blob of fat - almost 4 inches in diameter. And the steak had little flavor. It was worse than a cheap breakfast steak you get at a low quality diner. And then the service. It too was terrible. We ordered drinks from our waiter. Three of the 4 drinks arrived via another server. We told him one of the drinks was omitted. About 10 minutes later, I summoned a bus boy and asked for our waiter because we were missing a drink. The drink arrived about 10 minutes later, just before our meals were served. Then we never saw our waiter again until he brought the check. I am forgiving on challenged service when a restaurant is real busy, I can excuse substandard service. But the place was only about 3/4 full. Overall an unacceptable experience and a "never return."


paulajr 05-08-2025 07:05 AM

Beef
 
We purchase all of our quality beef at HM Cattle in Webster. Order online and pick up Saturday at Brownwood. Delicious!



Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 2430109)
I buy USDA Prime filet mignons at Publix. I shop at the Colony Plaza store often, and when they have them (usually 2-3 times per week), I buy them and freeze them. I never run out.

I have checked all of the high end restaurant menus in the area, and none of them sell a USDA Prime filet mignon, except Ruth Chris. This includes Chophouse, Mark's, and Prime 3.


PhilR 05-08-2025 07:20 AM

Charley’s does a nice job. Berns, if you’re up for scheduling 2 mos out

merrymini 05-08-2025 07:47 AM

Outback is ixnay. Way too spicy and salty. A fine steak should never taste that way.

JRcorvette 05-08-2025 07:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DBaty (Post 2429866)
We had dinner there last Saturday evening around 7:30. It was a terrible experience. I ordered an 18 ounce bone-in ribeye ($32). The steak I received had a bone of no more than 2 inches and at least a third of the steak was a big blob of fat. When I asked for the manager, I was told "ok, we will get you another one." No apology. The replacement steak that I received looked like a bone-in ribeye but was only about 1/2 thick and also had a huge blob of fat - almost 4 inches in diameter. And the steak had little flavor. It was worse than a cheap breakfast steak you get at a low quality diner. And then the service. It too was terrible. We ordered drinks from our waiter. Three of the 4 drinks arrived via another server. We told him one of the drinks was omitted. About 10 minutes later, I summoned a bus boy and asked for our waiter because we were missing a drink. The drink arrived about 10 minutes later, just before our meals were served. Then we never saw our waiter again until he brought the check. I am forgiving on challenged service when a restaurant is real busy, I can excuse substandard service. But the place was only about 3/4 full. Overall an unacceptable experience and a "never return."

We have eaten there twice and had a good meal and service. One bad experience should never preclude you from going back but that is your choice.

Stu from NYC 05-08-2025 08:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRcorvette (Post 2430308)
We have eaten there twice and had a good meal and service. One bad experience should never preclude you from going back but that is your choice.

Generally will agree but every once in awhile a restaurant out does itself in making me a former customer.

Driller703 05-08-2025 08:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DBaty (Post 2429866)
We had dinner there last Saturday evening around 7:30. It was a terrible experience. I ordered an 18 ounce bone-in ribeye ($32). The steak I received had a bone of no more than 2 inches and at least a third of the steak was a big blob of fat. When I asked for the manager, I was told "ok, we will get you another one." No apology. The replacement steak that I received looked like a bone-in ribeye but was only about 1/2 thick and also had a huge blob of fat - almost 4 inches in diameter. And the steak had little flavor. It was worse than a cheap breakfast steak you get at a low quality diner. And then the service. It too was terrible. We ordered drinks from our waiter. Three of the 4 drinks arrived via another server. We told him one of the drinks was omitted. About 10 minutes later, I summoned a bus boy and asked for our waiter because we were missing a drink. The drink arrived about 10 minutes later, just before our meals were served. Then we never saw our waiter again until he brought the check. I am forgiving on challenged service when a restaurant is real busy, I can excuse substandard service. But the place was only about 3/4 full. Overall an unacceptable experience and a "never return."

So I need to know this why?

Sandy and Ed 05-08-2025 08:49 AM

Wife an I went @ 3pm and sat at bar. Ordered a medium sized strip with baked potato. Not bad. Barkeep knew how to make a great perfect gin martini served up with olives. Not crowded and service was good. We try never to go to a dinner during regular hours in the crazy snowbird season.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:50 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.