I don't agree with the ordering, and there are others I would put higher on the list, but I've been to six of these and would/do go back plus three more I have heard are good but haven't made it to yet.

Especially since the Lady Lake PD station is on the way there.

I like this thread because I like limiting the choices to golf cart accessible. In eight years owning a home in the Villages we have only eaten outside the bubble using our car once. Everyone’s list reflects their unique tastes and mine is no exception, focusing on places that serve fish/seafood or have low carb choices.
1) Sakura (Shushi take-out)
2) Costal Del Mar
3) BLUE Fin
4) Bone Fish
5) Lopez Legacy
6) Chop House
7) Ay Jalisco
8) Naldos
9) Island Fin Polk
10) RJ Gators (always get the She Crab soup and blackened fish with rice and beans)
Honorable mention - Americanos, Back Porch, Edna’s, Tropical Smoothie, Fenney Grill
Bummed they closed - Crispers, Demshires
Totally dropped off list over the years - Lighthouse, VKI
Worst ever - Augustine’s 1812 (now closed) and Sawgrass
Looking forward - New FMK restaurant in Spanish Springs

I’m sure there are other good places we haven’t been to including the other FMK run restaurants and Country Clubs.

Stop taking short cuts in neighborhoods going to SS. Take Rio Grande to left at delmar to downtown. We dint need 3 cars per minute past our houses. Not needed.stop

For those that mentioned Trip advisor - I just did the same thing on that site - sorted by highest rated - Here is their top ten, very different list:

1) Red Sauce
2) Legacy - Nancy Lopez CC
3) Glenview CC
4) Square 1
5) Amerikanos
6) Cane Garden CC
7) Johnny Rockets
8) Bonefish
9) VKI
10) Thai Ruby

Wow very surprised.

In no particular order

Kungfoo
Havana
Napolinos

Yelp claims they don't manipulate reviews.

That said, a Federal Court has ruled the have the right to favor those who advertise on Yelp.

If they don't do it, I wonder why they bothered to defend against the court action?

Court Rules Yelp Can Manipulate Reviews

I've only been in TV for 2 years, but I've tried every restaurant in the squares and most around TV.

The best meal I've had in TV was at Augustine's 1812.

The worst meal I've ever had in Florida, was at Lighthouse.

I don't know who had the idea to give FMK a virtual monopoly in TV, but they've managed to bring TV food to a new low. I'm amazed they stay in business.

Naldo’s is now Tequila Cantina. New menu too.

I'm a fan of Poke and was happy to see them open. Food is fresh and delicious. Not much ambiance though. More like a fast food atmosphere. We always take it to go...

Bummer, haven’t been there since early May. Used to really like the crab quesadillas that Naldo’s had : (
That location can’t stay constant, first lost Crispers, which we really liked, and now Naldo’s. Looks like we are back to Ay Jalisco as the go to Mexican joint.

I have to agree about Lighthouse - I went there twice last year on my lifestyle visits and wasn’t impressed either time. I decided to return this week, as I read the owners are going to try and improve the place after selling Augustine’s. It was even worse than I remember. I really want to like this place, as it has a great location and view. I just wish they would “up’ their game with their menu and quality of seafood, this place could be the “jewel” of the villages.

Reviews
 

This is a good place to find reviews. The Villages Gourmet Club Restaurant Review Site There are 900 restaurants reviewed. You can click the link for only The Villages to shorten the list.

I agree the TV Gourmet Club website is extensive and only members (must be a Village residents) can post. There's no anonymous reviews or general comments like "Great Place 5 Star" like you see on Yelp, Trip Advisor and Google. This site is a lot more unbiased and believable. We use it a lot.

Skip

This is great - I’ll check it out for sure