I think they are both great. Both deserve to win. Scotty however will win IMHO. He will get the tween teen vote. There are a lot of them.

C

I guess its just me, but I found last night's showing to be boring. It could be that I'm just not a big country or ballad fan. I thought James & Haley were much more interesting & entertaining- I wish those two were in the finale instead of Lauren & Scotty.

I have to admit I agree. They would have been much more exciting. I guess we're not the majority demographic for Idol.

We are definitely pulling for Scotty to win.

I second that

I hope Scotty wins, I do think the judges have been biased towards Lauren, though she's good too.

Scotty!!!!!

I would have been happy with any of the top 3. Jame's heavy metal is a real turn off for me and we fast forwarded through his appearance with Judas Priest.

Yeah Scotty. Good final show. Love, love, love Steven Tyler! Dream on!

Yay Scotty. Good choice America! I thought the final show was entertaining.

IMO, that was a very entertaining final show. Thanks goodness for DVR and fast forward, I cannot imagine watching all of those commercials.

I may be off base here, but did Lauren and Scotty seem to be a bit closer than simply friends in a competition? Nothing wrong with that of course, and maybe nothing there but nervous energy, but .....

we got it on t.v. last night. I too taped and fast forwarded all adds, lucky we do not get as many in England as in the US, but we do get enough :laugh:
I am glad Scotty was the winner, I picked him from the start :wave:
We also thought the young 'uns were a bit friendlier as well L O L :wave: