Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   The Villages, Florida, General Discussion (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/)
-   -   Does anyone know the voltage of the power lines running through Chitty Chatty? (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/does-anyone-know-voltage-power-lines-running-through-chitty-chatty-338911/)

BrianL 02-11-2023 02:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Goldwingnut (Post 2185658)
Nope, Edison lost, Tesla proved that AC was the better power delivery method - less line losses, greater transmission distances, and transformer action allows easy adjustment of voltage - higher or lower as needed. Very very few transmission lines in the USA or anywhere else in the world are DC.

The lines going through Chitty Chatty are most likely 34.5KV, this line is the major feeder to all of the south end of Sumter County.

Within the United States, High-Voltage long distance lines are typically DC running anywhere from 100 kV to 800kV. It is not obvious as to the type of transmission used within Sumter County. The obversion that the large round ceramic insulators are 10 kV insulators is correct. So if you have 10 of these, it will be a 100 kV line; however, that doesn't determine if it's AC or DC. There are excellent reasons for DC in power transmission, you can read about them in wikipedia. If there are more than 4 ceramic insulators, the lines are unlikely to be 34.5 kV lines. Power line transmission is substantially different than local power distribution. The only way to really know the voltage of the lines would be to contact SECO, provided that the transmission lines going through the are even SECO lines. They would likely know the correct answer to the question regardless of the actual owner of the lines.

CoachKandSportsguy 02-11-2023 02:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BrianL (Post 2186301)
Within the United States, High-Voltage long distance lines are typically DC running anywhere from 100 kV to 800kV. It is not obvious as to the type of transmission used within Sumter County. The obversion that the large round ceramic insulators are 10 kV insulators is correct. So if you have 10 of these, it will be a 100 kV line; however, that doesn't determine if it's AC or DC. There are excellent reasons for DC in power transmission, you can read about them in wikipedia. If there are more than 4 ceramic insulators, the lines are unlikely to be 34.5 kV lines. Power line transmission is substantially different than local power distribution. The only way to really know the voltage of the lines would be to contact SECO, provided that the transmission lines going through the are even SECO lines. They would likely know the correct answer to the question regardless of the actual owner of the lines.

SECO is a distribution company, not a transmission company, so they may know. The govt ruled to prevent vertical integration of the industry. FP&L is the assumed generation company. However, the utility industry is classified as a CNI industry. Critical National Infrastructure and as such, certain physical properties are only on a need to know basis, even within the company.

villagetinker 02-11-2023 02:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BrianL (Post 2186301)
Within the United States, High-Voltage long distance lines are typically DC running anywhere from 100 kV to 800kV. It is not obvious as to the type of transmission used within Sumter County. The obversion that the large round ceramic insulators are 10 kV insulators is correct. So if you have 10 of these, it will be a 100 kV line; however, that doesn't determine if it's AC or DC. There are excellent reasons for DC in power transmission, you can read about them in wikipedia. If there are more than 4 ceramic insulators, the lines are unlikely to be 34.5 kV lines. Power line transmission is substantially different than local power distribution. The only way to really know the voltage of the lines would be to contact SECO, provided that the transmission lines going through the are even SECO lines. They would likely know the correct answer to the question regardless of the actual owner of the lines.

This is SO WRONG I do not know where to start, but here goes.
DC in the very few places it exists use TWO (2) sets of conductors, NOT 3, all of these lines are AC and are 3 phase. Those with ONE conductor per phase are 230 kV or less, those with two conductors per phase are typically 500 kV. I am not familiar with line designs for 345 kV AC so this would also be possibility for the lines with 2 conductors per phase.

As noted in the previous reply there are VERY FEW DC links in the US, and the few that exist are typically between the large east, west and Texas interconnects. DC links do not have frequency constraints and can control power flow through the inverters at each end.

As for those of you expressing concerns about living close to these lines, there have been many studies over the last few decades on this, with results indicating very low to NO effects.

Also, the one or 2 smaller conductors at the very top of the towers are 'static' or lightning protection lines and do not carry any voltage and very low current.

I found a map of these lines, and I was able to confirm they all terminate in AC only substations.

I was a senior staff engineer/scientist in the electric power industry with over 40 years experience, and 33 years of that in the design of these facilities.

AZ SLIM 02-11-2023 04:41 PM

Grandma was right
 
Like my Grandma said, "You fool, don't stick your tongue on that!"

DDToto41 02-11-2023 10:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CoachKandSportsguy (Post 2185652)
and believe it or not, its DC current, not AC. .

and its about 10KV per porcelain suspension insulators. . .

coachk's father worked on the substations in the power industry. .
so she whipped that statistic out.

sportsguy

There are no DC power lines. The reason for AC power lines is that there is resistance in the wires and the further the voltage travels the more power is lost (the voltage is lowered) to the resistance, therefore the AC is put through a transformer to bring the voltage back to the original voltage. Back when Edison and Westinghouse powered two different cities, one with AC (Westinghouse) and DC (Edison) they found out that AC was the more practical current to use because the DC would lose its value the farther away it was from the Generator.

DDToto41 02-11-2023 11:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DDToto41 (Post 2186447)
There are no DC power lines. The reason for AC power lines is that there is resistance in the wires and the further the voltage travels the more power is lost (the voltage is lowered) to the resistance, therefore the AC is put through a transformer to bring the voltage back to the original voltage. Back when Edison and Westinghouse powered two different cities, one with AC (Westinghouse) and DC (Edison) they found out that AC was the more practical current to use because the DC would lose its value the farther away it was from the Generator.

Sorry that was Tesla not Westinghouse. I believe that he started Westinghouse and Edison started GE.

RICH1 02-12-2023 05:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fused Glass (Post 2186086)
And buy near the turnpike

I can hear the guys kissing at the Coleman prison

RICH1 02-12-2023 05:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JMintzer (Post 2185651)
"Whatever it takes... ":a20:

Not many remember that movie… Michael Keaton was great!

CoachKandSportsguy 02-12-2023 10:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DDToto41 (Post 2186447)
There are no DC power lines. The reason for AC power lines is that there is resistance in the wires and the further the voltage travels the more power is lost (the voltage is lowered) to the resistance, therefore the AC is put through a transformer to bring the voltage back to the original voltage. Back when Edison and Westinghouse powered two different cities, one with AC (Westinghouse) and DC (Edison) they found out that AC was the more practical current to use because the DC would lose its value the farther away it was from the Generator.

Read VillageTinkers reply, there are a few, long distance, and we have at least one in the NE from Canada, the substation is in the town next to us, and the transmission corridor is adjacent to my parents' house. and its confirmed DC from Canada from the engineers in my company who built the receiving end distribution station of the Quebec hydro electric supply into the NE.

so its not a black and white There are no DC power lines. And I tried to connect with the transmission engineers in my company on Friday, but they were out of the office for the day.

but i still love the discussions here as its a perfect display of human behavior and biases in action.

fishon 02-12-2023 04:37 PM

The top wire is called “shield” the duplex conductors are called “double circuits”. Probably 475 lines. Kv has oddball multiples.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:49 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.